skip to main content
Was Jimmy Carter Wrong About Katrina?, "Sour" Mood?

Was Jimmy Carter Wrong About Katrina?, "Sour" Mood?

Katrina: The Nation's Top Priority?

I was interested in a comment by former President Jimmy Carter on CNN's Larry King Live recently. Carter was talking about the Hurricane Katrina disaster, berating the administration for not following through on its promises for aid. In the course of the discussion, Carter said to King: "… I don't think any American, if there was a poll done, I think it would be 99 percent of all Americans would say let's give the Katrina victims top priority."

As it happens, a Jan. 20-22 CNN/USA Today/Gallup poll did include "the problems caused by Hurricane Katrina" in a list of possible issues with which the president and Congress should deal in the next year. 

Unfortunately, Carter was wrong in his assertion. In terms of the percentage of Americans rating each issue as "extremely important," the problems caused by Hurricane Katrina came in next to last in a list of seven issues. Just 35% of Americans rated Katrina problems as extremely important for the president and Congress to deal with, far below the 58% who rated the situation in Iraq as extremely important, the 57% who said terrorism is extremely important, and well below the extremely important ratings given healthcare policy, the economy, and corruption in government. Only immigration was rated below Hurricane Katrina problems in importance.

That's not to say that Americans aren't compassionate toward Katrina victims. I think they are. But the poll data suggest that the aftermath of Katrina is not -- as Carter suggested -- the public's top priority at the moment.

"Sour" Mood?

Here is a transcript of some discussion about media coverage of the State of the Union address on Fox News Watch from the other day: 

[ERIC] BURNS: Well, that obviously was the president delivering his State of the Union address on Tuesday night. But the word used by many in the media -- and Jim, I saw it more than one story -- to describe the mood of the country now was "sour." Did a bunch of people get together and decide that that would be the key word?

[JIM] PINKERTON: Well, I think the fact that three networks, including Fox, used the word "sour" is a reminder that the reporters live in a small bubble and they all talk to each other and get the same ideas and the same thing.

Well, I don't think the characterization of the mood of the country at the moment as "sour" is simply a result of a bunch of media types talking to each other in a bubble.

Almost all measures of the country's mood from recent months show that Americans are not happy campers. A majority of the people in the country are dissatisfied with the way things area going, almost two-thirds say things in the United States have gotten worse over the last five years, less than half are satisfied with the size and power of the federal government, a majority of 54% disapprove of the job President George W. Bush is doing, and an even larger 67% disapprove of the job Congress is doing. These data to me signify a pretty sour population at the moment.  

One of the great advantages of public opinion polling is that it allows reporters to get out of their bubble and accurately assess what the people of the country are thinking and feeling in a scientific, projectable way. And at the moment, polling indicates a pretty downbeat population.

To be sure, polls don't usually tell us where attitudes and moods come from. One can certainly argue that the news media are personally responsible for creating a depressed population by virtue of emphasizing negative news and downplaying the positive. Whatever the cause, however, it is fair, I think, to characterize the public today as being in a generally sour mood.

Author(s)

Dr. Frank Newport is a Gallup Senior Scientist and the author of Polling Matters (Warner Books, 2004) and The Evangelical Voter.


Gallup https://news.gallup.com/poll/21355/Jimmy-Carter-Wrong-About-Katrina-Sour-Mood.aspx
Gallup World Headquarters, 901 F Street, Washington, D.C., 20001, U.S.A
+1 202.715.3030