skip to main content
Presidential Approval, Social Security, Michael Jackson, Abraham Lincoln, Exercise Guidelines

Presidential Approval, Social Security, Michael Jackson, Abraham Lincoln, Exercise Guidelines

Presidential Approval

President George W. Bush's job approval rating jumped to 57% in the weekend CNN/USA Today/Gallup poll -- a six-point increase from mid-January and the highest job approval rating for Bush since January 2004 (although he had a 55% rating in mid-November.) Prior to this poll, Bush's ratings had been consistently at or around 50% since mid-December.

What's behind the increase in Bush's ratings? A number of events in the past several weeks potentially could have affected the president's ratings. These include two major speeches (the inauguration and the State of the Union address), the elections in Iraq, and the president's high-intensity focus on changing Social Security.

It's most probable that the increase in Bush's ratings is not a direct reflection of the State of the Union address, as is often observed after a presidential candidate's nomination acceptance speech at his party's convention. Our research suggests a post-State-of-the-Union approval ratings bump is the rare exception -- not the rule.

It also does not appear that the public has been at all impressed with Bush's impassioned entreaties on the necessity of privatizing Social Security, so I don't think that issue (or other domestic issues) caused the uptick in ratings.

That leaves Iraq. The public's responses to the series of questions we asked about Iraq this weekend have all become more positive. Ergo, it appears most likely that the American public's positive perceptions of the Iraqi elections may be the most important factor in the improved perceptions of the president.

Maybe the most important indicator of sentiment on Iraq is a simple question asking the public how things are going for the United States in Iraq. This measure has changed fairly dramatically. Fifty-three percent of Americans now say things are going well in Iraq, compared with 40% in early January. At the same time, 46% say things are going badly, down from 59% in January. The current level of positivity about Iraq is the highest since March of last year.

Was involvement in Iraq a mistake for the United States? Gallup has been using this basic measure of the public's feelings about the war since March 2003. (Before March 2003, Gallup used this question in conflicts stretching back to the Korean War.) The "mistake" numbers have been hovering around 50% for months. In mid-January, 52% of Americans said Iraq was a mistake. Now, that percentage has dropped to 45%, while 55% say it was not a mistake, the highest level for the latter measure since September 2004.

The trends on Gallup's measures of the public's approval of the president's handling of various aspects of his job also support the conclusion that Iraq more than anything else has benefited the president's standing. Bush's approval ratings on the economy have not gone up at all, and his rating on handling Social Security only increased by two points. But Bush's rating on handling foreign affairs is up four points, and he had the largest increase of all on approval of his handling of Iraq -- up eight points from January to 50% -- and the highest Iraq approval rating since March of last year.

It's possible Bush's State of the Union address had an indirect effect on his job approval rating, to the extent that the speech content and the guests in the audience called attention to the successful election in Iraq. But Iraq clearly was not the main focus of the speech. I think it's much more likely the positive fallout from the Iraqi elections is responsible for Bush's improved ratings.

Social Security

I just don't see much happening for Bush on the Social Security front. One might expect that the extraordinary focus on privatizing Social Security over the last week -- including Bush's State of the Union address and his late-week barnstorming trip to five states -- would have persuaded more Americans of the need for, and potential efficacy of, his plan to privatize Social Security.

But this didn't happen. There has been little change in Gallup's measures of Americans' attitudes toward Social Security. Americans are no more likely now than they were before last week to say Social Security is a crisis or a major problem, Bush's approval rating on handling Social Security (as noted) has not changed significantly, and support for privatizing Social Security has not changed at all since January. Well less than half of Americans (44%) say they approve of "George W. Bush's approach to addressing the Social Security system."

It's interesting to note that the current discussion about privatizing Social Security is not new. A review of Gallup polling annals on the issue of privatizing Social Security finds that Gallup was asking about the concept as long ago as 1991. We honed in on the issue in a 1998 poll (long before Bush had stepped onto the national political stage), and focused on it in numerous polls in the 2000 campaign (when Bush had brought it up) and on through to 2003.

One of our basic conclusions: Support for privatizing Social Security was strong -- well in majority territory -- up through 2003.

