skip to main content
Questions and Answers With the Editor in Chief

Questions and Answers With the Editor in Chief

Has John Kerry's selection of John Edwards as his running mate affected the way Americans look at the presidential race?

All in all, I would say that Kerry's selection of Edwards has had a quite modest impact. The Kerry-Edwards ticket has gained slightly against George Bush-Dick Cheney in the horse race balloting, compared with Gallup's last pre-Edwards poll conducted June 21-23. But the overall size of the Kerry-Edwards lead among likely voters is no greater than it was at other times in June and May, and in any case, statistically speaking, the race among likely voters remains too close to call. The Kerry-Edwards ticket now gets 50% of the vote among likely voters, compared with 46% for Bush-Cheney. When we throw the third-party ticket of Ralph Nader-Peter Camejo into the mix, not much changes: Kerry-Edwards gets 50%, Bush-Cheney gets 45%, and Nader-Camejo gets 2% (again, among likely voters).

Any indication that Edwards is helping Kerry in the relatively vote-rich state of North Carolina, with 15 electoral votes?

Over the weekend, we conducted a special Gallup/CNN/USA Today poll in North Carolina. Among likely voters, the Bush-Cheney ticket beats the Kerry-Edwards ticket by a 56% to 41% margin -- roughly the margin by which Bush won the state in 2000. Gallup hasn't polled specifically in North Carolina before this, but the size of the Bush-Cheney lead certainly doesn't suggest that the addition of Edwards to the Kerry ticket has propelled the Tar Heel State into the ranks of contestable battleground states -- at least so far.

Does this throw cold water on the hypothesis that Edwards could make a positive difference for Kerry in the South?

The pattern in one Southern state is not necessarily translatable to all Southern states. But, yes, it seems reasonable to assume that if the Edwards selection were going to make a difference, it would be in his home state first. And so far that apparently hasn't happened.

Isn't Edwards a popular senator in his state?

Yes, Edwards is quite popular. He has a 63% favorable rating among North Carolinians, nearly 10 points higher than his favorable rating nationwide. It's also a more positive rating than North Carolinians give to either Bush or Kerry. It just appears that so far, Edwards' personal appeal has not been translated into votes.

The choice of Edwards was most likely made in part to contrast with the older, less charismatic Dick Cheney. There is continued speculation that Bush might still pull off a high-visibility move and dump Cheney in favor of a high-profile Republican like Colin Powell or John McCain. Could this make a difference?

If anything, there is less support for replacing Cheney than there was previously. Fifty-nine percent of all Americans and 71% of Republicans say that Cheney should remain on the ticket -- virtually unchanged from two previous polls conducted last October and July.

Of course, there is still the possibility that the Bush campaign might engineer a dramatic switch of the vice presidential nominee between now and the GOP convention, but at this time there are no signs that Republicans across the country are pressing for this type of change.

More generally, has Cheney become a liability to the Bush ticket?

No. Cheney's favorable rating is now at 46%, with a 42% unfavorable rating. These ratings are almost identical to what Gallup measured in February, long before the recent controversies in which Cheney has been involved. 

To be sure, Cheney's ratings are now lower than they were in polling conducted in 2002 and 2003, when the White House in general was doing well in the polls. But there are few signs that his standing among the public has deteriorated further in recent weeks or months.

Cheney also has slightly lower favorable ratings than his boss has, but it's interesting to note that 12% of Americans still say they either don't know enough about Cheney to rate him or have no opinion. And Cheney's unfavorable rating -- 42% -- is actually lower than Bush's 46% unfavorable rating.

In other words, despite the media focus on Cheney (that is, his highly visible use of the "F-word" on the Senate floor), Cheney is holding his own.

One of Cheney's roles is to appeal to the hard-core Republican base. Is he still doing that?

Yes. The data clearly show that Cheney is a polarizing figure. He has an 81% favorable rating among Republicans and a 69% favorable rating among conservatives. On the other hand, his unfavorable rating is 68% among Democrats and 66% among liberals.

But Cheney is actually slightly less polarizing than Bush, who has a 92% favorable rating among Republicans and a 79% unfavorable rating among Democrats.

Everything else being equal, should Kerry's ticket get a bounce from the Democratic convention?

Absolutely. It's extremely normal for a presidential ticket to gain in the neighborhood of five to seven percentage points after the convention. Thus, if the Kerry-Edwards ticket maintains their modest lead over the next two weeks, we can expect them to come out of the convention with about 55% of the vote (or slightly more), giving them a possible double-digit lead over Bush-Cheney in August.

But won't the Democrats lose some of this bounce after the Republican convention that takes place a month later?

