skip to main content
Investor Optimism Provides Another Gloomy Sign for Economy

Investor Optimism Provides Another Gloomy Sign for Economy

by Dennis Jacobe and David W. Moore

GALLUP NEWS SERVICE

PRINCETON, NJ -- Despite Federal Reserve Board Chairman Alan Greenspan's recent suggestions to Congress that the economic slowdown was less evident in January and February than it was late last year, investor optimism in February joined consumer confidence in painting a gloomy picture of the U.S. economy in early 2001.

According to the February 2001 PaineWebber/Gallup Index of Investor Optimism, investors' sentiments about the economy fell 9 points, putting the economic dimension of the Index at 15. This is the lowest score on this dimension since the Index was established in October 1996, when the economic dimension of the Index registered a rating of 41. This is also the third consecutive month that the economic dimension of the Index has been at an all-time low.

Investors' sentiments about their own personal well-being also hit an all-time low in February as the personal dimension of the Index fell to 89. This is the first time that the personal dimension of the Index has fallen below its 1996 baseline of 95.

Combined, these two dimensions of the Index convey a very negative view of investor optimism in February 2001.

Still, the overall Index of Investor Optimism declined only slightly in February, falling just 4 points to 126. An increase in investors' positive feelings about governmental policies that affect the investment climate has significantly moderated the fall of the overall Index during recent months.

In fact, investor optimism about government policies hit an all-time high in February as the governmental dimension of the Index increased to a positive rating of 22. When the Index was created in October 1996, the governmental dimension registered a negative score of -36, indicating that investors were pessimistic about government policies.

As Chairman Greenspan also noted in his late-February testimony before Congress, consumers continue to spend even though consumer confidence has plunged. In this regard, the insights provided by February's Index of Investor Optimism raise a number of questions concerning whether investors, who have strengthened consumer spending in the past, will continue to do so in the future. Will investor optimism about the government's favorable policies toward investments encourage investors to keep spending in spite of their concerns about the economy? And, if they do, does this imply that a major congressional battle over the federal budget and tax policy could have a highly negative impact on overall investor optimism and spending? In turn, does this suggest that the economy may be more vulnerable to a public-policy deadlock in 2001 than it has been at any other time in the last decade?

INDEX OF INVESTOR OPTIMISM

October 1996 to February 2001

February Decline in Economic Rating Primarily Due to Investors' Concerns About Unemployment and Growth
In November 2000, the economic dimension rating was at 41 -- the same level it was at in October 1996. Since then, it declined to 24 in December and remained at 24 in January 2001. In February 2001, this rating fell another 9 points to 15. It is now at its lowest level ever.

Five questions constitute the economic dimension: optimism ratings on economic growth, unemployment, performance of the stock market, inflation and interest rates. In February, the greatest decline by far took place in net investor optimism about unemployment.

In January, investors were on balance optimistic about the unemployment situation by 12 percentage points, 44% optimistic to 32% pessimistic. In February, investors turned pessimistic about the unemployment situation with a net pessimistic rating of 9 percentage points, 33% optimistic to 42% pessimistic. It appears that all the announcements of big layoffs early this year have made investors much more pessimistic about the unemployment situation in 2001.

Investor optimism about economic growth also decreased significantly in February. In January, investors gave a net optimism rating of 15 percentage points, 44% optimistic to 29% pessimistic. By February, investor net optimism about economic growth had fallen to 8 percentage points, 40% optimistic to 32% pessimistic.

As expected, investor optimism about interest rates continued to increase in February. Although significant, this increase was not enough to offset the declines in investor optimism about unemployment and economic growth.

In December, the net optimism rating for interest rates was 23 points, 47% optimistic to 24% pessimistic (virtually identical to the November reading). But after the Fed lowered interest rates in early January, optimism increased to a net positive of 34 percentage points, 55% to 21%. By February 2001, after the Fed lowered interest rates significantly once again, investor optimism about interest rates increased another notch to a net 41 percentage points, 59% to 18%. Investors' growing optimism about interest rates may be one reason they were so susceptible to rumors -- proven untrue -- that the Fed would announce another rate cut when Chairman Greenspan testified before Congress instead of waiting until the next Federal Open Market Committee meeting on March 20.

