skip to main content
Iraq, Democratic Presidential Candidates, The Economy, Sept. 11 Anniversary

Iraq, Democratic Presidential Candidates, The Economy, Sept. 11 Anniversary

Iraq

President Bush's address to the nation Sunday night highlighted the emphasis that his administration is placing on maintaining the American public's support of the multibillion-dollar U.S. venture in Iraq.

How well is the president's Iraq policy faring in the eyes of the American people? We can help answer that question by looking at four components of his Sunday night address.

1. First and foremost, the president acknowledged both implicitly and explicitly in his speech that things are not going as well as could be expected in Iraq. Bush reminded the nation that the undertaking is "difficult and costly."

Indeed, the American public is not as positive as it has been about the way things are going in Iraq. The latest CNN/USA Today/Gallup poll, conducted in late August, found that 50% of Americans feel that things are going well in Iraq. That's a drop from 56% in July, and down significantly from 70% in a May 30-June 1 poll.

The latest TIME/CNN poll, released over this past weekend, shows that 32% feel the military campaign against Iraq has been successful, compared to 39% who felt that way in July and 52% in late March (as the war was still underway).

A CBS News poll conducted in late August showed that 51% of Americans said things were going well in terms of the U.S. efforts to bring "stability and order to Iraq," down from 60% in July.

Still, it's important to note that the TIME/CNN poll doesn't show much change in the public's assessment of how good a job the United States has done with the situation in Iraq "now that the major fighting has ended." Seventy-one percent say "good" or "very good" now, compared to 72% in mid-July.

2. Bush repeatedly underscored the importance of U.S. involvement in Iraq and the necessity to stay the course there, saying: "This work continues. In Iraq, we are helping the long-suffering people of that country to build a decent and democratic society at the center of the Middle East … This undertaking is difficult and costly, yet worthy of our country and critical to our security."

The results of poll questions about the value that Americans place on the U.S. and allied involvement in Iraq vary according to what is stressed in the question wording. If respondents are reminded of the cost of the war in Iraq in terms of human lives, barely half say the effort there has been worth it. A more general question, asking about the worth of the war but not about specific costs, shows that more than 6 in 10 continue to say it is worth it.

Gallup's historical question measuring public perception of involvement in wars is an example of the latter format. Gallup's question does not specify costs, but simply asks: "All in all, do you think the situation in Iraq was worth going to war over, or not?" The last three times that Gallup has asked this question, 63% of Americans have said yes.

Slightly different questions asked by TIME/CNN and CBS News are examples of the first format outlined, emphasizing the costs of the war. In particular, faced with a reminder of the costs of the war in terms of human lives, a significantly lower percentage of Americans agree that the war has been worth it.

The latest TIME/CNN poll, conducted Sept. 3-4, shows that only 49% say the war has been worth "the toll it has taken in American lives and other kinds of costs." (This percentage has not changed since mid-July.) The latest CBS News poll shows that 46% think the war with Iraq has been worth the "loss of American life and other costs." (This percentage is also unchanged from earlier in August.)

In general, the fact that perceptions of the value of the venture into Iraq have not changed over the last month or so is good news for the administration. The fact that only about half of Americans say the Iraq situation is worth it when they are reminded of its cost in terms of human lives is obviously not so good news.

3. Bush made a concerted effort on Sunday night to tie the military efforts in Iraq into the broader war on terrorism.

In general, Americans appear to buy into this connection. Polling conducted by the Washington Post in August showed that significant majorities of Americans agree that Saddam Hussein had provided assistance to Osama bin Laden and his terrorist network, and that Saddam was personally involved in the Sept. 11 terrorist attacks.

4. Basically, Bush was arguing for continued support for his presidency.

The latest Gallup Poll, conducted in late August, shows that Bush's job approval ratings have stabilized over the last month or so. There are some signs in the most recent polls conducted by other polling organizations that Bush's job approval rating may have fallen over the last several weeks. New Gallup data available later this week will enable us to see if the president's job approval rating has indeed begun to slip, or if Sunday night's speech (and/or other developments) may have allowed his ratings to remain stable.

Democratic Presidential Candidates

If there is a drop in Bush's approval ratings, it will underscore the efforts on the part of the Democratic presidential candidates to paint the Bush administration as "a miserable failure," as Dick Gephardt repeatedly called it in last week's debate in Albuquerque, N.M. Most of the other Democratic candidates have repeated their own versions of Gephardt's assertion about the Bush presidency, albeit not always as harshly.