Yes. There is no reason not to expect a second bounce (a "bounce-back," if you will) for the Bush-Cheney ticket after their convention. It's possible that the GOP bounce will be slightly smaller, given that Bush is an incumbent, but the race should move back toward some degree of parity in Gallup's first September polling. How close the Republicans can get to parity will be the real key to the closing two months before the election.

An incumbent president's job approval rating is a major indicator of his probability of being re-elected. How is Bush doing in that department?

Neither extremely well nor extremely poorly. According to Gallup's weekend poll, Bush's job approval rating is 47%. More than anything else, this number represents stability. Bush's approval rating has remained within a narrow band between 46% and 53% for 16 Gallup Polls since mid-January. Most amazingly, the last six polls have seen almost no change at all in Bush's job approval rating -- 49%, 46%, 47%, 49%, 48%, 47%.

Bush is still below the 50% threshold that is the symbolic cut-off point for incumbents vying for successful re-election. At roughly this point in the year in which they sought re-election, Bill Clinton was at 57% approval, Ronald Reagan was at 55%, Richard Nixon was at 56%, Lyndon Johnson was at 74%, and Dwight Eisenhower was at 70%. All five of these presidents won re-election.

On the other hand, in July of their election years, Bush's father had a 32% job approval rating, Jimmy Carter was at 33%, and Gerald Ford was at 45%. These three presidents all lost their bids for re-election.

All in all, Bush is clearly vulnerable, but not as bad off as were the last two incumbents to be defeated -- his father in 1992, and Carter in 1980. Much will depend on what happens between now and Labor Day, particularly the voters' reactions to the two parties' conventions.

The high-profile Michael Moore movie, Fahrenheit 9/11, has now grossed more than $80 million. Is this movie going to affect the election?

It doesn't look like it's going to convert many Republicans, although it may fire up the Democratic base. Our weekend poll confirms that to a significant degree, the movie has been preaching to the choir. Those who have seen the movie and/or are interested in seeing it are overwhelmingly Democrats. Additionally, a significant majority of Democrats have favorable impressions of the movie (regardless of whether they have seen it), while Republicans have highly negative impressions.

Even though the poll shows less than 10% of American adults have seen Fahrenheit 9/11, most Americans have heard about it. That's a surprising finding, and presumably a tribute to the public relations campaign that accompanied the movie's release. Only 21% of Americans say they don't know enough about Fahrenheit 9/11 to give an opinion about it. And people obviously have a good feel for what the movie is about, given the strong partisan differences in opinions.

Any sign that the transfer of power in Iraq has made a difference in how the public looks at the situation there?

No. Attitudes toward the situation in Iraq remain stable and still negative. Most tellingly, for the second Gallup Poll in a row, 54% of Americans say that the U.S. involvement in Iraq was a mistake. (When Gallup asked this same question of Americans during the Vietnam War, that level of negative opinion wasn't observed until the late summer of 1968, several years after the conflict began.) Additionally, 59% of Americans say that the war in Iraq is going badly for the United States at this time.

These views on Iraq have not changed between Gallup's June 21-23 poll and the poll this past weekend, suggesting that the late June handover of power had little effect on the public's views of the situation there.

The other high salience issue in this election is the economy. How's that looking?

Better. Americans haven't budged in their assessments of the current economy -- only 37% say it is in excellent or good shape. But for the first time since February, a majority of Americans (51%) now say that economic conditions in the United States are getting better, while only 38% say they are getting worse.

Additionally, there has been a slight increase in the percentage of Americans who say that now is a good time to find a quality job. Thirty-six percent feel this way, and that's the highest we have measured on this question since August 2001. But 32% of Americans said now is a good time to find a quality job last month, so there hasn't been a major jump, and the majority still say it is not a good time to be looking for a job.

So, Bush faces negative attitudes on Iraq, and improving attitudes on the economy?

That's right. Given the stability in Bush's overall job approval rating, it's probably fair to say that the impact of more positive attitudes about the economy is being counterbalanced by Americans' concerns about the Iraq situation.

This week, the Senate votes on the so-called marriage amendment. Is the public engaged with the issue of same-sex marriage?

No. The latest polling shows that same-sex marriage barely comes up at all when Gallup asks Americans to name the most important problem facing the country. And it is near the bottom of the list when we ask Americans to rate the importance of various issues.

The latest Gallup Poll on the issue, conducted in May, shows that 51% of Americans favor an amendment that would define marriage as between a man and a woman.

Author(s)

Dr. Frank Newport is a Gallup Senior Scientist and the author of Polling Matters (Warner Books, 2004) and The Evangelical Voter.


Gallup https://news.gallup.com/poll/12355/questions-answers-editor-chief.aspx
Gallup World Headquarters, 901 F Street, Washington, D.C., 20001, U.S.A
+1 202.715.3030