skip to main content
Questions and Answers With the Editor in Chief

Questions and Answers With the Editor in Chief

The Republican convention got underway Monday in New York. Where does the presidential race stand at this point?

Things are not as positive for John Kerry as the Democrats would have liked. In the final CNN/USA Today/Gallup poll conducted before the July Democratic convention, Kerry was ahead of George Bush among likely voters by 49% to 47%. At this point, just prior to the final pre-Republican convention poll, Kerry is behind Bush by 47% to 50%. In the broadest sense, that's not much change. The race statistically was too close to call before the Democratic convention and it is too close to call now. But the direction of the change we have seen is exactly the wrong way from Kerry's perspective. Candidates usually gain ground as a result of their conventions, but Kerry if anything had an immediate negative bounce after the Boston Democratic convention (followed by stability over the last two Gallup Polls).

Will Bush gain even more as a result of this week's convention?

That's certainly possible, but by no means assured. One explanation for the lack of a bounce for Kerry after his convention is that voters are quite rigid in their preferences this year and less susceptible to changing their minds than is usually the case. If this is indeed the case, I would expect to see little substantial change after the GOP convention.

But there is a competing theory that Kerry's lack of a bounce resulted from his failure to excite voters at his convention. If that's the correct explanation, then it's possible that Bush could do a better job and thus gain ground as a result of what voters see this week.

There's also a third possible scenario. Gallup's research suggests that the Democratic convention had the paradoxical effect of increasing motivation and enthusiasm among Republicans. The reverse could happen this week. Democrats could become more united and motivated after watching Bush and the Republicans, resulting in an uptick for Kerry.

Some observers assume that Kerry has been hurt by the recent charges and countercharges about his Vietnam service. What do the data show?

Kerry's Vietnam service has been the subject of a great deal of media attention, including commentary and debate over the now famous "Swift Boat" television ads. Indeed, the latest Gallup Poll shows that 8 in 10 Americans have either seen or heard about the ads.

The conventional wisdom is that this controversy has hurt Kerry. But I am hard pressed to find substantiation for the assertion the Swift Boat ads per se are the cause for Kerry's doing less well now than he did in mid-July. Our data suggest that Kerry lost positioning vis-a-vis Bush immediately after the Democratic convention, which was before most of the attention given to his Vietnam service. If anything, the trend over the last several weeks shows a slight weakening of Bush's position, not a weakening in Kerry's.

At the same time, Kerry's favorable/unfavorable numbers have become more negative. Kerry's image has deteriorated slightly since the convention, from a 57% favorable, and 37% unfavorable reading in the July 30-Aug 1. Gallup Poll, to a 52% favorable, 40% unfavorable reading today. There's also been a drop in the number of Americans who say that Kerry's military service has made them more likely to vote for him -- from 42% just after the Democratic convention to 21% in the Aug. 23-25 poll. More voters now say that Kerry's service will not affect their votes.

But it's difficult to determine whether even these changes were a direct result of the impact of the Swift Boat ads. Some of the changes could simply reflect the passage of time since Kerry was in the spotlight during his convention.

How would you typify Bush's strengths as he goes into the GOP convention?

In terms of issues, Bush's greatest strength remains the perception of his handling of terrorism. Bush also has a slight advantage over Kerry in Americans' perceptions of who can best handle the situation in Iraq.

In terms of more personal dimensions, Bush is much more likely than Kerry to be seen by voters as a) a strong and decisive leader; b) standing up for what he believes in; and c) best able to manage government. Bush is also a little more likely than Kerry to be seen as honest and trustworthy and a person Americans admire.

On the other hand, Kerry edges Bush on most domestic issues, particularly Medicare.

So Bush is now ahead of Kerry in voters' minds on the issue of Iraq?

Yes. I think the changes we are seeing in the American public's perception of the situation in Iraq (and Bush's handling of it) are potentially very important.

Forty-nine percent of Americans say that Bush can do the best job handling Iraq, compared with 43% who choose Kerry. Just after the Democratic convention, 48% chose Kerry and 47% chose Bush.

Furthermore, there are signs of an increase in positive sentiment about Iraq. Fifty-one percent of Americans now say that the situation in Iraq was worth going to war over. In early May, that number was 44%.

