skip to main content

Frank Newport

A new Gallup Poll included a question that asked Americans if they favor or oppose a proposal "…that would allow workers to invest part of their Social Security taxes in the stock market or in bonds, while the rest of those taxes would remain in the Social Security system." Only 48% of Americans say they are in favor of this proposal, while 48% are opposed. 

A recent Fox News/Opinion Dynamics poll asked a somewhat different question on the issue: "Do you think people should have the choice to invest privately up to five percent of their Social Security contributions, or not?" With this question wording, 60% of those polled said they are in favor. 

The different responses to these two questions asking about privatization of Social Security suggest that this is an issue that is still to a significant degree "in play" as far as public opinion is concerned. Strategists working on referendum campaigns have longed pointed out that being first to define the guts of a complicated policy initiative is often the key to winning a campaign.

I think Americans are generally aware of the basic idea behind privatization, but the issue is not so well formulated that the public has a crystal-clear idea of how they stand on it. The Fox/Opinion Dynamics question emphasized the word "choice," which sounds pretty reasonable. It also used a 5% figure that made it clear that the policy would not involve most of Social Security. The Gallup question was a little less reassuring, perhaps, stressing only "part" as opposed to 5%. The Gallup question also mentioned the stock market and bonds specifically, which perhaps were a bit scary to respondents. 

The bottom line here: The proponents of privatizing Social Security will have an easier time of it if they can get their more benign version of the plan out into circulation first. If opponents, on the other hand, stress such things as the "risky stock market" and avoid mentioning percentage figures, they will have a better chance of stopping the privatization plan.


Gallup https://news.gallup.com/poll/14440/Frank-Newport.aspx
Gallup World Headquarters, 901 F Street, Washington, D.C., 20001, U.S.A
+1 202.715.3030