skip to main content
Questions and Answers With the Editor in Chief

Questions and Answers With the Editor in Chief

What was the biggest surprise in the election?

There weren't a great number of surprises in the outcome. As I pointed out last week, the best strategy for analyzing an election is to start by assuming things will be the same as the previous election, then look for deviations. Overall, this year there weren't a lot of deviations from 2000.

Only three states "flipped" and gave their electoral votes to a different party's candidate than they did in 2000. Two states flipped for Bush: New Mexico and Iowa. Both of these states narrowly went for Al Gore in 2000, so the shift didn't mark a dramatic change (particularly because each just barely went for George W. Bush this year). New Hampshire, which went for Bush in 2000, flipped for John Kerry, but not by a lot. So from a state-by-state perspective, the map of the Electoral College this year stayed remarkably similar to what it was in 2000.

In terms of the popular vote, the absence of meaningful third-party candidates this year may have been as significant a factor as anything else. Third-party candidates received 4% of the total vote in 2000 and only 1% this time (based on preliminary figures). Bush seems, at the aggregate level, to have been the beneficiary of these lost third-party votes; his share of the vote rose three points (from 48% in 2000 to 51% this year). Kerry's share (48%) was the same as Gore's in 2000.

Did this year mark any structural change in the electorate?

No. I think it's fair to say that this election does not represent a major shift in the American political landscape. There were no dramatic new patterns of voter realignment. "Red states" in 2000 were almost all red states this year, and "blue states" in 2000 were almost all blue states this year.

In fact, a careful comparison of Gallup's last 2004 pre-election poll to the last 2000 pre-election poll showed the same basic pattern of candidate support by subgroups of the population. For example, Bush did well in both years among men, those living in the South, those who attend church frequently, married voters, and Protestants.

Kerry did better among nonwhites, voters who do not attend church, those living in urban areas, and those either with no college education or with postgraduate education. Again, these demographics were Gore's strengths in 2000 as well.

Where did Bush make the gains necessary to move ahead in the popular vote (after narrowly losing the popular vote in 2000) and how did he achieve these gains?

Gallup's comparison of the final pre-election polls in 2000 and 2004 showed that Bush gained disproportionately among conservatives, those who attend church regularly, Protestants, and voters living in urban areas. Bush's gains among conservative, churchgoing Protestants suggest that the so-called moral values vote may have been a factor in the election's outcome.

It was certainly part of the Bush strategy to solidify support among this group, although the exact role of "moral values" in the election has developed, as these things often do, into a mini-controversy of sorts.

Here's part of the background on the controversy. A question included on the Edison-Mitofsky exit poll this year asked voters to choose which of seven different issues was most important in their decision on whom to vote for. The list included terrorism, Iraq, education, taxes, healthcare, economy/jobs, and moral values. About a fifth of voters (22%), mostly Bush voters, selected "moral values." From this finding, a conclusion emerged that Bush's edge this year may have resulted from concern about moral values among religious conservatives.

This conclusion dovetails with the widely reported fact that courting white, Protestant, religious voters was a mainstay for Bush adviser Karl Rove's re-election strategy. According to reports, this strategy prompted Bush to focus on public stances that would appeal to this group (supporting a federal amendment to define marriage as between a man and a woman; opposing new embryonic stem cell research; supporting a ban on partial-birth abortion), and also spurred a major "get out the vote" effort among conservative Christians.

But some polling experts have argued against this conventional wisdom. Gary Langer, director of polling at ABC News, argued in a New York Times op-ed piece that the results of the Edison-Mitofsky exit poll question were misleading. Langer contends that moral values were the only broad, general issue listed among five other very specific issues. "…This hot button catch phrase had no place alongside defined political issues on the list of most important concerns in the 2004 vote," Langer said. He argues that it was perhaps too easy for voters to choose "moral values" from the list. Langer and others have also pointed out that moral values have not emerged as a top issue when voters are asked, in an open-ended format, to name their No. 1 concern in the election this year.

I have looked for additional Gallup data that speak to this issue. Gallup asked about moral values in a different way in its penultimate pre-election survey this year, conducted Oct 22-24. In this survey, interviewers read a list of issues and concerns to respondents, one by one, and asked them to rate the perceived importance of each dimension to their presidential vote. This format obviates a possible problem with the structure of the Edison-Mitofsky exit poll question, which asked voters to choose only one issue from the list.

The results from Gallup's survey show that Bush voters were sharply more likely than Kerry voters to say that moral values were extremely important in their vote decision. Forty-seven percent of Bush voters said that moral values were extremely important, compared with 26% of Kerry voters. Only terrorism, at 54%, was higher on the list for Bush voters. For Kerry voters, the economy, Iraq, healthcare, social security, education, terrorism, Medicare, and the environment all came before moral values on the list of issues that were extremely important to their vote. Moral values outscored only one other issue among Kerry voters -- gay marriage.

