skip to main content
Americans Continue to Call Iraq Involvement a Mistake

Americans Continue to Call Iraq Involvement a Mistake

GALLUP NEWS SERVICE

PRINCETON, NJ -- The majority of Americans continue to believe that the Bush administration's decision to involve the U.S. in Iraq over three years ago was a mistake. At the same time, there is no clear-cut direction from the people about what to do now. Only one out of five Americans would like to see an immediate withdrawal of U.S. troops from Iraq. The vast majority favor an eventual withdrawal of troops, but disagree as to the timetable, with some favoring removal within 12 months' time, and others only when it is possible to turn the country over to the Iraqis. There continue to be strong partisan differences in views on the Iraq war.

Mistake?

Fifty-six percent of Americans now say it was a mistake for the United States to have become involved in the Iraq war, while 41% say it was not.

Gallup has asked this question about Iraq nine times this year, involving more than 7,500 interviews. The average percentage of Americans saying the war was a mistake over this time period has been 54%, and at no point this year has this measure dropped below 50%.

Americans were first asked about the Iraq war using this "mistake" question format in March 2003, at which time just 23% replied in the affirmative.

As it became clearer that the invasion had led to increased chaos and insurgent activity in Iraq rather than a stable democracy, the percentage of Americans saying U.S. involvement was a mistake began to climb. By June 2004, for the first time, a majority of Americans said they believed the war to be a mistake.

Thus, it took a year and three months for public opinion to change to the point where a majority disagreed with the basic decision to go to war in Iraq. (In contrast, it was not until August 1968 that a majority of Americans said involvement in the Vietnam War had been a mistake. This was more than three years after the initial decision to send large numbers of troops to Vietnam.)

Americans' views on the Iraq war have fluctuated over the last two years. The "mistake" percentage dropped to 38% in September 2004 -- after the successful Republican convention and official renomination of George W. Bush for president.

For the remainder of 2004 and throughout 2005, the percentage of Americans saying the war was a mistake was sometimes above, and sometimes below, the 50% mark. Americans were most negative in September of last year, when 59% said the war was a mistake.

As noted, all nine measures this year have shown at least half of the public saying the war was a mistake.

It comes as no surprise to find that views on the war are intensely partisan. In this latest poll, just 22% of Republicans say the war was a mistake, compared with an overwhelming 79% of Democrats (and 62% of independents).

There is a close connection between Americans' views of President Bush in general and their views on the war. Only 20% of those who approve of the job Bush is doing as president say the war was a mistake, compared with 80% of those who in general disapprove of the job Bush is doing.

In America today, there is a close connection between an individual's religion and his or her political views. It follows, then, that there is a strong relationship between various measures of religion and views on Iraq:

  • Protestants and other non-Catholic Christians are most supportive of the war, with 49% saying the war was a mistake and 49% saying it was not.
  • Catholics are more negative than other Christians, with 62% saying the war was a mistake.
  • Non-Christians and those with no religion are the most negative of all. Seventy-two percent of the former and 69% of the latter say the war was a mistake.
  • Only 46% of those who attend church weekly say the war was a mistake, compared with 63% of those who attend less than once a month.

What to Do Now?

Despite the majority opinion that the United States' initial decision to send troops to Iraq was a mistake, there is no consensus about what to do now. Most Americans favor a reduction of U.S. troops, but there is no clear-cut direction from the public about a specific timetable for troop withdrawal.

Only 19% of Americans favor immediate withdrawal. One-third favor a timetable that would withdraw all U.S. troops within a year. Another 38% favor an option that specifies taking "as many years to do this as are needed to turn control over to the Iraqis." A small 7% want more troops sent to Iraq.

There has been little substantive change in these views over the five times this question has been asked since November 2005.

Of interest is the fact that a broadly similar pattern of responses was obtained when this question was asked about U.S. involvement in Vietnam in the summer of 1970 -- 23% favored immediate withdrawal, 25% withdrawal within a year, 33% withdrawal in as many years as needed, and 10% favored an increase in troops.

Despite calls for immediate withdrawal by some Democratic leaders in recent months, only 30% of Democrats favor that option.

Given that 44% of Democrats favor a one-year timetable for withdrawal of troops, it can be said that three-quarters of Democrats do favor withdrawal of troops within the next year. The majority of Republicans, on the other hand, favor the option that closely mirrors the administration's position -- withdrawal only when the country is ready to be turned over to the Iraqis.

