skip to main content
Disapproval of Bush is Policy-based, While Approval is More General in Nature

Disapproval of Bush is Policy-based, While Approval is More General in Nature

GALLUP NEWS SERVICE

PRINCETON, NJ -- Three out of 10 Americans disapprove of President George W. Bush's job performance, according to a new Gallup poll, and are most likely to cite objections to specific policies and positions as the basis for their negative evaluations. Those who approve, on the other hand, are more likely to cite general approval of his leadership style, cabinet appointments, and character.

Bush Approval Rating Now At 53%
Bush's job approval rating is now at 53%, lower than the average for most presidents since World War II at this point in the first year of their first terms. Only Bill Clinton had a similarly low rating -- 52% -- in late March of 1993. Bush's father's job approval rating was 58% in early April of 1989. The highest job approval rating after about two months in office belonged to President John F. Kennedy, who had a 78% rating in an early April 1961 Gallup poll.

President Bush began his administration this year with an initial reading of 57%, and his job approval went up to the low 60s in mid-February and early March. By mid-March, it had fallen back to 58% and registered at 53% in the most recent Gallup poll, conducted March 26-28,

Twenty-nine percent of Americans now say they disapprove of the way Bush is handling his job, while 18% say they have no opinion.

There are the usual divisions by party and ideology in rating Bush. A full 86% of Republicans say they approve of the job Bush is doing, a figure that drops to 48% among independents and to only 26% among Democrats. Similarly, 68% of conservatives approve of the job Bush is doing, compared to 50% among moderates and 34% among liberals. Reflecting the gender gap that has become a part of American presidential politics, Bush's approval rating among men is 58% and 47% among women (standing in marked contrast to Democrat Clinton, whose job approval rating was almost always higher among women than among men). Regionally, Bush currently does best in the Midwest and the South, with job approval ratings of 57% and 54%, respectively. He does slightly less well on the two coasts, with a 47% job approval rating in the East and 52% in the West.

Reasons Behind Approval and Disapproval
This Gallup poll included an effort to investigate what is on Americans' minds at this early stage in the Bush administration when they are asked to evaluate their new president. After indicating whether they approved or disapproved of Bush's job performance, respondents were asked to explain their answer in their own words. The results were categorized, and then further grouped into broad categories.

Here are the basic results:

Why do you approve of the way Bush is handling his job as president? [Open-ended]

BASED ON -- 548 -- WHO APPROVE OF BUSH; ±5 PCT. PTS.

 

 

2001 Mar 26-28

   

Specific Policies

16

Agree with his tax plan

8

Agree with his policies in general

4

Agree with his economic policies

3

Concerned for people

1

   

General Satisfaction

22

Satisfied/doing good job

22

   

Character Issues

11

Honest/trustworthy/man of integrity

10

No scandals

1

   

Style of Governing

20

Approve of his style/balance/moderate approach

8

Accomplishing things/getting things done

5

Chose good advisors/Cabinet

3

Appears confident/in control

4

   
   

Campaign

7

Fulfilling his promises

7

   

Party

6

Voted for him/Republican

6

   

Other

8

Better than Bill Clinton

4

Other

4

   

None/Don't Know Why

10



Why do you disapprove of the way Bush is handling his job as president? [Open-ended]

BASED ON -- 311 -- WHO DISAPPROVE OF BUSH; ±6 PCT. PTS.

 

 

2001 Mar 26-28

   

Specific Policies

52

Disagree with his tax plan

13

Don't agree with his policies in general

11

Disapprove of his economic policies

9

Disapprove of his environmental policies

8

Caters to the rich/big business

7

Disapproves of his foreign policy

3

Hasn't accomplished much

1

   

General Dissatisfaction

10

Dissatisfied/doing a poor job

10

   

Character Issues

2

Untrustworthy

2

   

Style of Governing

5

Not knowledgeable

5

   

Campaign/Election

11

Failing to fulfill his campaign promises

8

Elected in a flawed election

3

   

Party

7

Didn't vote for him/Democrat

7

   

Other

6

Other

6

   

None/Don't Know Why

7



It is first apparent that those who approve of Bush's performance are somewhat less likely to speak in very specific terms than are those who disapprove. This is, to some degree, a natural function of the fact that approval (or having no opinion) is a logical default response of Americans when asked the job approval question. In essence, they give a new president the benefit of the doubt -- only 16% cite specific Bush policies as the reason for their position. The common responses, used by about one-fifth each of those who approve of the job Bush is doing, are a general sense of satisfaction, the perception that his administration is balanced, and positive reactions to his cabinet appointments.

