skip to main content
Americans Not Convinced That Local Schools Are in Crisis

Americans Not Convinced That Local Schools Are in Crisis

GALLUP NEWS SERVICE

PRINCETON, NJ -- Although the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation has focused much of its charitable efforts on eradicating disease around the world, the foundation also has as one of its goals improving education in the United States. To date, the Gates Foundation has given more than a billion dollars to improve high schools and more than a billion dollars in scholarships.

When the couple appeared on Oprah Winfrey's television show recently, the talk show hostess applauded them for "sounding the alarm" about education, and echoed the notion that America is in grave danger of losing its status as world leader unless the school system is fixed now. She also stated the country is "face to face with a frightening national emergency."

Winfrey referred to a special TIME magazine poll conducted earlier this year. Winfrey reported that the poll found, among other things, that "sixty one percent of Americans think that the public school system is in crisis."

While the value of investing more money in the nation's public schools is probably not broadly controversial, there is a valid question about whether or not the nation's public schools are really "in crisis" from the public's perspective.

In fact, while Americans will agree that there are major problems with the public school system across the country, a more detailed analysis of available polling data shows that Americans are much more positive when asked about schools in their local community, and that parents of students in the nation's public schools are even more positive when asked about the school their child attends. In short, while people tend to agree that schools are in trouble "out there" across the country, there is much less indication of dissatisfaction when Americans evaluate the public schools in situations they know best.

"Out There" versus Local

The latest evidence for this phenomenon comes from the recently released 38th Annual Phi Delta Kappa/Gallup Poll of the Public's Attitudes Toward the Public Schools. The survey shows that only 21% of American adults are willing to give the "public schools nationally" a grade of A or B (using the traditional A,B, C, D, F grading system), while 51% give the nation's public schools a C, and 17% say they deserve a D or an F.

The PDK/Gallup poll also asked Americans to rate the public schools "in your community", and found considerably more positive results. Forty-nine percent gave them an A or a B, 32% a C, and 14% a D or an F.

Finally, the poll shows that 64% of parents who had children in public schools gave their particular child's school an A or a B, only 24% have them a C, and 9% a D or an F.

Giving a Grade to the Public Schools*

Public schools in nation as a whole

Public schools in your community

(Parents) Public school your oldest child attends

%

%

%

A

2

13

26

B

19

36

38

C

51

32

24

D

14

9

5

F

3

5

4

Don't know

11

5

3

A+B combined

21

49

64

D+F combined

14

14

9

* Source: PDK/Gallup Poll of the Public's Attitudes Toward the Public Schools, 2006.

So, to the extent public believes there is a crisis in public schools, this mostly appears to be perception from afar. Schools look much better the closer Americans get to them.

Pollsters traditionally find similar patterns in terms of Americans' ratings of other issues and concerns, including healthcare, Congress, and crime. Asked to comment on the state of affairs nationally, Americans -- who usually have little experiential basis for making such judgments -- appear to rely on media reports which typically tend to focus on problems, worse cases, and negative examples. Asked to comment on something local, on the other hand, Americans apparently focus on what they know and see, and these evaluations are usually much more positive.

The fact that Americans are pretty positive about their local area schools and the schools their children attend doesn't necessarily negate the importance of spending money to address problems in some of the nation's schools. The Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation may well focus most of its efforts on the schools at the bottom end of the performance distribution. In fact, it is worth noting that 9% of parents of students in public schools give their schools a D or an F grade, and it may be these types of schools which will be the recipients of most of the Gates Foundation aid.

But the idea that the public school system in general has crisis level problems is not borne out by the perceptual data from the average American.

An open-ended question asked in the PDK/Gallup poll also merits some interest. Participants were asked -- "What do you think are the biggest problems the public schools of your community must deal with?" As the PDK analysis concludes: "Discipline was the top problem for the poll's first 16 years. Drugs then took over and occupied the top position alone until financial support drew into a tie in 1991. Frequent changes occurred in the Nineties until lack of financial support came back to the top in 2000. It has held that position in each poll since."

What do you think are the biggest problems the public schools of your community must deal with?*

National Totals

No Children in School

Public School Parents

'06
%

'05
%

'04
%

'06
%

'05
%

'04
%

'06
%

'05
%

'04
%

Lack of financial support/funding/money

24

20

21

25

19

22

21

21

20

Overcrowded schools

13

11

10

12

9

9

16

15

13

Lack of discipline, more control

11

10

10

8

9

7

7

8

7

Use of drugs/dope

8

9

7

8

9

7

7

8

7

Pupils' lack of interest

6

*

3

6

*

4

6

*

2

Parents lack of support

5

12

4

5

2

5

6

3

3

Fighting/violence/gangs

5

8

6

6

7

6

4

10

6

* Less than .5%

* Source: PDK/Gallup Poll of the Public's Attitudes Toward the Public Schools, 2006.

