skip to main content
Questions and Answers With the Editor in Chief

Questions and Answers With the Editor in Chief

The big political news this week is the first presidential debate, to be held at the University of Miami on Thursday. Is there any doubt the debates will be important?

The debates will certainly be important, but exactly how important is still up in the air. The conventional wisdom is that the debates made a difference in 2000 (Al Gore's performance was seen by observers as below expectations), in 1992 (George H.W. Bush famously looking at his watch as if bored), 1984 (Ronald Reagan's famous joke about not taking his opponent's relative youth and inexperience into account), 1980 (Reagan's strong performance in the only debate, held close to the election), and of course in 1960 (Richard Nixon's sweating and John F. Kennedy's tanned, relaxed appearance supposedly convinced voters that the latter was indeed presidential material).

This year, however, Gallup's weekend poll shows that a somewhat smaller percentage of voters than usual expect the debates to make a difference in their choice for president. Only 18% of registered voters think the debates will make a difference, down from 26% prior to the debates in 2000, and 30% in 1992.

Independents, Democrats, and John Kerry voters are slightly more likely to say the debates will matter than are Republicans and George Bush voters.

Part of the run-up to the debates is the expectations game. Both campaigns are trying to raise expectations for the other candidate. What do the data show?

Registered voters predict that Bush will do a better job in the debates than Kerry, by 52% to 39%. This is a significant change from September 2000, when voters expected that Gore would do a better job than Bush by 44% to 37%.

Is this good or bad news for Bush?

The Bush campaign probably isn't interpreting this as good news, because both campaigns seem to think that it is better for a candidate to go into the debate with low expectations rather than high expectations.

The debates are taking place in Florida. How have the hurricanes affected the Sunshine State?

The latest CNN/USA Today/Gallup poll was completed in Florida last week, before Hurricane Jeanne hit. Results reinforce the massive economic impact of the hurricanes. About one in four adults living in Florida report that they personally suffered significant property damage or financial loss this year as a direct result of a hurricane hitting the area where they live. That's a far cry from the usually more isolated damage that a hurricane does when it hits a particular state.

Furthermore, 62% of Floridians say that they are very or somewhat worried about suffering significant property damage or financial loss in the future as a result of a hurricane hitting the area where they live.

Perhaps most importantly, the hurricanes appear to have made a significant difference in the way Florida residents are looking at the economic situation in their state. In July, 51% of registered voters in Florida rated their state's economy as excellent or good, while only 12% rated it as poor. Now, in the Sept. 18-22 poll, only 41% of Florida voters rate economic conditions positively, compared with 25% who rate it as poor (30% say conditions are only fair). And that was before any additional damage from Hurricane Jeanne.

What are the political implications of the hurricanes in Florida?

It's interesting to speculate about the impact of the forces of nature on a political election. For years, observers have speculated that rain on Election Day hurts Democratic candidates, based on the assumption that Republicans are more likely to turn out and vote regardless of the weather.

The four recent hurricanes hit Florida right in the middle of a heated presidential race. Florida, of course, is the hottest of the hot swing states. The race was so close in 2000 that it took over a month and a decision by the U.S. Supreme Court to disentangle which candidate won the state.

Still, the overall presidential ballot in Florida has not changed much over the last month. Bush was ahead of Kerry by two points among likely voters in August, and he is ahead by three points now. In others words, the race remains virtually a statistical tie, just as it was in December 2000.

But perceptions of the economy clearly divide the state. There is an extraordinary correlation between voters' views of the economy in Florida and their vote choices. Even now, Bush voters are positive about the state's economic conditions, while Kerry voters are much more negative. 

The second-quarter gross national product data will be released Wednesday. Much of the political talk has been about Iraq in recent days. But will the economy in the end be an important issue for voters?

Yes. No matter how you look at it, the economy is still one of the most important issues to voters as they make up their minds this year.

