skip to main content

Frank Newport

Our new CNN/USA Today/Gallup poll shows that almost half -- 45% -- of Americans report having given money for tsunami relief. Some people have asked us if this number is high because of overreporting; that is, the desire on the part of poll respondents to claim to have engaged in socially desirable activities. 

Certainly this is possible. This is one of those situations in which there is no precise "real world" standard against which to compare self-reported behavior. There are compilations of the amount of money Americans have given for tsunami relief, based on reports from various charitable groups, but no precise government figure that gives us the percentage of Americans who have given money. So the survey data we have is the best estimate.

It is reasonable to hypothesize that some Americans may fudge their responses a little and report having given money because they intend to in the future. But we designed our question explicitly to attempt to preclude this type of overreporting. Gallup's question included an option that allowed respondents to indicate that they had "thought about" engaging in each of these three activities, in part because we thought it would lower the social pressure within the interview context to report actually having given aid or prayed for the victims and their families.

Some Americans may have reported giving money for tsunami relief because they believe that their normal religious donations will in part be spent for this purpose.

And, of course, some Americans may just want to present themselves as charitable -- even to an anonymous Gallup Poll interviewer on the telephone -- and thus report having given money when they hadn't really done so.

But I usually find myself trusting the veracity of the people we talk to in polls. I have no doubt that the 45% figure is just an estimate. If we were able to follow up with each and every one of the 450 or so people who claimed to have given money for tsunami relief, we probably would find a wide variety of explanations for why they responded affirmatively to the question. Some may not have in reality actually written a check or given a credit card donation. But that's OK. Polling data are by their nature estimates, particularly when it comes to self-reported behavior. Regardless of the exact stories involved with each of those people who said they had donated, the results give us strong evidence of an overwhelmingly positive response on the part of the American people to the tsunami tragedy.


Gallup https://news.gallup.com/poll/14539/Frank-Newport.aspx
Gallup World Headquarters, 901 F Street, Washington, D.C., 20001, U.S.A
+1 202.715.3030