These data certainly appear to reinforce the conclusion that Bush voters were concerned about moral values when they voted this year. At the same time, it is reasonable to assume that Bush voters, based on their demographic characteristics, are always generally concerned about moral values, so there is no definitive evidence that this issue was more important this year than in other election years. But if we take Bush voters at their word, they were certainly thinking about morality when they went into the booth.

What else was involved in the election this year?

Democratic Senator-elect Barack Obama of Illinois said on NBC's Meet the Press that Kerry lost the election in part because he was running against a popular wartime president. But poll data don't support that assertion. The political environment this year was not unusually auspicious for Bush, particularly compared with other presidents who have been re-elected over the last 50 years. Bush's last job approval rating before the election -- 48% -- was not strong, and his favorable rating was relatively weak and no better than Kerry's.

All five of the presidents who have successfully run for re-election since 1956 -- Dwight Eisenhower, Lyndon Johnson, Richard Nixon, Ronald Reagan, and Bill Clinton -- had a stronger public opinion base than Bush had this year. All had job approval ratings that were above 50% in their re-election years.

On the other hand, the last two presidents who sought re-election and lost -- George H. W. Bush and Jimmy Carter -- had job approval ratings well below 50% in the final Gallup Polls before Election Day. Both of these candidates sought re-election in environments that projected more classic signs of a failed presidency.

The current President Bush's approval ratings did not approach the negative depths of the elder George Bush or Carter, but his 48% job approval rating was most certainly not in the league of the successful incumbents who basically breezed on to re-election. The fact that Bush had been behind Kerry at several points this year in Gallup's trial heat surveys also did not auger well for his re-election chances.

All in all, I think it is fair to say that Bush was vulnerable this year. The final result notwithstanding, a shift among a relatively small number of Ohio voters would have won the election for Kerry, and a movement of only about 1.5% of the national electorate (subtracted from Bush and added to Kerry) would have given Kerry the popular vote as well.

So how did Bush win?

That's the key question. Kerry certainly had good positioning relative to Bush on a number of domestic issues, suggesting that voters recognized Bush's relative weakness on many bread and butter issues.

But Kerry never was able to capitalize on these Bush weaknesses. Even during the debates, which Kerry won, Kerry did not move ahead of Bush in the trial heat polls, but the race evened. (Perhaps telling was the fact that Bush beat Kerry on the "likable" dimension among debate watchers, despite the fact that Kerry was seen as superior on every other aspect of his performance.) After the debates, when the two candidates once again campaigned independently, Bush gained the lead again and held it until Election Day.

I have to say that at least in part, Bush was able to win because Kerry did not have what it took to move voters off the dime in the face of Bush's perceived leadership strength, his strength on terrorism and his appeal to conservative voters on moral issues.

Who are the presidential front-runners for 2008 at this point?

Well, the 2008 election is only about 3 years and 358 days away! There will be no incumbent, and Vice President Dick Cheney has said that he has no plans to run in 2008, so the field is wide open on both sides.

In recent years, defeated presidential candidates have rarely captured their party's nomination in the following election cycle. (Gore, Bob Dole, Michael Dukakis, Walter Mondale, and George McGovern all ran once for president, were defeated, and didn't run again.) In fact, one has to go back to Nixon and Adlai Stevenson to find a candidate who received his party's nomination again after having been defeated the first time. This is all a way of saying that there is not much precedent for Kerry returning to capture the Democratic nomination in 2008.

But Kerry's running mate, John Edwards, does becomes an automatic contender. Edwards is from the South, and it hasn't escaped the Democrats' attention that the last two successful Democratic presidential candidates were from Arkansas and Georgia.

And of course, almost every discussion of the 2008 presidential race focuses on New York Sen. Hillary Clinton, who will be up for re-election for her Senate seat in 2006, and who almost every one assumes will be running for the presidential nomination in 2008. Other Democrats in the mix include Howard Dean and a possible long shot -- the charismatic, newly elected senator from Illinois, Obama. 

On the Republican side, the candidates with the highest name recognition at this point include Sen. John McCain from Arizona, former New York Mayor Rudy Giuliani, and Florida Gov. Jeb Bush.

Author(s)

Dr. Frank Newport is a Gallup Senior Scientist and the author of Polling Matters (Warner Books, 2004) and The Evangelical Voter.


Gallup https://news.gallup.com/poll/14017/questions-answers-editor-chief.aspx
Gallup World Headquarters, 901 F Street, Washington, D.C., 20001, U.S.A
+1 202.715.3030