skip to main content

The Persistence of 34

I watched Jay Leno last night, and he referred to George W. Bush's poor job approval rating of 34%.That was the number from the recent CBS poll that has received so much media attention.  

It is interesting to me to see how that 34% number has persisted, nearly two weeks after the CBS poll was released. Since the CBS poll came out, there have been six other polls, with Bush approval ratings of 36% to 41%. The average of these polls is 39%. Some of the variation could be due to different polling dates, but three of the polls overlapped the CBS poll by anywhere from one to four days. 

My point is to not cast doubt on the validity of the CBS poll, nor is it to allege media bias. But mainly to point out how much media attention the 34% number has gotten, even after several polls have come out that place CBS' rating on the low range of Bush's approval rating. 

Among other reasons, the long shelf life of the CBS poll could be partly due to the following: First, it was the first poll on Bush in a while. People who study human memory demonstrate that initial information is usually more memorable than what comes after it. Second, the 34% estimate is obviously the most dramatic of the recent results and therefore probably more memorable to that average poll consumer than the other numbers around 40%. Last, the low rating and the drop CBS reported fits the conventional wisdom that Bush should have suffered as a result of the controversial Dubai ports deal, and perhaps the Cheney shooting incidents, the two major political stories since the State of the Union address, the last time most firms polled. Our polling indicates that Bush's approval has declined, but more gradually. CBS compared its 34% number with its January number of 42%. Most polls had Bush in the low 40s around the State of the Union. Our trend line shows Bush stayed in the low 40s into February, dropped to 39% near the middle of the month (in a Feb. 9-12 CNN/USA Today/Gallup poll before the ports deal was controversial; it was reported by the Associated Press on Feb. 11) and has stayed steady since. 

Survey

Dates

Approve


Dis-
approve

Unsure

Approve minus
disapprove

%

%

%

 

.

ABC/Washington Post

3/2-5/06

41

58

1

-17

FOX/Opinion Dynamics RV

2/28-3/1/06

39

54

7

-15

CNN/USA Today/Gallup

2/28-3/1/06

38

60

2

-22

L.A. Times/Bloomberg

2/25-3/1/06

38

58

4

-20

Quinnipiac RV

2/21-28/06

36

58

6

-22

Cook/RT Strategies

2/23-26/06

40

54

6

-14

CBS

2/22-26/06

34

59

7

-25


Gallup https://news.gallup.com/poll/21841/persistence.aspx
Gallup World Headquarters, 901 F Street, Washington, D.C., 20001, U.S.A
+1 202.715.3030