The two other questions that comprise the economic dimension of the Index showed little change. Investor net optimism about the stock market decreased slightly, from a net positive rating of 7 percentage points in January to a net positive rating of 6 percentage points in February. Investor optimism about inflation increased from a net positive of 9 percentage points, in both December and January, to a net positive of 12 percentage points in February.

Investors More Optimistic About Government's Policies on Tax Incentives for Investing
The governmental dimension of the Index improved in February 2001, from +8 to +22 -- a 14-point increase. This follows a similar 15-point increase that took place in January.

Much of the improvement in this dimension over the past two months is found in the question asking investors to rate their optimism on the federal government's policies about tax incentives for saving or investing. In December 2000, net optimism was just a positive 2 percentage points, as 36% of investors said they were optimistic and 34% said pessimistic. In January 2001, net optimism increased to a positive 19 points, and in February it increased further to a positive 26 percentage points (51% optimistic to 25% pessimistic).

This jump in optimism could well be related to the Bush administration's tax-cut proposal that would cut personal income taxes across the board. Optimism also might be higher in March as the popularity of the tax-cut idea has increased following the president's budget address to the Congress.

On the other two questions that constitute the governmental dimension, there was also some positive movement in February 2001. One of the questions asked investors to rate their optimism on governmental policies dealing with Social Security and Medicare. In February, net optimism on this question increased from 1 percentage point to 7 percentage points.

Similarly, the third question that constitutes the governmental dimension -- investors' optimism about the federal budget -- also showed an increase in optimism, from net optimism of 4 percentage points in January to 14 percentage points in February 2001.

Survey Methods

The results reported here are based on telephone interviews with a randomly selected national sample of 1,000 adult investors, 18 years and older, with at least $10,000 of investable assets, conducted February 1-14, 2001. For results based on this sample, one can say with 95 percent confidence that the maximum error attributable to sampling and other random effects is plus or minus 3 percentage points. In addition to sampling error, question wording and practical difficulties in conducting surveys can introduce error or bias into the findings of public opinion polls.

Economic Dimension:

Now, I would like to ask you to think about the factors that could affect the overall investment environment OVER THE NEXT 12 MONTHS. On the same five-point scale, as far as the general condition of the economy is concerned, how would you rate(read and rotate A-E), OVER THE NEXT 12 MONTHS?