Still, it's apparent that voters have become increasingly likely in recent weeks to say that terrorism is an important issue to their vote. When given a choice among four issues, 35% of Americans now say that the economy will be their No. 1 consideration, and terrorism is just three points behind at 32%. Iraq and healthcare are much farther behind.

This represents a shift. In July, only 21% of Americans chose terrorism as the most important of four issues to their vote. The percentage choosing terrorism increased to 26% by early September, just after the GOP convention.

The shift was slightly more pronounced among registered voters and a little less pronounced among likely voters, but in all three groups the same movement is evident. 

Does the increased concern about terrorism reflect the Republican strategy to emphasize terrorism as the major issue in this election?

Yes. The trends in the data certainly support the hypothesis that Americans are reacting favorably to the Republican emphasis on terrorism.

At the same time, these data also cast at least some doubt on the Kerry campaign strategy to go straight after Bush on the issue of Iraq. Only 19% of likely voters say that Iraq is most important of the four issues to their vote this year.

What's happening in the showdown states?

It's apparently "the economy, stupid" in the showdown states. Thirty-eight percent of people in these states say that the economy is most important to their vote this year, followed by 28% who choose terrorism. Only 17% say it's Iraq, and 14% choose healthcare.

What is current public opinion about Iraq? 

Mixed signals. The majority of Americans continue to say that U.S. involvement in Iraq was not a mistake. But a slight majority (52%) also say that things are going badly for the United States in Iraq at this time. Importantly, the percentage of Americans who feel that things are going badly for the United States in Iraq is slightly lower now than at other times earlier this year, despite the continued television and newspaper reports of casualties and coverage of the fact that more than 1,000 U.S. servicemen and servicewomen have died in Iraq.

Bush is now better positioned than Kerry on Iraq, despite the latter's heavy emphasis on the situation there in the last week or so. Approval of how Bush is handling the situation in Iraq is now at 48% -- three points better than when we last measured it in early August. Asked who can better handle the situation in Iraq, Americans choose Bush over Kerry by 55% to 41%, unchanged from early September.

Going into Thursday's first debate, how would you characterize where this election stands?

Bush leads. He is ahead in enough of the showdown states to indicate a probable Electoral College victory if the election were held today. Nationally, Bush leads Kerry by eight points, 52% to 44%, among likely voters in Gallup's Sept. 24-26 poll.

As I have repeatedly noted in these columns over the last month,  these findings by no means indicate that Bush is going to win the election. Much can change over the next five weeks.

The main purpose of the campaigning, debates, and advertising that takes place this fall is to change people's minds. (The other purpose, of course, is to rally the troops and make sure that each party's base voters stay motivated to turn out and vote.) I would be surprised if there weren't a lot of changes and shifts as the campaign moves into its final phases. 

A look at history confirms the likelihood of change. Hubert Humphrey came from way behind and almost beat Nixon in the 1968 election. Gerald Ford was far behind Jimmy Carter in 1976, but closed the race to within two points by Election Day. Reagan -- virtually at the last moment -- used a strong debate performance to charge ahead and beat Carter by 10 points, when Carter had been ahead earlier that fall. George H.W. Bush was trailing Bill Clinton by double digits in 1992, but ultimately lost by just five points. And most recently, both George W. Bush and Al Gore were each ahead in the polls at different times in September and October 2000, only to end up in a virtual dead heat, with Gore getting about 500,000 more votes than Bush.

The moral of the story: I fully expect change in a competitive election environment. What the polls shows now about the status of the election "if it were held today" is accurate, but the current results are by no means a prediction of what the polls will show on the eve of the election.  

Author(s)

Dr. Frank Newport is a Gallup Senior Scientist and the author of Polling Matters (Warner Books, 2004) and The Evangelical Voter.


Gallup https://news.gallup.com/poll/13219/questions-answers-editor-chief.aspx
Gallup World Headquarters, 901 F Street, Washington, D.C., 20001, U.S.A
+1 202.715.3030