skip to main content
Majority Predicts History Will Judge Bush Harshly

Majority Predicts History Will Judge Bush Harshly

GALLUP NEWS SERVICE

PRINCETON, NJ -- That ticking sound in the Oval Office may seem louder to President George W. Bush now that there are only two years left on the timer for his presidency. Focusing on his legacy may be more satisfying than dealing with the newly elected Democratic Congress, but a new USA Today/Gallup poll suggests it won't be any easier. According to the Dec. 8-10, 2006 survey, more than half of Americans predict Bush will go down in history as a "below average" or a "poor" president. Only 19% think history will judge him as exemplary (as either "outstanding" or "above average").

The poll asked about the six most recent presidents, from Gerald Ford through George W. Bush.

Fifty-four percent of Americans believe history will consider Bush a below average or poor president. The closest any of the previous five presidents comes to that level is Bill Clinton, with 25% of Americans expecting history to judge him harshly.

Few Americans predict that either Gerald Ford or George H.W. Bush will be remembered as stellar presidents. Their 23% and 32% outstanding/above average scores, respectively, are not that much better than the current president's 19%. But, rather than predicting history to be critical of Ford and the elder Bush as they do for the current Bush, half or more of Americans believe Gerald Ford and George H.W. Bush will be remembered as "average."

George W. Bush's ratings are nearly the inverse of the most lauded of recent presidents -- Ronald Reagan. Nearly two-thirds of Americans believe Reagan will go down in history as an outstanding or above average president; only 10% believe he will be judged harshly. 

Legacy vs. Job Approval

According to the new poll, 38% of Americans approve of the job Bush is doing as president while 59% disapprove. Thus, there is nearly a one-to-one correspondence between the percentage disapproving of Bush and the percentage saying he will be remembered as a subpar president (59% vs. 54%, respectively). Two years ago, there was a bigger gap between these figures (49% disapproval vs. 38% subpar rating).

What has happened is that people who disapprove of the job Bush is doing have grown more intense in their feelings. In June 2004, only 62% of those disapproving of his job performance said he would go down in history as subpar. Today that figure is 85%.

Bush's supporters are much less extreme in their predictions about Bush's legacy than his opponents are in theirs. Only 46% of those who approve of Bush's job performance say he will be remembered as a superior president. The rest of his supporters mostly believe he will be remembered as just average.

This indication of the intensity of anti-Bush sentiment is different from the pattern with most other recent presidents. With presidents Ford, Reagan, and the elder Bush, the percentages saying each would be remembered as below average or poor were generally much lower than the percentages disapproving of their job performance at the points in time the two dimensions of opinion were measured. However, like Bush, Clinton's job disapproval and negative legacy ratings were also very similar. 

A Troublesome Comparison

Bush's current image ratings appear to be similar to those of former president Richard Nixon who resigned in disgrace in 1974 over his role in the Watergate affair. Gallup last measured public opinion about Nixon's legacy in June 2004, at which time 14% of Americans thought he would be considered an outstanding or above average president, 34% said he would be considered average, and 51% predicted he would be remembered as below average or poor.

Whether Bush's current legacy ratings would be similar to Nixon's if the two were rated in the same poll is, however, unclear. It is possible that each president's ratings are affected by the context of other presidents included on the list, thus making the evaluations more relative in nature, rather than absolute.

Survey Methods

Results are based on telephone interviews with 1,009 national adults, aged 18 and older, conducted Dec. 8-10, 2006. For results based on the total sample of national adults, one can say with 95% confidence that the maximum margin of sampling error is ±3 percentage points. In addition to sampling error, question wording and practical difficulties in conducting surveys can introduce error or bias into the findings of public opinion polls.

