Skip to main content

Protests by Blacks Over Amadou Diallo Verdict Not Surprising Given Long-Standing Perceptions Among Blacks That They Are Discriminated Against in Most Areas of Their Daily Lives

The protests among those in the black community over the innocent verdict in the Amadou Diallo trial should not come as a great surprise to those who study public opinion data on race-related issues. The Gallup Poll Social Audit, conducted annually since 1997, continues to show that blacks in this country are highly likely to perceive that they are treated less fairly than whites, and these perceptions of discrimination have been increasing, rather than decreasing, over the last several years.

By Frank Newport

PRINCETON, NJ -- The protests among those in the black community over the innocent verdict in the Amadou Diallo trial should not come as a great surprise to those who study public opinion data on race-related issues. The Gallup Poll Social Audit, conducted annually since 1997, continues to show that blacks in this country are highly likely to perceive that they are treated less fairly than whites, and these perceptions of discrimination have been increasing, rather than decreasing, over the last several years.

The general perception of fair treatment on the part of black Americans -- now at only 36% -- is lower than it was in 1997, when 49% of blacks thought that they were treated fairly. Additionally, although their rating of fair treatment has fluctuated in the years prior to 1997, it is important to note that in the 1960s blacks had more positive ratings of the fairness of the way they were treated (in the 41% to 44% range) than they do now.

In short, only a little more than a third of blacks in this country today feel that they are being treated, in the most general sense, the same way that whites are treated, and these feelings are not too much different from those Gallup measured more than 30 years ago.

These perceptions of less than fair treatment also occur consistently when blacks are asked about such issues as employment, education and housing. And, germane to the Diallo trial, black perceptions of differential treatment are particularly acute in the context of dealings with police. Three different Gallup Poll Social Audit surveys taken over the last three years document that between 55% and 64% of blacks say that they are treated less fairly than whites in their dealings with police. These perceptions occur across the spectrum of African Americans, but are particularly high among blacks who are below the age of 35 (72%), who live in the East (76%) and who are college educated (79%).

Perceptions do not necessarily reflect immediate personal experience, of course. When asked specifically about unfair treatment by police, a much lower percentage of blacks, 20%, say that they have had such experiences over the past 30 days. Still, one in five in the past month is a sobering number. And, whether based on direct experience or not, a basic social psychological principle states that if a person perceives the situation as real, the consequences will be real. This suggests that blacks' perceptions of police behavior, their attitudes toward the police, and their more general cynicism about racial fairness in their communities, are in a very real sense as important as what actually occurs on the streets. Indeed, these attitudes provide the context for African Americans' understanding of current events, and at least suggest the possibility that blacks' interpretation of what police may perceive to be normal operating procedures will be much more skeptical than would be the case for white citizens.

The Social Audit series of polls also shows conclusively that whites don't agree with black perceptions on the issue of black treatment. While 36% of blacks say that, in general, they are treated the same way that whites are, 74% of whites say that blacks are treated the same way whites are treated. And, while 64% of blacks say that they are treated less fairly by police, only 30% of whites agree.

The verdict acquitting white police officers of the murder of Amadou Diallo simply played into these existing perceptions. Whites may be puzzled at the protests, but to blacks, unfair treatment by police is nothing new, and the perception that what the police did was wrong was apparently for many an extension of what they already believed.