skip to main content
Questions and Answers About Public Opinion and the Situation in Florida

Questions and Answers About Public Opinion and the Situation in Florida

Senior Scientist

PRINCETON, NJ --

The presidential election situation in Florida is now officially being fought in the courts, and the outcome there rests on the interpretation of laws, precedents and arguments. Why be concerned about public opinion at all?

There is, in fact, no official role left for the public in this process -- unless a revote of some type is ordered in a Florida county or across the entire state, a very remote possibility.

Yet, there can be little doubt that in a democracy, public opinion is and should be an integral part of matters relating to the governing of the country. Whatever happens, the new president will be the representative of the public and will be required to serve with the authority granted him by the people. How the people view this process, in other words, is a very important component of its ultimate outcome.

For one thing, public opinion may well be an instrumental factor in helping determine the degree to which either candidate pursues legal and other options to keep the race open, as opposed to conceding. When and if public opinion turns strongly against one or the other candidate in this situation, it will be very difficult for him to continue his pursuit of the office. Additionally, the public’s acceptance of whatever outcome ensues may be an important factor in the operation of the U.S. government over the next four years -- regardless of whoever becomes the next president. A president viewed as having arrived at the office illegitimately would undoubtedly be in a less certain and less powerful position than one whose ascension to the White House has the public’s imprimatur of legitimacy. And the way in which the public views the process may have as yet unknown repercussions on the course of future elections and faith in the overall democratic process in years to come.

The two candidates, and their campaign teams, are well aware of the ultimate importance of the public’s views of the process. The result has been an almost continuous parade of press conferences and press briefings and public appearances as each side attempts to establish or reinforce its position in the eyes of Americans. Appearances of the candidates and their surrogates on network news and talk shows have been as carefully orchestrated in recent days as they were in the more straightforward days of the campaign before November 7.

As noted, there is unlikely to be another nationwide vote on the presidency or the issues involved in the current situation in the near future. Survey research, therefore, becomes the only mechanism by which, particularly in the short term, the views and opinions of the American public can be accurately assessed.

Recognizing this fact, public opinion specialists have wasted little time since the November 7 election in measuring the reaction of Americans across the country to the process as it unfolds. Gallup has conducted four polls since November 7, covering the days of November 11-12, November 13-15, November 19, and November 26-27. We will, of course, continue to monitor public opinion in the weeks ahead.

Do Americans across the country know enough about what is going on in Florida to have opinions?

Polling Americans about the Florida situation, at first glance, might appear to be a difficult challenge. The situation is complex and fast changing, and many of the pundits and lawyers who appear on television and in print have difficulty enough coming to grips with what is happening, much less the average American who is less directly engaged.

Still, polls suggest that Americans are in fact rather highly aware of what is happening in the Sunshine State. We know, for example, that 87% of the public said they were following the situation closely in the first week after the election. That level of attention is among the highest for any news event Gallup has measured over the past 10 years. Attention has now waned a little -- to 77% -- but this is still a relatively high number. (The percentage of Americans following the race "very closely" has fallen from 46% to 35%.)

We have also been surprised at the degree to which our internal analysis of the data shows how carefully attuned Americans are to the Florida situation. What we have found is this: there are highly significant differences in how Bush and Gore supporters respond to questions about Florida, and in all instances, the differences follow precisely the pattern we would predict of individuals who are very aware of what is happening in the state.

For example, in the November 19 poll, 92% of Gore supporters said that hand-recounted ballots should be included in the final vote total in Florida, while only 23% of Bush supporters agreed. This question was the first one asked in that particular survey, and no indication was given by the interviewer as to the current status of the race (regarding Bush or Gore) or about who was requesting the recounts. Still, people across America immediately and without prompting apparently knew at least enough about the situation to answer in a way appropriate to their candidate’s position.

Additionally, in Gallup’s November 26-27 poll, only 9% of Bush supporters said they were willing to wait a little while longer for the situation to be resolved, while 67% of Gore supporters said they were willing to wait. If nothing else, this tells us that the candidates’ supporters were fairly well aware of the implications for "their" candidate of stopping or keeping the process going.

What is it exactly that Americans want to happen in Florida?

Until this past weekend, Americans have been evenly split in their reactions to the situation in Florida, mainly along partisan lines. But our Gallup polling conducted on Sunday night, November 26, immediately after the Florida Secretary of State officially certified Bush as the winner (the polling continued into Monday night, but was concluded before Al Gore made a speech to the nation), showed a movement towards the position that Gore should concede and the situation should be ended.

Here is the wording of one important question used in Gallup’s November 26-27 poll:

"As you may know, the Florida Secretary of State declared George W. Bush the winner of the presidential election in Florida, with 537 more votes than Al Gore. Several court cases concerning the Florida vote recount, including a hearing before the U.S. Supreme Court, are still underway. As of today, do you think Al Gore should concede the election, or should he not concede?"

The results: should concede -- 56%, should not concede -- 38%, no opinion -- 6%.

