skip to main content
Iraq, Bolton and the United Nations, Abortion, Congressional Approval, Religion and Politics

Iraq, Bolton and the United Nations, Abortion, Congressional Approval, Religion and Politics

Iraq

The American Association for Public Opinion Research (AAPOR) conducted its annual meeting this past weekend in Miami Beach, Fla. There were a number of papers presented at the conference that analyzed data about last fall's presidential vote -- no surprise because the election was the biggest public opinion event of the year.

In addition to in-depth scrutiny of the exit-poll controversy, one theme that came through loud and clear at the conference was the importance of the Iraq war to George W. Bush's victory. In a paper presented at the conference, J. Merrill Shanks of the University of California, Berkeley, and three of his colleagues showed the invasion of Iraq was the "most important policy-related controversy in 2004 election" and had more influence than any other issue on all the "dependent variables" of the election.

Other research presented at the conference showed the same thing. Even controlling for the impact of partisan identification and other factors, voters' views on the Iraq war were the major determinant of presidential vote choice.

After the election last fall, everyone was talking about the impact moral values had on Bush's victory. The current news seems more focused on domestic issues, such as Social Security and judicial appointments, than it is on Iraq. But as I've indicated before, Iraq was apparently important last fall and it continues to be today. When Gallup recently asked Americans what they would talk about if they had 15 minutes with Bush, Iraq topped the list.

Greg Mitchell, the editor of Editor & Publisher magazine, recently raised an interesting point relating to public opinion and Iraq. In his May 15 column, Mitchell reviewed Bush's speeches just before the invasion of Iraq in March 2003 and notes how focused the president was on weapons of mass destruction as the justification for the war. Of course, no weapons were found, yet Bush was re-elected and the WMD issue simply doesn't appear to be as major as some might have expected.

I think it's worth mentioning that some recent polling continues to show many Americans believe the war may have some salubrious benefits in the long run for the Iraqi people. An ABC News/Washington Post poll conducted in mid-March, for example, found 67% of Americans think the Iraqi people are better off now than they were before the U.S.-led invasion of Iraq. Seventy-four percent said Iraqis will be better off in the long run.

Support for the war continues to be highly partisan. In Gallup's late April, early May poll, 76% of Republicans said the war was worth it, compared with 32% of independents and only 12% of Democrats.

Bolton and the United Nations

The contentious nomination of John Bolton as U.S. ambassador to the United Nations has cleared the Senate Foreign Relations Committee and moved to the Senate floor. Democrats are going to do what they can to stop the nomination, while Republicans press for a full Senate vote as soon as possible.

The arguments surrounding Bolton's nomination have focused on his suitability to represent the United States at the United Nations. The Bush administration has argued that a more aggressive representative is needed to shake up the United Nations. Many in the Bush administration see the United Nations unfavorably, particularly because the body failed to support the invasion of Iraq in 2003.

There is little doubt that the United Nations has image problems. Allegations of sexual abuse on the part of U.N. peacekeepers and reported corruption in the oil-for-food program are just two of the problems that have beset the international body in recent years. What do Americans think about the job the United Nations is doing?

Mike Allen of the Washington Post gave an interesting answer to that question a couple of weeks ago on CBS News' Face the Nation program. Allen said: "Eighty percent of the American people are suspicious of the United Nations."

Gallup staffers later called Allen and asked about the origin of that number. He said he did not quote the number from an original source (nor from Washington Post survey data) but rather that his comments reflected what he had heard from the White House. We looked and looked, but could find no specific reference to a publicly released poll that shows 80% of Americans are suspicious of the United Nations.

Gallup data, in fact, suggest the American public has somewhat mixed views on the United Nations. Gallup's February 2005 World Affairs poll shows only 36% of Americans believe the United Nations is doing a good job trying to solve the problems it has to face. Six in 10 (61%) say the United Nations is doing a bad job.

Gallup has asked this question many times over the last 50 years. The absolute low point came in 1985, when 28% said the United Nations was doing a good job. The most positive point on record was in February 2002, when 58% said the world body was doing a good job.

These negative sentiments don't mean Americans want the United States to get out of the United Nations altogether, as critics such as North Carolina Republican Sen. Jesse Helms and conservative commentator Pat Buchanan have called for over the years. About two-thirds of Americans (64%) say the United Nations is performing a necessary role in the world today, and only 13% say the United States should give up its membership in the organization.

Abortion?

