skip to main content
Permissive Public Opinion vs. a Public Mandate

Permissive Public Opinion vs. a Public Mandate

The results of public opinion polls on certain policies are typically treated as though they represent a public mandate. According to a recent Program on International Policy Attitudes /Knowledge Networks poll, for example, 66% of Americans said that in the future the United States should not feel free to use military force without U.N. authorization, while only 29% said it should. Based on these results, Steven Kull, director of PIPA, said, "While the public is ready to give the president a pass this time, it appears that in the future, two-thirds will still insist on getting UN approval for the use of military force."

That two-thirds of the public will "insist" on U.N. approval for future military actions seems highly questionable, if the past is any guide. As late as March 14-15, just days before the Iraq war began, the public opposed war without a new vote in the United Nations by 50% to 47%. A month earlier, opposition to war without a new U.N. vote was even greater -- 57% to 39%. Yet, immediately after the United States began military action against Iraq -- still without a new U.N. vote -- the public approved of the U.S. decision to go to war by 76% to 20%.

This is a classic case in which a supposed public "mandate" for a certain position disappears once the government acts opposite to that mandate. Gallup research suggests that one reason for this apparent contradiction is that policy-preference questions constitute only a first look at public opinion -- that many people who say they favor or oppose a given policy really don't care very much one way or the other. A follow-up question measuring the public's level of commitment to a position can provide a clearer picture of the real public mandate.

For example, Gallup asked Americans for their opinions on privatization of Social Security several times between 2000 and 2002, with similar results in each asking: More than 6 in 10 supported privatization, while about 3 in 10 opposed it.

A proposal has been made that would allow people to put a portion of their Social Security payroll taxes into personal retirement accounts that would be invested in private stocks and bonds. Do you favor or oppose this proposal?

 

Favor

Oppose

No opinion

%

%

%

2002 Apr 8-11

63

33

4

2002 Jan 25-27

63

33

4

2001 Nov 26-27 ^

64

31

5

2001 Aug 24-26

62

34

4

2001 Mar 26-28 ^

63

30

7

2000 Jun 6-7 ^

65

30

5

 

^

Asked of half sample.



In the April 2002 poll, however, Gallup also asked a follow-up question of those who expressed an opinion. If they were in favor, they were asked how upset they would be if Congress and the president did not pass the proposal. And if they were opposed, they were asked how upset they would be if Congress and the president did pass the proposal.

The combined results of the two questions show that only 47% of Americans held an opinion so strongly that they would be upset if Congress and the president did the opposite of their expressed opinion -- 27% who favored the personal retirement account proposal and would be upset if it were not adopted, and 20% who opposed the proposal and would be upset if it were adopted.

That leaves a majority of the public, 53%, who indicated they would not be upset with whatever action Congress and the president took on this proposal. This includes 36% who initially said they favored the proposal, 13% who opposed it, and 4% who expressed no opinion.

Respondents who expressed an opinion -- and said they would be upset if the government adopted a position contrary to that opinion -- are classified as having "directive" opinions. These opinions can be interpreted as constituting the public "mandate."

People who either do not have an opinion (just 4% in this example), or who expressed an opinion but would not be upset if government policy contradicted their views, are classified as having a "permissive" opinion.

 

Public Opinion on Proposal to Establish Personal Retirement Accounts
From Part of Social Security Taxes

 

Classification of Opinion

Response Categories

Overall

Directive
(Mandate)

Permissive
(No mandate)

 

%

%

%

Favor, upset* if not passed

27

27

 

Favor, but not upset if not passed

36

 

36

No opinion

4

 

4

Oppose, but not upset if passed

13

 

13

Oppose, upset if passed

20

20

 

TOTAL

 

100

 

47

 

53

Respondents who said they would be "very" or "somewhat" upset were classified as "upset," while "not too" and "not at all upset" respondents were classified as "not upset."

Based on telephone survey of 1,003 adults nationwide, conducted April 8-11, 2002.



These results suggest that if the government adopts a personal retirement account proposal, 80% of the public would go along with it (they would not be upset). On the other hand, if such a proposal is not passed, 73% of the public would go along with that as well. (Of course, opinion can change as debate on the issue continues and more information becomes available.)

The initial measurement of public preferences on issues is still useful. But the follow-up measurement, identifying the number of people with a "permissive" opinion, provides greater insight into how much of a public mandate actually exists. In the case of personal retirement accounts, a 2-to-1 expression of initial support translates into no majority public mandate either for or against the proposal.

It is likely that for most policy proposals, there is no majority mandate in either support or opposition. On a day-to-day basis, Americans seem to trust their elected representatives' leadership on the issues facing the country.


Gallup https://news.gallup.com/poll/8701/Permissive-Public-Opinion-vs-Public-Mandate.aspx
Gallup World Headquarters, 901 F Street, Washington, D.C., 20001, U.S.A
+1 202.715.3030