An ABC News/Washington Post poll conducted Sunday night, November 26, asked:

"Tonight the Secretary of State in Florida declared George W. Bush as the winner of the election there. Al Gore says the votes were not counted fairly. Do you think Gore should concede the election and let Bush become president, or ask the courts to decide whether the vote count in Florida was fair?"

Sixty percent said that Gore should concede, in response to this question wording.

A poll conducted by The New York Times and CBS News on November 27 and 28, on the other hand, found somewhat different results, using a different question wording:

The New York Times/CBS Poll asked, on November 27-28:

"Based on what you know so far, do you think one of the candidates should concede now, or is it too soon for that?" (IF "one should concede,") "Who do you think should concede: Al Gore or George W. Bush?"

The results: Gore should concede -- 42%, Bush should concede -- 3%, too soon for either to concede -- 48%.

And then another poll, conducted for Reuters by Zogby on November 28, used this question wording:

"Do you think that Al Gore should now concede the presidency to George W. Bush?"

This poll showed results that are very consistent with the Gallup and ABC News/Washington Post results: 58% said yes, while 37% said no.

Three of the recent polls that asked directly about the issue of Gore conceding found 56% to 60% of Americans saying that he should concede. The other recent poll found a lower percentage favoring a Gore concession, but the question allowed respondents the option of saying it was "too soon" for a concession. This poll also did not initially ask about the concession of either candidate in particular (the question said "one of the candidates"); instead, it followed up with a more specific question regarding which of the two candidates should concede (asked of those who thought a candidate should concede).

Differences in responses to differential question wording are not unusual in polling. The focus should be on what the differences tell us. A majority clearly favors a Gore concession when the question is asked directly. The fact that the percentage favoring a Gore concession drops below a majority when a perhaps attractive "stalling" alternative of "too soon" is given indicates that these attitudes are perhaps not deeply rooted nor firmly held. In this situation, if nothing else, the pattern suggests that attitudes about a possible Gore concession are fluid at this point in time, and certainly subject to change as events unfold.

Can either of these candidates still govern effectively when one of them finally takes possession of the White House?

The available data suggest that Americans are still willing to accept either candidate as president. We have been measuring the degree to which Americans would see each candidate as "legitimate." To be precise, we have asked Americans in three separate polls to indicate whether they would accept Bush and whether they would accept Gore as a "legitimate" president if either is "declared the winner and is inaugurated next January." The percentage who would accept Bush as legitimate has gone from 79% to 86% to 84% across the three polls. The percentage accepting Gore has gone from 82% to 80% to 74%. So, while there has been some erosion for Gore, it is clear that the significant majority of the country would accept him if he ends up the winner.

When we combine these responses, we get 60% who say they would accept either Bush or Gore as legitimate. About a quarter would accept only Bush, and 13% would accept only Gore.

How are Americans evaluating the way the two candidates and their advisers are handling themselves in the post-election controversy?

Al Gore seems to be losing ground relative to George W. Bush on this front. We have asked Americans to rate their approval or disapproval of George W. Bush and his campaign advisers and Al Gore and his campaign advisers at three different points since the election: November 11-12, November 19, and November 26-27. The results show that approval of Bush and his advisers has remained essentially constant across the three polls, going from 53% to 55% to 54%. At the same time, approval of Gore and his advisers went from 52% to 48% to 42% in the most recent poll. (Disapproval of Bush and his advisers on November 26-27 is 41%, while disapproval of Gore and his advisers is 54%. )

By way of reference, the New York Times/CBS News poll conducted November 27-28 shows a similar pattern. Although the way these organizations ask the questions is different, the Times/CBS News report shows that 50% of Americans approve of the Bush campaign’s handling of the "uncertain outcome of the presidential election," compared to 38% who approve of the Gore campaign’s handing of the uncertain outcome.

Are Americans losing patience with the whole affair?

The patience factor seems to be going down. Our most recent Gallup poll, conducted November 26-27, shows that 62% of Americans say "the presidential situation has gone on too long already," while 37% choose the alternative "you are willing to wait a while longer for a final resolution to the presidential election situation." A week before, the choices of Americans between these same two alternatives had been essentially equal.

Who has the more intense feelings in this race -- Republicans or Democrats?

This is still a very, very partisan situation, with most attitudes eminently predictable in terms of the partisan orientation of those who are answering. As noted above, the "waited too long" question shows that 90% of Bush supporters agree that the situation has gone on too long, compared to only 32% of Gore supporters. Similarly, 77% of Gore supporters approve of Gore’s actions in the situation, while only 9% of Bush supporters approve.

And Republicans seem to be more intense than Democrats.

For example, 65% of Gore supporters say they would accept George W. Bush as a legitimate president should he be elected. On the other hand, only 46% of Bush supporters say they would accept Gore as a legitimate president. Similarly, 26% of Gore supporters say they approve of the actions taken by Bush and his advisers, while only 9% of Bush supporters say they approve of the actions taken by Gore and his advisers.  


Gallup https://news.gallup.com/poll/4654/Questions-Answers-About-Public-Opinion-Situation-Florida.aspx
Gallup World Headquarters, 901 F Street, Washington, D.C., 20001, U.S.A
+1 202.715.3030