The Senate will once again take up wrangling over Bush's judicial nominees Wednesday,  which in turn will lead to arguments over the Senate's filibuster rule. 

The subtext of this debate is the looming possibility that there will be at least one vacancy on the Supreme Court within months, and that the Senate will soon be voting on the confirmation of a new justice appointed by Bush. 

And the subtext of that possibility is the controversy over abortion. Conservatives are ever hopeful that at some point in the future, a more conservative Supreme Court will be in a position to make decisions that will limit abortion. Those on the other side of the debate obviously want the current Roe v. Wade decision to stand.

A recent analysis by Gallup Senior Editor Lydia Saad suggests the pro-life side of the argument may be more emotionally invested in the issue than the pro-choice side. While 48% of Americans call themselves pro-choice and 44% call themselves pro-life, only 39% of those who say the abortion position of future Supreme Court nominees is very important to them are pro-choice, while a majority -- 53% -- are pro-life. 

Questions specifically on the filibuster rule have been controversial to some degree, because critics argue the public responds based on how the question is read to them. That's certainly true, and I strongly advocate that anyone studying public opinion on this issue look carefully at the question wording while interpreting the results.

With that said, here's the latest poll question on the filibuster rule, asked in a TIME magazine poll released last weekend: "Some Republicans in the Senate want to eliminate the ability of Democrats to use the filibuster, or extended debate, to block the Senate from voting on some of President Bush's judicial nominees. Do you think the Republicans should or should not be able to eliminate the filibuster in this case?" Twenty-eight percent of Americans said Republicans should be able to eliminate the filibuster, while 59% said they should not.

Congressional Approval

Why is Congress approval now at 35%, its lowest point in about eight years? 

Sen. Edward Kennedy of Massachusetts thinks he knows. Over the weekend, Kennedy said on Face the Nation: "We have, in the last five months, failed to deal with the fundamental concerns of the American people. We haven't done anything at all, really, on education, except cut it. We haven't done anything on health care costs. They've increased. We haven't done anything to provide paid sick leave. We haven't done anything to provide the secretary of HHS the authority to negotiate drugs."

I think there is some validity to Kennedy's thesis. When Gallup questions Americans about what the country's problems are and what Congress' priorities should be, there are few mentions of judicial nominees, the filibuster rule, or removing feeding tubes from patients. In addition to the education and healthcare costs that Kennedy mentioned, Americans are also concerned about Iraq (discussed above) and the economy.

Gallup asked Americans in an early April poll to rate the importance of six separate issues for the president and Congress to deal with. Terrorism and healthcare costs top the list. "Changes to how the federal courts handle moral issues" appears at the bottom, with less than half saying this is an extremely or very important issue for Congress and the president to deal with.

Religion and Politics

An interesting analysis presented at AAPOR by Ariela Keysar and Barry Kosmin looked at the relationship between Americans' political party identification and their religious identification. The study used data from a large survey of more than 34,000 adults conducted in 2001. 

Which religion has the highest percentage identifying with the Republican Party? Keysar's and Kosmin's analysis suggests it's the Mormons, 55% of whom identify as Republican. Mormons are followed by mainline Christians (Methodists, Lutherans, Presbyterians, Episcopalians, etc.) with 38% GOP identification, Pentecostals with 37%, and Christians who don't place themselves into a specific denomination, also at 37%.

What about the Democrats? The data show Jewish Americans are the only group to have majority Democratic identification with 54%, followed by "other religions" with 40%, Baptists with 39%, and Catholics with 36%. The large number of blacks in the Baptist group helps explain the high percentage of Baptist Democrats. White Baptists are much less likely to identify as Democrats.

Interestingly, the analysis confirms that Americans who are apathetic in one realm of life tend to be apathetic in other realms. Americans who say they don't identify with any particular religion are more likely than any other group to identify as independent, meaning they don't identify with any particular political party. Americans who identify with Eastern religions such as Hinduism and Buddhism, as well as Islam, are also less likely than others to identify as Republican or Democrat.

Author(s)

Dr. Frank Newport is a Gallup Senior Scientist and the author of Polling Matters (Warner Books, 2004) and The Evangelical Voter.


Gallup https://news.gallup.com/poll/16378/Iraq-Bolton-United-Nations-Abortion-Congressional-Approval.aspx
Gallup World Headquarters, 901 F Street, Washington, D.C., 20001, U.S.A
+1 202.715.3030