Those who feel strongly enough to tell an interviewer that they disapprove of the president's job performance are more likely to have developed specific reasons for their position at this point. Over half of those who disapprove of Bush's job performance cite aspects of the policy positions he has taken, including mentions of his tax plan, foreign, environmental, and economic policies.

Five percent say that they disapprove because they think that Bush is not knowledgeable.

Interestingly, despite the tremendous visibility given to the Florida recount situation after the election, and the fact that Bush actually lost the popular vote, only 3% base their negative response on the fact that he gained office "in a flawed election."

Whither Bush's Job Approval In the Months Ahead?
Which way is Bush's job approval most likely to move at this point? History provides little guidance. Bill Clinton's approval rating continued its nosedive as the first year of his presidency unfolded, ultimately bottoming out at 37% in June 1993. Clinton enjoyed a brief uptick in September of 1993, and remained essentially mired in the 40% range throughout much of 1994 and 1995, but recovered closer to the 60% range by Election Day 1996. Bush's father, on the other hand, enjoyed very high job approval ratings throughout 1989, and after a dip in the fall of 1990, soared to record heights on the heels of the Persian Gulf War, topping out at a Gallup record 89% in late February, and early March, 1991. It didn't take long, however for a sour economy and the recession to depress his ratings. By the summer of 1992, the elder Bush had bottomed out at a very low 29% job approval -- paving the way for the election victory of Bill Clinton that fall.

Gallup's historical analysis shows that two major factors are usually the most important determinants of a president's job approval rating: the economy and foreign policy. The economic outlook for Bush is not favorable at this point, given the depressed economic indicators that Gallup polls have picked up over the past several months. Gallup polling also suggests that Americans are unlikely to respond very positively to either a tax cut, if it is passed by Congress, or the prospect of campaign finance reform. Neither are high priorities for Americans. To Americans, the key domestic issues in addition to the economy are Social Security, healthcare and education. So far, there are no dramatic developments on any of these fronts that might presage a Bush job approval rally.

It is possible that the current China crisis may have a rallying effect on Bush's job approval ratings as, for example, happened to President Jimmy Carter's after the American hostages were taken captive in Iran in late 1979. Gallup Poll findings over the past sixty years have shown that in most foreign affairs crises the public unites behind the president -- at least in the short term.

Survey Methods

The results below are based on telephone interviews with a randomly selected national sample of 1,024 adults, 18 years and older, conducted March 26-28, 2001. For results based on this sample, one can say with 95 percent confidence that the maximum error attributable to sampling and other random effects is plus or minus 3 percentage points. In addition to sampling error, question wording and practical difficulties in conducting surveys can introduce error or bias into the findings of public opinion polls.

Do you approve or disapprove of the way George W. Bush is handling his job as president?

 

 

 

Approve

Disapprove

No opinion

       
 

%

%

%

2001 Mar 26-28

53

29

18

       

2001 Mar 9-11

58

29

13

2001 Mar 5-7

63

22

15

2001 Feb 19-21

62

21

17

2001 Feb 9-11

57

25

18

2001 Feb 1-4

57

25

18



Why do you approve of the way Bush is handling his job as president? [Open-ended]

BASED ON -- 548 -- WHO APPROVE OF BUSH; ±5 PCT. PTS.

 

 

2001 Mar 26-28

   
 

%

Satisfied/doing good job

22

Honest/trustworthy/man of integrity

10

Agree with his tax plan

8

Approve of his style/balance/moderate approach

8

Fulfilling his promises

7

Voted for him/Republican

6

Accomplishing things/getting things done

5

Better than Bill Clinton

4

Appears confident/in control

4

Agrees with his policies in general

4

Agrees with his economic policies

3

Chose good advisors/Cabinet

3

Concerned for people

1

No scandals

1

   

None

3

Other

4

No opinion

7



Why do you disapprove of the way Bush is handling his job as president? [Open-ended]

BASED ON -- 311 -- WHO DISAPPROVE OF BUSH; ±6 PCT. PTS.

 

 

2001 Mar 26-28

   
 

%

Disagree with his tax plan

13

Don't agree with his policies in general

11

Dissatisfied/doing a poor job

10

Disapprove of his economic policies

9

Failing to fulfill his campaign promises

8

Disapprove of his environmental policies

8

Caters to the rich/big business

7

Didn't vote for him/Democrat

7

Not knowledgeable

5

Disapprove of his foreign policy

3

Elected in a flawed election

3

Untrustworthy

2

Hasn't accomplished much

1

   

None

*

Everything

1

Other

6

No opinion

6




Gallup https://news.gallup.com/poll/1834/disapproval-bush-policybased-while-approval-more-general-nature.aspx
Gallup World Headquarters, 901 F Street, Washington, D.C., 20001, U.S.A
+1 202.715.3030