skip to main content
Iraq, Bush and Kerry, 9/11 Commission, The Economy

Iraq, Bush and Kerry, 9/11 Commission, The Economy

Iraq

We are just now beginning to get a sense of the American public's reaction to the recent uprisings in Iraq, which have so dominated news coverage over the past week or two.

First and foremost, it's clear that Americans are paying attention to the news and they are well aware of what is happening in Iraq. About one in four Americans (26%) now mention either war in general, or the war in Iraq specifically, as the most important problem facing the country today. That's up sharply from 11% in March, although still lower than the percentage who named war as the top problem in the first months of 2003, just before the Iraq war began.

There's also rising recognition among Americans that the war in Iraq is not going well. Sixty-four percent of Americans now say that things are going either "moderately" or "very" badly for the United States in Iraq. That's a significant jump from the 43% who felt that way a month ago. Previously, the highest "going badly" percentage registered in Gallup's polling was in early November, before the capture of Saddam Hussein, when 61% of Americans said that things were going badly. The 33% of Americans who say things are going very badly is six points higher than at any point across the 12 times Gallup has asked this question since the major fighting ended a year ago.

The increased awareness of the problems in Iraq does not directly translate into a dramatic loss of support for the basic rationale for U.S. intervention there. The most recent poll (April 5-8) shows only a five-point decrease in the percentage of Americans saying the situation in Iraq was worth going to war over, compared with the polls taken in early and late March. In other words, there has been a much bigger increase in awareness that things are not going well in Iraq than there has been a concomitant loss of support for the Iraq initiative in general.

These numbers may reflect a modified version of a phenomenon known as the "rally effect," in which public opinion becomes more supportive of a leader or policy when the United States is being challenged abroad. Support for President Jimmy Carter rose initially after the hostages in Iran were taken in November 1979. And President John F. Kennedy's job approval rating went up, not down, after the abortive Bay of Pigs invasion in 1961. Thus, today Americans' basic tendency to rally behind their country in time of international crisis may explain why public support for the war has not dropped much more than it has.

Similarly, basic support for the war in Iraq did not fall significantly in the first weeks of military action last March, even as polling measures showed that Americans quickly recognized that progress was initially slower than anticipated.

Still, this constancy in basic support of the historical rationale for the United States and allied presence in Iraq doesn't necessarily translate into support for U.S. troops remaining there. Twenty-eight percent of Americans now think that the United States should withdraw all its troops from Iraq. Although this is nowhere near a majority, it is the highest number supporting this strategy across the seven times that Gallup has asked this question. Another 18% feel that the United States should withdraw some of its troops.

The percentage of Americans who want the number of troops to be kept at the same level as it is now has dropped since December and January. About a fifth of Americans want more troops sent, 29% want troop levels kept as they are now, 18% want some troops withdrawn, and 28% want all troops to be withdrawn. All in all, there appears to be more of a tendency on the part of Americans to believe that something should be done either way in Iraq, rather than living with the status quo.

Bush and Kerry

The relative stability in the public's attitudes about Iraq is also evident in Gallup's overall measure of approval of the job George W. Bush is doing as president, now at 52%. We have measured presidential job approval eight times since late January, and it has fluctuated to only a minor degree, between 49% and 53%.

Similarly, we don't yet detect any major change in support for the two presidential candidates. At this point, Bush and the presumptive Democratic nominee John Kerry are statistically tied.

Since late January, Kerry's level of support among registered voters in the two-way trial heat has ranged between 46% and 51%. Support for Bush has ranged between 45% and 49%. Historically, this is an exceedingly narrow range of support. Indeed, one could assume that the population's actual level of support for each candidate has remained constant at 48% over this entire period, and that the changes from poll to poll could have resulted solely from measurement error.

Support for Bush and Kerry among likely voters, as opposed to registered voters, has been more variable, because different groups of voters have expressed different levels of interest in the election as the campaign has progressed. Democrats were more enthusiastic while the Democratic primaries were garnering all of the media attention; now, Republicans are slightly more highly represented in Gallup's calculation of the likely voter pool.