The Albuquerque debate itself probably had little impact on the standing of the Democratic candidates. It involved a crowded field of eight candidates, each of whom was limited to a minute or a minute and a half to respond to each question. The debate had only limited television exposure on PBS. There are more and more debates to come this fall, including tonight's debate at Morgan State University in Baltimore, co-sponsored by the Congressional Black Caucus Institute and Fox News Channel.

Gallup Poll data suggest that as of late summer, the majority of rank-and-file Democrats across the country were not paying a great deal of attention to the campaign for their party's nomination. But Labor Day traditionally marks a point at which the campaigning gets underway in earnest, and it's clear to everyone involved that a great deal can change in the four months between now and January, when the actual caucuses and primaries begin.

Former Vermont Gov. Howard Dean continues to be designated by media commentators and pundits as the front-runner in the Democratic race, so much so that much of the press coverage of the Albuquerque debate revolved around the fact that the other candidates did not spend as much time as expected criticizing Dean.

Polling-wise, Dean's front-runner status rests almost exclusively on polling in New Hampshire showing him pulling ahead of his competitors in that state. For example, a Boston Globe poll released over the weekend found Dean leading Massachusetts Sen. John Kerry by 12 points. Dean and Kerry share the advantage of being from states adjacent to New Hampshire, so it's not surprising that the race in the Granite State may come down to a contest between the two of them.

Nationally, the new TIME/CNN poll released over the weekend shows that it is Kerry, not Dean, who has moved into the lead over 2000 vice-presidential candidate Joe Lieberman. Kerry received a good deal of press coverage last week when he formally announced of his candidacy in front of a World War II aircraft carrier moored in the Charleston, S.C. harbor. Kerry chose South Carolina for his announcement because it (along with several other states) will hold its Democratic primary on Feb. 3, just a week after New Hampshire. (The latest polls in South Carolina show no clear leader.)

Gallup analysis does show that Dean does better in our national polls when the sample is restricted only to Democrats who have been paying attention and know something about the major candidates. That suggests that Dean may prosper as other Democrats begin to tune into the campaign.

The Economy

While the Democratic candidates have made the decision to go after Bush on the Iraq front, polling continues to show the importance of the economy in voters' minds.

Bush and his administration have touted recent progress on some economic fronts, although Democrats have seized on reports that another 93,000 jobs were lost in August as evidence of continued economic problems under the Bush administration's watch.

Americans continue to be concerned about the job situation in general. Gallup's polling shows that about 8 in 10 Americans think that now is not a good time to find a quality job.

Interestingly, however, Gallup analysis indicates that workers themselves profess somewhat lower levels of concern about losing their own jobs. Gallup's August Work and Education poll found that workers are considerably less satisfied with levels of stress, pay, health benefits, chances for promotion, and retirement plans than they are about their job security. Similarly, only 19% of workers are worried that they will be laid off (no different from last August) and only 9% are worried about the possibility that their company will move jobs to countries overseas.

Sept. 11 Anniversary

Thursday is the two-year anniversary of the Sept. 11 terrorist attacks on New York City and Washington, D.C. There's no question that one of the lasting effects of the attacks is a basic sensitivity on the part of the American public to the possibility of additional terrorism here on the home front.

Indeed, the latest Gallup Poll shows that about 4 in 10 Americans are worried about becoming the victim of a terrorist attack, and slightly over half think it is at least somewhat likely that there will be additional terrorist attacks within "the next few weeks." Both of these percentages are up from just a month or two ago.

But still, it is hard to find much evidence that people's daily lifestyles have changed since the attacks. A Gallup analysis shows that church attendance and gun ownership, for example, are no different now than they were before the attacks.

There is one change in behavior that is of considerable interest. Americans remain much more likely now than before Sept. 11 to say that they are extremely proud to be American. This number was at 70% in June 2003, compared to 69% in September 2002, and 55% in January 2001.

Author(s)

Dr. Frank Newport is a Gallup Senior Scientist and the author of Polling Matters (Warner Books, 2004) and The Evangelical Voter.


Gallup https://news.gallup.com/poll/9235/iraq-democratic-presidential-candidates-economy-sept-anniversary.aspx
Gallup World Headquarters, 901 F Street, Washington, D.C., 20001, U.S.A
+1 202.715.3030