skip to main content
Questions and Answers With the Editor in Chief

Questions and Answers With the Editor in Chief

Is the presidential race still too close to call?

Yes. No matter how you look at the data, the two major-party candidates are neck and neck. Gallup's final Oct. 29-31 CNN/USA Today/Gallup poll shows that if all registered voters actually turn out (which is not likely to happen, of course), John Kerry wins over George W. Bush by two points. Among likely voters, including our estimate of what the remaining undecided voters will do on Election Day, the race is dead even at 49% for each candidate.

Analyzing the data in other ways, such as modifying likely voter assumptions and changing turnout estimates, doesn't make a substantial difference in the election predictions. The support for both candidates is basically in the upper-40% range, and the final popular vote may well depend on which side is best able to mobilize its voters to go to the polls.

How does Gallup decide how to "allocate" undecided voters?

The allocation procedure is a Gallup tradition, and represents Gallup scientists' best estimate of what the final popular vote will be on Election Day.

Here's how it works. The unallocated numbers in the pool of likely voters (that is, the percentages of likely voters supporting Bush and Kerry, not including undecided voters) are 49% for Bush and 47% for Kerry. We assume, based on an analysis of previous presidential and other elections, that there is a high probability that the challenger (in an incumbent race) will receive a higher percentage of the popular vote than he did in the last pre-election poll, while there is a high probability that the incumbent will maintain his share of the vote without any increase. This has been dubbed the "challenger rule." There are various explanations for why this may occur, including the theory that any voter who maintains that he or she is undecided about voting for a well-known incumbent this late in the game is probably leaning toward voting for the challenger.

This persistent historical pattern is the basis for Gallup's decision to allocate the 3% undecided vote to Kerry and Nader/other, making the final estimate 49% Bush, 49% Kerry, and 2% Nader/other. 

What are some possible Electoral College scenarios?

There has been a lot of discussion about abolishing the Electoral College in favor of a straight popular vote to elect the president. But one downside of that reform (which is favored by the majority of Americans, by the way) is that it would eliminate the fun of doodling out the vast variety of possible Electoral College scenarios as Election Day approaches. 

The math is simple. The number of possible binary outcomes of the Electoral College is 2 to the xth power, with x being the number of states involved. If we assume there are 10 swing states, that equals out to 2 to the 10th power, or 1,024 possible scenarios. If, like Princeton University professor Sam Wang, one assumes that there are 23 swing states, then there are 4,194,304 possible ways that the election could unfold. And so forth.

Poll results from the states help estimate the probabilities of specific outcome combinations with more precision. But even with the latest CNN/USA Today/Gallup poll results in hand, there are still so many different plausible ways that the Electoral College could play itself out that we can have no firm idea of what is going to happen on Election Day. Still, there is hope. There are ways to help make sense out of what is happening on a state-by-state basis.

Certainly I believe that Florida is the place to start. With 27 electoral votes, Florida is the biggest prize of all the states that are still considered to be in play. Our final poll in Florida gives Kerry the edge, although not outside the margin of error. 

If Bush wins every state he won in 2000, that would give him 277 electoral votes (EVs) -- including Florida. Using that number as a baseline, if we concede Florida to Kerry for sake of argument, the Democratic challenger moves ahead of Bush by 20 EVs. 

The other two big states in play are Ohio (20 EVs) and Pennsylvania (21 EVs). The Gallup Poll shows Kerry with a slight lead in Ohio and Bush with a slight lead in Pennsylvania (although neither are outside the margin of error). If Kerry wins Ohio and Bush wins Pennsylvania (the opposite of 2000, when Bush won Ohio and Gore won Pennsylvania), the result would be 20 EVs for Kerry that Gore did not have in 2000 and 21 "new" votes for Bush, giving Kerry a total advantage of 19.   

Here's where it gets interesting. Our data show Bush ahead in Wisconsin, which has 10 EVs and was taken by Gore in 2000. If Bush actually wins there, Kerry's lead would be reduced to nine votes (since Bush would be taking away a 2000 Democratic state). Iowa is too close to call, but Bush has a slight lead. Gore also won Iowa in 2000. If Bush wins in Iowa (seven EVs taken from the 2000 Democratic ledger), Kerry's lead is reduced to two EVs. 

The race is a true nail-biter in this scenario, and could come down to New Mexico and New Hampshire, with five and four EVs, respectively. Gore won New Mexico in 2000 and Bush won New Hampshire. If Bush retains New Hampshire and also wins New Mexico, he wins under this scenario. If Bush loses New Hampshire and wins New Mexico, he loses.   