Survey Methods

The latest results are based on telephone interviews with a randomly selected national sample of 1,005 adults, aged 18 and older, conducted July 21-23, 2006. For results based on this sample, one can say with 95% confidence that the maximum error attributable to sampling and other random effects is ±3 percentage points. In addition to sampling error, question wording and practical difficulties in conducting surveys can introduce error or bias into the findings of public opinion polls.

Turning to Iraq,

9. In view of the developments since we first sent our troops to Iraq, do you think the United States made a mistake in sending troops to Iraq, or not?

Yes,
a mistake

No, not

No
opinion

Iraq

%

%

%

2006 Jul 21-23

56

41

2

2006 Jun 23-25

55

43

1

2006 Jun 9-11

51

46

2

2006 Apr 7-9

57

42

1

2006 Mar 10-12 ^

57

42

1

2006 Feb 28-Mar 1

55

43

2

2006 Feb 9-12 ^

55

42

3

2006 Jan 20-22

51

46

3

2006 Jan 6-8 ^

50

47

3

2005 Dec 16-18

52

46

2

2005 Dec 9-11

48

50

2

2005 Nov 11-13 ^

54

45

1

2005 Oct 28-30

54

45

1

2005 Oct 21-23

49

49

2

2005 Sep 16-18

59

39

2

2005 Sep 8-11

53

46

1

2005 Aug 28-30

53

46

1

2005 Aug 5-7 ^

54

44

2

2005 Jul 22-24

46

53

1

2005 Jun 24-26

53

46

1

2005 Apr 29-May 1 ^

49

48

3

2005 Mar 18-20 ^

46

51

3

2005 Feb 25-27

47

51

2

2005 Feb 4-6

45

55

*

2005 Jan 14-16

52

47

1

2005 Jan 7-9

50

48

2

2004 Nov 19-21

47

51

2

2004 Oct 29-31 ^

44

52

4

2004 Oct 22-24

47

51

2

2004 Oct 14-16

47

52

1

2004 Oct 9-10 ^

46

53

1

2004 Oct 1-3

48

51

1

2004 Sep 24-26

42

55

3

2004 Sep 3-5 ^

38

57

5

2004 Aug 23-25 ^

48

50

2

2004 Jul 30-Aug 1

47

51

2

2004 Jul 19-21

50

47

3

2004 Jul 8-11 ^

54

45

1

2004 Jun 21-23 ^

54

44

2

2004 Jun 3-6 ^

41

58

1

2004 May 7-9 ^

44

54

2

2004 Apr 16-18 ^

42

57

1

2004 Jan 12-15 ^

42

56

2

2003 Nov 3-5 ^

39

60

1

2003 Oct 6-8 ^

40

59

1

2003 Jul 7-9 ^

27

72

1

2003 Mar 24-25 ^

23

75

2

Afghanistan

2004 Jul 19-21

25

72

3

2002 Jan 7-9

6

93

1

2001 Nov 8-11

9

89

2

Yugoslavia

1999 Jun 4-5

43

53

4

1999 Apr 21

42

51

7

Persian GulfWar

1991 Jul 18-21

15

82

3

1991 Feb 28-Mar 3

10

87

3

1991 Feb 7-10

21

76

3

1991 Jan 30-Feb 2

18

80

2

1991 Jan 23-26

18

77

5

1991 Jan 17-20

16

80

4

1991 Jan 11-13

29

65

6

1991 Jan 3-6

30

61

9

1990 Dec 6-9

28

66

6

1990 Nov 29-Dec 2

29

66

5

1990 Nov 15-18

27

65

8

1990 Nov 8-11

27

68

5

1990 Nov 2-4

25

67

8

1990 Aug 30-Sep 2

16

76

8

1990 Aug 23-26

18

76

6

1990 Aug 16-19

17

75

8

1990 Aug 30-Sep 2

16

76

8

1990 Aug 23-26

18

76

6

1990 Aug 16-19

17

75

8

1990 Oct 25-28

24

71

5

1990 Oct 18-21

26

67

7

1990 Oct 11-14

27

68

5

1990 Oct 3-4

21

71

8

1990 Sep 27-30

20

73

7

1990 Sep 14-16

18

73

10

1990 Sep 10-11

19

76

5

Q.9 (MISTAKE SENDING TROOPS) CONTINUED

Yes, a
mistake

No, not

No
opinion

VietnamWar

%

%

%

2000 Nov 13-15

69

24

7

1995 Apr 21-24

71

23

6

1990 Mar 15-18

74

22

4

1973 Jan 12-15

60

29

11

1971 May 14-17

61

28

11

1971 Jan 8-11

60

31

9

1970 May 21-26

56

36

8

1970 Apr 2-7

51

34

15

1970 Jan 15-20

57

32

11

1969 Sep 17-22

58

32

10

1969 Jan 23-28

52

39

9

1968 Sep 26-Oct 1

54

37

9

1968 Aug 7-12

53

35

12

1968 Apr 4-9

48

40

12

1968 Feb 22-27

49

42

9

1968 Feb 1-6

46

42

12

1967 Dec 7-12

45

46

9

1967 Oct 6-11

47

44

9

1967 Jul 13-18

41

48

11

1967 Apr 19-24

37

50

13

1967 Jan 26-31

32

52

16

1966 Nov 10-15

31

