skip to main content
Columbine Could Cast Long Shadow Over 2000 Election

Columbine Could Cast Long Shadow Over 2000 Election

GALLUP NEWS SERVICE

PRINCETON, NJ -- The 1992 Clinton campaign motto "It's the economy, stupid," could be redefined for the upcoming 2000 presidential election in terms of the youth issues emanating from the Columbine High School shooting rampage. Of thirteen different issues tested in a recent Gallup Poll election survey, the quality of public education and "the problems of raising children in today's culture" rank as the two most important voting issues for Americans. Over forty percent of respondents in Gallup's June 4-5 survey say the candidates' stands on these issues will be a top priority for them in deciding whom to support for president.

Women seem to be especially concerned about the quality of public education, with 47% of women rating it a top priority, compared to 38% of men. However, men and women are about equally likely to cite the problems of raising children, with 43% of men and 40% of women saying a candidate's stand on this issue will be a top priority in their vote choice.

Interestingly, the other key issue raised by the Columbine shooting -- gun laws -- ranks much further down Americans' list of issue priorities, with just one-quarter rating it a top priority. Other issues rated more important than gun laws include the economy, Social Security and Medicare policy, health care costs, the rate of violent crime, the availability of good jobs, and the amount Americans pay in federal taxes.

The four issues ranked at the bottom of the list are mentioned by less than one-quarter of the public as being top priorities in their presidential vote. These include the situation in Kosovo, race relations, abortion policy and, lastly, campaign finance reform.

Education as Perennial Top Issue
Education's current positioning as a top election issue for Americans may not be a direct reflection of public reaction to the teen shooting at the Littleton, Colorado high school. This item, described as "the quality of education in public schools through grade 12" also emerged as the number one issue in a Gallup survey taken during the 1996 presidential election. At that time 44% rated education as their top priority, compared to 42% today. Even in 1992, using a slightly different wording, education emerged as the number two election issue for Americans, just behind the economy.

While education seems to be a perennial public concern, the high score received by the related item, "the problems of raising children in today's culture" -- 41% in the latest poll -- indicates the degree to which America's youth are currently on the minds of voters. The fact that these two issues outrank traditional campaign behemoths such as the economy, crime, and Social Security could cause candidates to adjust their focus accordingly. The Columbine tragedy certainly gives candidates a subject around which to organize this focus.

Taxes Play Better Than Education Among Republicans
While education emerges as a critical voting issue among Americans as a whole, this is largely driven by concern for the issue among Democratic and independent voters, among whom 50% and 46%, respectively, rate it a top issue. Republicans are much less likely to consider it highly important to their vote, with only 28% rating it as a top issue for them.

The number one issue among Republicans is the problems of raising children, mentioned by 43%, followed by "the amount Americans pay in taxes," mentioned by 39%. By contrast, taxes is rated a top issue by only 21% of independents and 22% of Democrats.

Jobs, Health Care and Gun Laws of Greater Interest to Democrats
Just as taxes finds a relatively strong constituency among Republicans, certain social issues are rated especially highly as election issues by Democrats. These include health care, considered a top priority by 40% of Democrats, the availability of good jobs, receiving 39%, and gun laws, with 32%. These issues are more than ten percentage points lower among Republicans: 28% for health care, 26% for jobs and 20% for gun laws.

The results below are based on telephone interviews with a randomly selected national sample of approximately 525 adults, 18 years and older, conducted June 4-5, 1999. (The entire sample contained 1,053 national adults; items on this list were asked of a random half-sample of that total.) For results based on this sample, one can say with 95% confidence that the maximum error attributable to sampling and other random effects is plus or minus 4 percentage points. In addition to sampling error, question wording and practical difficulties in conducting surveys can introduce error or bias into the findings of public opinion polls.

Next, I'm going to read a list which includes some national issues and some problems facing Americans today. For each one, please tell me how important a candidate's position on that issue is to you personally in deciding which candidate you will support for president. First, would you say [READ ITEMS IN RANDOM ORDER] is a top priority in how you vote, a high priority in how you vote, very important but not a priority, somewhat important, or not important?

1. The quality of education in public schools through grade 12
  Jan 5-7 1996 Jun 4-5 1999
Top priority 44% 42%
High priority 23 33
Very important 25 18
Somewhat important 5 3
Not important 2 3
No opinion 1
100%
1
100%
2. The problems of raising children in today's culture
  Jan 5-7 1996 Jun 4-5 1999
Top priority -- 41%
High priority -- 26
Very important -- 21
Somewhat important -- 8
Not important -- 2
No opinion --
100%
2
100%
3. The cost of health care in the U.S.
  Jan 5-7 1996 Jun 4-5 1999
Top priority 36% 36%
High priority 27 32
Very important 26 22
Somewhat important 9 7
Not important 1 3
No opinion 1
100%
*
100%
4. The rate of violent crime in the United States
  Jan 5-7 1996 Jun 4-5 1999
Top priority 41% 35%
High priority 25 32
Very important 24 24
Somewhat important 8 6
Not important 1 3
No opinion 1
100%
*
100%
5. Social Security and Medicare policy
  Jan 5-7 1996 Jun 4-5 1999
Top priority -- 33%
High priority -- 36
Very important -- 21
Somewhat important -- 7
Not important -- 2
No opinion --
100%
1
100%
6. The availability of good jobs in the U.S.
  Jan 5-7 1996 Jun 4-5 1999
Top priority -- 32%
High priority -- 31
Very important -- 26
Somewhat important -- 7
Not important -- 3
No opinion --
100%
1
100%
7. The nation's economy
  Jan 5-7 1996 Jun 4-5 1999
Top priority 37% 29%
High priority 27 41
Very important 26 21
Somewhat important 7 6
Not important 1 2
No opinion 2
100%
1
100%
8. The amount Americans pay in federal taxes
  Jan 5-7 1996 Jun 4-5 1999
Top priority 29% 26%
High priority 23 28
Very important 31 28
Somewhat important 12 13
Not important 4 4
No opinion 1
100%
1
100%
9. Gun laws
  Jan 5-7 1996 Jun 4-5 1999
Top priority -- 26%
High priority -- 24
Very important -- 24
Somewhat important -- 13
Not important -- 11
No opinion --
100%
2
100%
10. The situation in Kosovo
  Jan 5-7 1996 Jun 4-5 1999
Top priority -- 19%
High priority -- 24
Very important -- 29
Somewhat important -- 18
Not important -- 7
No opinion --
100%
3
100%
11. Race relations
  Jan 5-7 1996 Jun 4-5 1999
Top priority -- 17%
High priority -- 28
Very important -- 29
Somewhat important -- 16
Not important -- 8
No opinion --
100%
2
100%
12. Abortion policy
  Jan 5-7 1996 Jun 4-5 1999
Top priority -- 17%
High priority -- 18
Very important -- 24
Somewhat important -- 18
Not important -- 21
No opinion --
100%
2
100%
13. Campaign finance reform
  Jan 5-7 1996 Jun 4-5 1999
Top priority -- 10%
High priority -- 14
Very important -- 29
Somewhat important -- 26
Not important -- 18
No opinion --
100%
3
100%
* Less than 0.5%


Gallup https://news.gallup.com/poll/3796/columbine-could-cast-long-shadow-over-2000-election.aspx
Gallup World Headquarters, 901 F Street, Washington, D.C., 20001, U.S.A
+1 202.715.3030