And so forth. The numerous permutations and close races in many states allow for all manner of possible scenarios. The bottom line from my perspective -- anything can happen. 

How might the president's job approval rating influence the outcome of the election?

A president's job approval rating is an important indicator of re-election probabilities. But like so much else in this election, this measure isn't giving us a great deal of direction right now. Bush's job approval has slipped to 48% among national adults and is thus below the symbolically important 50% point. If we take that 50% line seriously, then Bush is in a less-than-auspicious position. No president since Harry Truman has won re-election with a job approval rating below 50%. 

But the last two presidents who lost (George H. W. Bush and Jimmy Carter) had job approval ratings much worse than George W. Bush's 48%. He is clearly not as bad off as they were. On the other hand, the winners all had job approval ratings well above 50%. Bush is in a gray zone when it comes to his job approval rating.

What is the impact of turnout among younger voters?

We've heard a lot about the impact of younger voters this year. The data indeed show that Kerry does better among younger voters -- that is, those under age 30. Among all national adults in that age group, Kerry wins by a 59% to 34% margin.

Over the years, many analyses of voting patterns by age have documented that younger Americans are less likely to vote than older Americans. In fact, age is a fairly consistent linear prediction of voting probability. Thus, while 18- to 29-year-olds represent 18% of the total sample of adults, they represent only 13% of the likely voter sample. This difference between the 18- to 29-year-old representation in the registered voter sample and the 18- to 29-year-old representation in the national adult sample is not huge, and even if we were to assume that 18- to 29-year-olds will vote in direct proportion to their percentage in the overall population, it wouldn't affect the Bush-Kerry ballot numbers more than a point or two. 

Still, in a close election, almost anything could make a difference, so the ultimate turnout of younger voters proportionate to the overall turnout rate could make a difference in tomorrow's election results.

Is there any indication that the missing weapons in Iraq and/or the Osama bin Laden tape will affect the outcome?

Bush's positioning vis-à-vis Kerry on both Iraq and terrorism has slipped in the most recent poll, and it is reasonable to assume that this slippage is, at least in part, related to the weapons and bin Laden tape. 

Among all national adults, 49% now choose Kerry as the candidate best able to handle Iraq, while 47% choose Bush. This marks a significant pickup on this measure for Kerry, who was down nine points to Bush last week. In fact, Kerry has lost out to Bush on this measure in every poll conducted since the Democratic convention.

Bush's margin over Kerry as the candidate best able to handle terrorism is now seven points 51% of Americans choose Bush and 44% choose Kerry. This again marks a significant change. Last week, Bush had an 18-point margin over Kerry, and the 7-point advantage is the lowest yet for Bush.

What else may be driving this election?

We asked voters in each of the six showdown states in which we interviewed this weekend to indicate which of four issues (the economy, terrorism, Iraq, or healthcare) will be the most important in determining their votes for president.

The economy, terrorism, and Iraq (to a slightly lesser degree) are important to voters in all six states. Healthcare is universally viewed as the least important of the four. There are minor variations among the six states. The economy is slightly more likely to be chosen as the most important issue in four states: Ohio, Iowa, Minnesota, and Wisconsin. Voters in Florida and Pennsylvania are slightly more likely to choose terrorism.

Is the gender gap still alive and well?

Yes, to a modest degree. In this past weekend's poll, the unallocated sample of likely voters showed men breaking for Bush by a 53% to 43% margin, and women breaking for Kerry by a 50% to 45% margin. Given the slightly higher percentage of women in the overall population (and in the likely voter pool), this averages out to the 49% Bush, 47% Kerry margin that we found before allocating the undecideds.

Of some interest is the fact that Bush wins 57% to 40% among likely voters who are married, while Kerry wins 57% to 37% among likely voters who are not married. Kerry wins overwhelmingly in union households. Bush wins overwhelmingly in gun-owning households. Bush continues to win among frequent churchgoers, while Kerry does best among infrequent churchgoers. Kerry wins by four points among Catholics, but does less well among actively practicing Catholics. Bush wins 56% to 39% among veterans.

Finally, I want to point out that Bush has the lead over Kerry among voters who listen to country music, and among those who drive trucks, minivans, and SUVs. Kerry does better among voters who listen to R&B music, and among foreign car drivers.

Author(s)

Dr. Frank Newport is a Gallup Senior Scientist and the author of Polling Matters (Warner Books, 2004) and The Evangelical Voter.


Gallup https://news.gallup.com/poll/13948/Questions-Answers-Editor-Chief.aspx
Gallup World Headquarters, 901 F Street, Washington, D.C., 20001, U.S.A
+1 202.715.3030