All in all, my conclusion is that the tumultuous events of the past several weeks -- including in particular Richard Clarke's testimony to the 9/11 commission and the renewed fighting in Iraq -- have not had a significantly detrimental effect on the public's view of Bush.

9/11 Commission Testimony

Last Thursday's highly publicized testimony of national security adviser Condoleezza Rice took place in the middle of the field period of Gallup's latest poll, making it impossible to determine the specific impact that the extraordinary session may have had on public opinion.

A CNN/TIME poll, however, was conducted in its entirety on Thursday night after the hearing. The poll showed that less than half of Americans had heard a great deal or a moderate amount about Rice's testimony at that point in time. Given a choice, respondents in that poll were slightly more likely to say they would believe Rice rather than Clarke if their testimony conflicted.

Several other polls conducted recently have shown that Americans believe that the Bush administration did not do everything possible to stop terrorism before 9/11. For example, a Newsweek poll released this past weekend asked: "From what Condoleezza Rice and Richard Clarke have told the commission, do you think the Bush Administration took the threat of global terrorism as seriously as it should have prior to September 11th, or that they underestimated the terrorist threat and focused too much on other security issues like missile defense and Iraq?" By 60% to 23%, Americans chose the second alternative.

This finding isn't at all surprising, given the obvious fact that the 9/11 attacks occurred. In hindsight, it is natural to conclude that neither the Bush administration nor anyone else took the threat as seriously as they should have. Therefore, I don't believe these types of questions tell us a great deal other than to confirm the obvious.

The Economy

Economic news has improved in recent weeks. The government announced that a significant number of new jobs were created in March, wholesale inventories are up, jobless claims are down, manufacturers have become more optimistic, and March retail sales were up.

On the other hand, there has been the dispiriting and ominous news from Iraq, suggesting to some that the United States could become bogged down in a long-term war of attrition with echoes of the Vietnam era. And back here at home, Americans are confronted by the ever-increasing price of gas at the pump each time they fill up. Gas prices are at an all-time high in some parts of the country, and news reports suggest that there may be no end in sight as the busy summer driving season approaches.

Thus, as we went into the field with the April 5-8 Gallup Poll, we didn't know whether to expect Americans to be more upbeat about the economy, reflecting some of the broadly positive economic trends, or more downbeat, reflecting concern about international events and gas prices.

What were the findings? Essentially, "none of the above." Across a wide variety of measures, there has been no significant change over the last month in the public's attitudes toward the economy.

Thirty-four percent of Americans rate economic conditions in the United States as excellent or good, almost unchanged from March and February, but down from more optimistic readings at the beginning of the year. Forty-seven percent of Americans now say economic conditions are getting better, while 45% say they are getting worse. This measurement is only slightly different from last month, when 44% said conditions were getting better, and 47% said they were getting worse (but again substantially less optimistic than results from earlier this year).

Last week's poll also shows that overall satisfaction with the way things are going in the United States is at 41%, very similar to last month's 39%. And as noted, there has been essentially no change in Bush's overall job approval rating this month.

It's possible that the stability in these numbers indicates a canceling-out effect. The more positive news about jobs may have been countered by the negative news from Iraq. Or perhaps Americans are waiting for more definitive news on the economy before changing their minds. Yet another possibility is that Americans are waiting to see an economic pickup in their local areas before they change their perceptions of the overall status of the economy. Whatever it is, Americans have generally the same attitude that they had in February and March -- somewhat less ebullient than in January.

These trends have a direct bearing on the presidential election. The three big issues that are going to affect the outcome of next November's vote will be Iraq, terrorism, and the economy. Most polls conducted so far this year show the economy has the highest priority of all. Right now, public opinion about economic conditions isn't great, nor is it dismal. Americans are sitting on the fence when it comes to the economy, and we will have to continue to wait to see which way they will eventually fall.

Author(s)

Dr. Frank Newport is a Gallup Senior Scientist and the author of Polling Matters (Warner Books, 2004) and The Evangelical Voter.


Gallup https://news.gallup.com/poll/11314/iraq-bush-kerry-911-commission-economy.aspx
Gallup World Headquarters, 901 F Street, Washington, D.C., 20001, U.S.A
+1 202.715.3030