52

17

1966 Sep 8-13

35

48

17

1966 May 5-10

36

49

15

1966 Mar 3-8

26

59

15

1965 Aug 27-Sep 1

24

60

16

Yes, a
mistake

No, not

No opinion

Korean War

%

%

%

2000 Jun 6-7

34

47

19

1953 Jan 11-16

36

50

14

1952 Oct 17-22

43

37

19

1952 Oct 9-14

43

37

20

1952 Feb 28-Mar 5

51

35

14

1951 Aug 3-8

42

48

11

1951 Jun 16-21

43

40

17

1951 Apr 16-21

37

45

18

1951 Mar 26-31

45

43

12

1951 Feb 4-9

49

41

9

1951 Jan 1-5

49

38

13

1950 Aug 20-25

20

65

15

AFGHANISTAN WORDING: Do you think the United States made a mistake in sending military forces to Afghanistan, or not?

YUGOSLAVIA WORDING: In view of the developments since we entered the fighting in Yugoslavia, do you think the United States made a mistake sending military forces to fight in Yugoslavia?

PERSIAN GULF WAR WORDING (Feb. 28-Mar 3, 1991-Jul. 18-21, 1991): In view of the developments since we first sent our troops to the Persian Gulf region, do you think the United States made a mistake in sending troops to the Persian Gulf region, or not?

PERSIAN GULF WAR WORDING (Aug. 16-19, 1990-Feb. 7-10, 1990): In view of the developments since we first sent our troops to Saudi Arabia, do you think the United States made a mistake in sending troops to Saudi Arabia, or not?

VIETNAM WAR WORDING (1990-2000): Looking back, do you think the United States made a mistake sending troops to fight in Vietnam?

VIETNAM WAR WORDING (1965-1973): In view of the developments since we entered the fighting in Vietnam, do you think the U.S. made a mistake sending troops to fight in Vietnam?

KOREAN WAR WORDING (2000): Based on what you have heard or read, do you think the United States made a mistake in going into the war in Korea, or not?

KOREAN WAR WORDING (Feb. 1951-Jan. 1953): Do you think the United States made a mistake in going into the war in Korea, or not?

KOREAN WAR WORDING (Aug. 1950-Jan. 1951): In view of the developments since we entered the fighting in Korea, do you think the United States made a mistake in deciding to defend Korea, or not?

10. Here are four different plans the U.S. could follow in dealing with the war in Iraq. Which ONE do you prefer -- [ROTATED: withdraw all troops from Iraq immediately, withdraw all troops by August 2007 -- that is, in 12 months' time, withdraw troops, but take as many years to do this as are needed to turn control over to the Iraqis, (or) send more troops to Iraq]?



With-
draw
imme-
diately


With-
draw in
12 months'
time

With-
draw,
take as
many
years as
needed

Send more troops

No
opinion

%

%

%

%

%

2006 Jul 21-23

19

33

38

7

2

2006 Jun 23-25

17

33

41

8

1

2006 Jun 9-11

17

32

42

6

3

2006 Mar 10-12

19

35

39

4

3

2005 Nov 11-13

19

33

38

7

3

Trends for Comparison: The Vietnam War -- Here are four different plans the U.S. could follow in dealing with the war in Vietnam. Which ONE do you prefer? Plan A: Withdraw all troops from Vietnam immediately; Plan B: Withdraw all troops by July, 1971 -- that is, in 12 months time; Plan C: Withdraw troops but take as many years to do this as are needed to turn the war over to the South Vietnamese; or Plan D: Send more troops to Vietnam and step up the fighting?



With-
draw
imme-
diately


With-
draw in
12 months'
time

With-
draw,
take as
many
years as
needed

Send more troops

No
opinion

1970 Jul 31-Aug 2

23%

25

33

10

9


Gallup https://news.gallup.com/poll/23923/americans-continue-call-iraq-involvement-mistake.aspx
Gallup World Headquarters, 901 F Street, Washington, D.C., 20001, U.S.A
+1 202.715.3030