All in all, it appears that Americans believe that lack of money, more than anything else, is the biggest problem faced by public schools today. To the degree that the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation is pouring billions into the schools, they certainly would seem to be focusing on a real need as perceived by the average American.

Other Findings of Interest

Several other findings from the annual PDK/Gallup poll are of interest:

By in large, the American public continues to want control of their public schools to be lodged in their local school board, not in the state or federal government.

In your opinion, who should have the greatest influence in deciding what is taught in the public schools here -- the federal government, the state government, or the local school board?*


National totals

No children in schools

Public school parents

The federal government

14%

13%

15%

The state government

26

26

28

The local school board

58

59

55

Don't know

2

2

2

* Source: PDK/Gallup Poll of the Public's Attitudes Toward the Public Schools, 2006.

The American public is becoming increasingly familiar with the No Child Left Behind Act (NCLB), passed by Congress in 2001, but there are no signs that this has been accompanied by a concomitant increase in positive evaluations of NCLB.

In the time span between 2003 and this year, the percentage of American adults who say they know a great deal or a fair amount about NCLB has gone from 24% to 45%.

Now, here are a few questions about the No Child Left Behind Act. How much, if anything, would you say you know about the No Child Left Behind Act - the federal education bill that was passed by Congress in 2001 - a great deal, a fair amount, very little, or nothing at all?**

National totals

No children in schools

Public school parents

'06
%

'05
%

'04
%

'03
%

'06
%

'05
%

'04
%

'03
%

'06
%

'05
%

'04
%

'03
%

Great deal + fair amount

45

40

31

24

42

39

28

25

49

45

37

22

A great deal

8

8

7

6

6

8

6

5

11

10

8

7

A fair amount

37

32

24

18

36

31

22

20

38

35

29

15

Very little

40

43

40

40

41

44

41

37

37

40

38

44

Nothing at all

15

16

28

36

17

16

30

38

13

14

24

34

Don't know

*

1

1

*

*

1

1

*

1

1

1

*

Very little + nothing at all

55

59

68

76

58

60

71

75

50

54

62

78

* Less than 0.5%

** Source: PDK/Gallup Poll of the Public's Attitudes Toward the Public Schools, 2006.

But the ratio of favorable to unfavorable opinions about NCLB has been and remains roughly split.

From what you know or have heard or read about the No Child Left Behind Act, do you have a very favorable, somewhat favorable, somewhat unfavorable, or very unfavorable opinion of the act - or don't you know enough about it to say?**

National Totals

Know great deal/fair amount

'06
%

'05
%

'04
%

'03
%

'06
%

Very + somewhat favorable

32

28

24

18

42

Very favorable

9

7

7

5

12

Somewhat favorable

23

21

17

13

30

Somewhat unfavorable

18

15

12

7

24

Very unfavorable

13

12

8

6

23

Don't know enough to say

37

45

55

69

10

Don't know

*

*

1

*

1

Somewhat unfavorable + very unfavorable

31

27

20

13

47

* Less than 0.5%

** Source: PDK/Gallup Poll of the Public's Attitudes Toward the Public Schools, 2006.

In similar fashion, there is no consensus about the impact of NCLB on the public schools in respondents' local communities. About half of the American public in general doesn't have an opinion about the impact of NCLB. But among those who do, 26% say it is helping the public schools in the local community while 21% say it is hurting them. Among those who know a great deal or a fair amount about the act, the ratio of helping to hurting is 29% to 31%, perhaps suggesting that familiarity with NCLB breeds more contempt, to some degree.

Just your impression, how would you rate the overall impact of the No Child Left Behind program on the public schools in your community? Would you say it was helping, hurting, or making no difference in the performance of the local public schools?*

National totals
%

Know a great deal/fair amount
%

Helping

26

29

Hurting

21

31

Making no difference

37

37

Don't know

16

3

* Source: PDK/Gallup Poll of the Public's Attitudes Toward the Public Schools, 2006.

Survey Methods

The latest results are based on telephone interviews with a randomly selected national sample of 1,007 adults, aged 18 and older, conducted June 11-July 5, 2006. For results based on this sample, one can say with 95% confidence that the maximum error attributable to sampling and other random effects is ± 3 percentage points.


Gallup https://news.gallup.com/poll/24244/Americans-Convinced-Local-Schools-Crisis.aspx
Gallup World Headquarters, 901 F Street, Washington, D.C., 20001, U.S.A
+1 202.715.3030