3. How do you think each of the following presidents will go down in history -- as an outstanding president, above average, average, below average, or poor? [RANDOM ORDER]

2006 Dec 8-10
(sorted by "outstanding/above average")

Outstanding
/Above average

Average

Below
average/
Poor

%

%

%

Ronald Reagan

64

26

10

Bill Clinton

45

29

25

Jimmy Carter

38

38

22

George H.W. Bush

32

50

18

Gerald Ford

23

60

12

George W. Bush

19

27

54

FULL TRENDS:

A. The current president, George W. Bush

Out-
standing

Above
average

Average

Below
average

Poor

No
opinion

%

%

%

%

%

%

2006 Dec 8-10

4

15

27

25

29

*

 

 

 

 

 

 

2004 Jun 3-6

6

25

30

23

15

1

* = Less than 0.5%

B.  Bill Clinton

Out-
tanding

Above
average

Average

Below
average

Poor

No
opinion

%

%

%

%

%

%

2006 Dec 8-10

12

33

29

15

10

*

 

 

 

 

 

 

2004 Jun 3-6

9

29

31

18

13

*

2002 Jan 11-14

12

27

32

11

17

1

2001 Jan 5-7

15

32

30

11

11

1

2000 Jul 14-16

6

27

39

13

14

1

2000 Feb 14-15

8

29

34

12

16

1

1999 Feb 8-9

11

29

27

13

18

2

1998 Jan 24-25

8

23

37

16

14

2

1998 Jan 23-24

7

23

41

14

14

1

1997 Jan 31-Feb 2

6

30

47

8

8

1

* = Less than 0.5%

C. The former president, George Bush, the father of the current president

Out-
standing

Above
average

Average

Below
average

Poor

No
opinion

%

%

%

%

%

%

2006 Dec 8-10

5

27

50

10

8

*

 

 

 

 

 

 

2004 Jun 3-6

3

23

55

12

6

1

1999 Aug 3-4 ^

7

34

46

8

4

1

1993 Jan 8-11 ^

6

30

51

8

4

1

^ = WORDING: George Bush

* = Less than 0.5%

D. Ronald Reagan

Out-
standing

Above
average

Average

Below
average

Poor

No
opinion

%

%

%

%

%

%

2006 Dec 8-10

24

40

26

6

4

1

 

 

 

 

 

 

2004 Jun 3-6 ^

15

43

31

6

4

1

1999 Aug 3-4

12

42

34

7

6

*

1993 Jan 8-11

8

30

37

15

9

1

1988 Dec 27-29

17

42

25

9

5

2

1988 Sep 9-11

12

40

24

11

9

4

1987 Jul 10-13

9

28

35

16

10

3

1986 Mar 7-10

16

46

23

8

5

2

1985 Jan 25-28

15

40

27

9

5

4

^ = Reagan passed away on June 5, 2006. Interviewing from June 3-4 showed 12%
giving him an outstanding rating, 41% above average, 33% average, 8% below
average, and 5% poor.

* = Less than 0.5%

E. Jimmy Carter

Out-
standing

Above
average

Average

Below
average

Poor

No
opinion

%

%

%

%

%

%

2006 Dec 8-10

11

27

38

13

9

3

 

 

 

 

 

 

2004 Jun 3-6

5

22

48

17

7

1

1999 Aug 3-4

6

24

50

13

5

2

1993 Jan 8-11

3

13

40

27

14

3

1981 Jan 30-Feb 2

5

19

37

26

11

2

1980 Dec 5-8

3

11

37

31

15

3

F. Gerald Ford

Out-
standing

Above
average

Average

Below
average

Poor

No
opinion

%

%

%

%

%

%

2006 Dec 8-10

6

17

60

9

3

5

 

 

 

 

 

 

2004 Jun 3-6

2

12

66

13

4

3

1976 Dec 10-13

5

20

50

15

7

4


Gallup https://news.gallup.com/poll/25882/Majority-Predicts-History-Will-Judge-Bush-Harshly.aspx
Gallup World Headquarters, 901 F Street, Washington, D.C., 20001, U.S.A
+1 202.715.3030