The Economy
James Carville famously told the Bill Clinton campaign team back in 1992 that "the economy, stupid" was going to determine the outcome of the election. Sure enough, Clinton emphasized his plans to fix the bad economy, and George Bush 41 went down in defeat.
I was reminded of this famous dictum this week as we looked at the results of a fascinating set of questions on our latest Gallup Poll. Americans were asked whether they thought things had gotten better or gotten worse in this country over the last five years. The results showed that the "worse off" alternative won by more than a 2-to-1 margin.
Americans were asked to justify their answers in their own words. "In what ways," the poll asked, "have things gotten better/worse?"
The surprising thing that came through in the answers was the importance of the economy -- from the positive and negative sides of the ledger. Sixty-six percent of those who say things have gotten better over the past five years mention some aspect of the economy as their reason for being positive. Among those who say things have gotten worse over the past five years, 56% mention some aspect of the economy.
In other words, views of the economy are a real pivot point in terms of determining one's views of the overall situation in the United States today. This suggests, of course, that President George W. Bush really needs to hit home on economic issues in his State of the Union address Tuesday night, even though his ability to change people's minds is problematic. If Bush claims things are much better economically speaking (as he undoubtedly will), he will meet resounding agreement from those who are already convinced that the United States is in better shape now than it has been. But he will be greeted by rampant skepticism among those who are more negative. It's probably unlikely that his words are going to change many minds along these lines, but it's presumably an effort he needs to make. As the economy goes, it appears, so goes overall levels of satisfaction with life in the United States today.