As the issue has become more hotly debated in the last couple of months, the polling data have shown much more varied levels of support, depending on how the concept is explained to respondents. In fact, Senior Gallup Poll Editor Lydia Saad and I found 17 different examples of ways in which polling firms have asked about privatizing Social Security since December, with support levels ranging over a 30-percentage point range. The lowest levels of support came in response to questions that reminded respondents of negative consequences of the privatization plan.

I think one additional fact is very important: The issue of privatizing Social Security has become heavily politicized. Much as he did in relationship to the war in Iraq, Bush has adopted the privatization issue as a personal crusade, engendering predictable and vociferous objections from his Democratic critics. Thus, it is highly possible that many Americans will simply react to the plan based on their overall evaluations of Bush himself, with Republicans approving it and Democrats opposing it. Debate on the issue of privatization could be reduced from one based on the merits of the system to one more simply based on who is backing it and who is not.

In general, the Democrats and anti-privatization forces may have an advantage in this debate. It is generally easier to criticize and oppose a significant policy change than it is to support it, as Bill and Hillary Clinton discovered in their failed attempt to change the U.S. healthcare system in 1993 and 1994.  

The significant opposition to privatization that develops when poll questions include qualifications or specifications of problems indicates the public can be quickly moved against the concept. Bush might still be able to persuade Congress to pass legislation privatizing Social Security, but sustaining support among the public may be a harder row to hoe.

Michael Jackson

About 7 in 10 Americans (69%) believe the charges that pop star Michael Jackson sexually abused a boy are probably or definitely true. That's little changed from the last time we asked a similar question a year ago.

President Abraham Lincoln

Although Presidents' Day won't be officially celebrated until Feb. 21, this Saturday is Abraham Lincoln's real birthday. Many historians consider Lincoln to be the greatest U.S. president of all time, but not all Americans agree. The last time we asked Americans to name the greatest president of all time in November 2003, Lincoln was basically tied with John F. Kennedy, receiving the most mentions at 17%. The next most popular response was Ronald Reagan at 13%. Lincoln did do better than his fellow February birthday celebrant, George Washington, in response to this "greatest president" question (Washington received 7% of mentions). When Americans were asked in 1999 which of these two was the greater president, Lincoln beat Washington by 68% to 27%.

Exercise Guidelines

New federal exercise guidelines released last month advise Americans to exercise 30 minutes to 90 minutes a day, and that's going to be a real stretch for many Americans. Gallup data show only 29% of Americans say they exercise vigorously three or more days a week, although 56% say they engage in moderate physical activity three or more times per week.

Based on a Gallup analysis of the self-reported data on exercise (which may include overestimates by respondents unwilling to admit to an interviewer that they rarely exercise), about half of Americans engage only in low levels of exercise or are essentially sedentary.

Exercise has a number of benefits, including in particular its role in helping people lose weight, which federal guidelines suggest is a high priority for much of the public. Indeed, 62% of Americans say they would like to lose weight, although only 29% say they are actually trying to lose weight at the time of the interview.

These data on losing weight highlight one of the obstacles to getting Americans to do things to improve their health. Most Americans who hear about the new exercise guidelines will probably agree with them in principle. (In the same way, Gallup Poll data show most smokers agree with the advice that they should stop smoking.) But following through on that advice is another thing.

Former U.S. Department of Health and Human Services Secretary Tommy Thompson made the issue sound simple in his remarks accompanying the new guidelines' promulgation: "It's really common sense. Do you want to look better? Yes. Do you want to feel better? Yes. If you do that, you lower your calorie intake, you lower your fats, your carbs, you eat more fruits and vegetables, more whole grain, and you exercise. And that's as simple as it can be."

Finding the discipline and motivation to follow through on this type of advice is obviously much more difficult than it is to agree with the rationale behind it. As noted, many Americans want to lose weight, but don't, and all of those smokers who agree they should stop hadn't stopped at the time of the Gallup survey.

Author(s)

Dr. Frank Newport is a Gallup Senior Scientist and the author of Polling Matters (Warner Books, 2004) and The Evangelical Voter.


Gallup https://news.gallup.com/poll/14878/presidential-approval-social-security-michael-jackson-abraham-linco.aspx
Gallup World Headquarters, 901 F Street, Washington, D.C., 20001, U.S.A
+1 202.715.3030