Similarly, the two most recent August Gallup Polls have shown that about 50% of Americans believe that the U.S. involvement in Iraq was not a mistake. That is up from three polls in June and July when only about 45% thought that sending troops to Iraq was not a mistake, and the "mistake" number was up to 54%.

What is Bush's overall job approval and image rating?

The public's perception of the job Bush is doing as president is roughly balanced between those who approve (49%) and those who disapprove (47%). These numbers have not changed materially for months. Gallup has asked this job approval question in 10 polls since May, and Bush's approval score has ranged only between 46% at the low end and 51% at the high end.

Bush's favorable rating of his overall image -- 54% -- is a little more positive than his job approval rating. In other words, a few more Americans like Bush personally than approve of the job he is doing as president.

What impact are the vice presidential candidates having?

It's unclear whether the vice presidential candidates will have a hugely significant impact in this election, or if vice presidents have ever had a major impact on an election.

But the data show that on a head-to-head basis, John Edwards is in a considerably stronger position than Dick Cheney. Edwards has a 52% favorable, 28% unfavorable rating, which compares very positively with Cheney's 44% favorable, 45% unfavorable marks.

Gallup also asked voters in our last poll, "If you could vote separately for vice president, would you be more likely to vote for Edwards or Cheney?" Edwards won over Cheney by 52% to 42%.

The presidential race will not ultimately play out at the national level, but rather in specific swing states. What's happening in these "showdown" states?

The combined vote in 16 showdown states, according to the latest national Gallup Poll (Aug. 23-25), shows Bush and Kerry within a point of each other.

It simply doesn't get much closer than that.

We are going to see many high-profile speakers at the GOP convention. Who is most likely to impress voters?

Although California Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger is arguably the biggest celebrity on the program at the GOP convention, the most popular of the speakers is likely to be former New York City Mayor Rudy Giuliani, who has a 65% favorable, 14% unfavorable rating. Schwarzenegger has only a 56% favorable rating. First Lady Laura Bush receives a 63% favorable rating, and Arizona Sen. John McCain, with a 55% favorability rating, is not as popular now as he has been in the past.

Bush himself has a 54% favorable rating. It appears that Cheney, scheduled to make his address on Wednesday night, will be the least popular major speaker on the podium.

Much of the news coverage of the presidential campaign over the last several weeks has focused on foreign, rather than domestic issues. Will the economy still turn out to be a major factor in the election?

Yes. It's likely that the economy will be one of the major issues -- if not the major issue -- to ultimately determine the outcome of this election.

Kerry still beats Bush when voters are asked which of the two candidates would do the best job handling the economy -- 49% to 43%. Although the specific size of this gap has varied from poll to poll, Kerry has led Bush on the economy across six different Gallup Polls since early March.

Additionally, Bush has not gotten a lot of mileage out of his signature economic issue, tax cuts. Bush's official election Web site says: "On May 28, 2003, President Bush signed into law a bold jobs and growth plan to strengthen America's economy and ensure its continued growth." That law, of course, primarily involved cutting taxes. But this "bold" program hasn't excited a lot of Americans. Kerry has a slight lead over Bush, 47% to 44%, when Gallup asks voters which candidate can do the best job handling taxes.

Perhaps most damaging to the president that the public is no more likely to say that the tax cuts have helped the U.S. economy than it is to say they have hurt the economy. About a third of Americans -- mostly Republicans -- say the tax cuts have mostly helped the U.S. economy, while exactly the same percentage say that the tax cuts have hurt. Another third say that they have had no effect. In other words, about two-thirds of Americans say that the tax cuts have had no effect or a negative effect.

Let's cut to the chase. Who's going to win this election?

Sorry, it's still too early to tell. Although things look a little better for Bush than they did a few weeks ago, he is by no means in a strong position for an incumbent. Bush's job approval rating is just below the symbolically important 50% mark, and he is essentially tied with Kerry among likely voters.

On the other hand, as I discussed previously, there is at least a 50-50 probability that Bush will gain after the convention, and there is some chance that he will gain significantly. That would put him in a relatively good position going into the debates, scheduled for later in September.

Author(s)

Dr. Frank Newport is a Gallup Senior Scientist and the author of Polling Matters (Warner Books, 2004) and The Evangelical Voter.


Gallup https://news.gallup.com/poll/12895/Questions-Answers-Editor-Chief.aspx
Gallup World Headquarters, 901 F Street, Washington, D.C., 20001, U.S.A
+1 202.715.3030