  1. economic growth

Very opti-
mistic

Some-
what opti-
mistic

Neither opti-
mistic nor pessi-
mistic

Somewhat pessi-
mistic

Very pessi-
mistic

Don't know/
refused

%

%

%

%

%

%

01 Feb

9

31

26

25

7

2

01 Jan

9

35

25

25

4

2

00 Dec

10

36

27

21

5

1

00 Nov

12

47

21

16

2

2

00 Oct

13

48

19

16

1

3

00 Sep

16

51

19

10

2

2

00 Aug

18

51

17

11

*

3

00 Jul

15

46

24

12

2

1

00 Jun

15

51

19

11

2

2

00 May

17

53

19

8

1

2

00 Apr

16

51

18

13

1

1

00 Mar

16

53

15

12

2

2

00 Feb

21

55

13

7

2

2

00 Jan

22

57

10

7

1

3

99 Dec

24

50

12

10

2

2

99 Nov

16

54

15

11

2

2

99 Oct

16

51

15

13

3

2

99 Sep

15

57

15

10

2

1

99 Aug

16

51

17

11

3

2

99 Jul

20

52

15

11

1

1

99 Jun

17

54

14

12

2

1

99 May

22

52

14

8

3

1

99 Apr

18

53

13

12

2

2

99 Mar

16

52

14

13

3

2

99 Feb

20

51

13

13

2

1

98 Dec

11

50

21

15

2

1

98 Sep

16

51

15

13

3

2

98 Jun

20

52

14

9

2

3

98 Mar

17

53

16

10

3

1

97 Dec

15

51

19

10

4

1

97 Sep

16

50

18

9

3

4

97 May/Jun

15

53

18

10

2

2

97 Feb/Mar

11

49

20

14

4

2

96 Nov

11

43

21

17

5

3

96 Oct

10

43

24

16

4

3

* Less than 0.5%

b. the unemployment rate

Very opti-
mistic

Some-
what opti-
mistic

Neither opti-
mistic nor pessi-
mistic

Somewhat pessi-
mistic

Very
pessi-
mistic

Don't know/
refused

%

%

%

%

%

%

01 Feb

7

26

24

29

13

1

01 Jan

10

34

21

26

6

3

00 Dec

16

31

24

21

6

2

00 Nov

15

41

24

12

5

3

00 Oct

20

40

20

16

2

2

00 Sep

20

45

21

10

3

1

00 Aug

21

42

22

8

3

4

00 Jul

20

41

19

13

3

4

00 Jun

20

41

18

14

4

3

00 May

25

41

18

10

3

3

00 Apr

21

43

21

11

3

1

00 Mar

24

40

19

13

2

2

00 Feb

29

42

16

8

3

2

00 Jan

28

46

13

7

4

2

99 Dec

31

41

13

9

4

2

99 Nov

23

42

19

10

4

2

99 Oct

20

43

20

12

4

1

99 Sep

23

47

16

10

2

2

99 Aug

22

41

18

12

4

3

99 Jul

25

41

18

10

3

3

99 Jun

21

46

17

11

3

2

99 May

21

44

18

12

4

1

99 Apr

23

42

20

10

2

3

99 Mar

20

43

15

15

6

1

99 Feb

25

44

15

11

2

3

98 Dec

20

40

18

14

4

4

98 Sep

22

45

16

11

3

3

98 Jun

26

39

16

11

4

4

98 Mar

26

42

16

9

4

3

97 Dec

22

40

18

12

4

4

97 Sep

20

42

21

8

4

5

97 May/Jun

18

44

19

11

4

4

97 Feb/Mar

10

40

23

16

7

4

96 Nov

11

37

23

16

8

5

96 Oct

13

36

29

14

4

4

c. the performance of the stock market

Very opti-
mistic

Some-
what opti-
mistic

Neither opti-
mistic nor pessi-
mistic

Somewhat pessi-
mistic

Very pessi-
mistic

Don't know/
refused

%

%

%

%

%

%

01 Feb

5

35

23

27

7

3

01 Jan

9

31

23

27

6

4

00 Dec

9

33

26

23

6

3

00 Nov

9

43

23

19

3

3

00 Oct

7

44

24

17

4

4

00 Sep

11

49

21

13

3

3

00 Aug

15

43

21

15

2

4

00 Jul

12

43

21

17

3

5

00 Jun

11

46

21

17

3

2

00 May

8

47

23

16

3

3

00 Apr

10

41

23

18

5

3

00 Mar

15

48

17

14

3

3

00 Feb

15

51

18

12

2

2

00 Jan

18

50

18

8

3

3

99 Dec

21

47

14

11

3

4

99 Nov

14

48

18

14

3

3

99 Oct

11

46

18

16

6

3

99 Sep

13

50

20

12

2

3

99 Aug

12

43

23

15

3

4

99 Jul

18

46

18

14

3

1

99 Jun

17

45

17

15

3

3

99 May

19

43

21

12

2

3

99 Apr

17

47

17

13

2

4

99 Mar

15

47

17

13

5

3

99 Feb

17

46

17

13

4

3

98 Dec

11

41

24

17

4

3

98 Sep

13

41

20

18

5

3

98 Jun

16

47

16

13

2

6

98 Mar

22

41

18

12

3

4

97 Dec

14

47

19

11

4

5

97 Sep

20

39

20

11

3

7

97 May/Jun

18

43

20

12

1

6

97 Feb/Mar

17

39

20

12

4

8

96 Nov

18

39

20

12

3

8

96 Oct

13

40

23

14

3

7

d. inflation

Very opti-
mistic

Some-
what opti-
mistic

Neither opti-
mistic nor pessi-
mistic

Somewhat pessi-
mistic

Very pessi-
mistic

Don't know/
refused

%

%

%

%

%

%

01 Feb

10

31

26

22

7

4

01 Jan

10

29

29

23

7

2

00 Dec

9

32

25

26

6

2

00 Nov

10

35

26

21

5

3

00 Oct

10

34

30

20

4

2

00 Sep

9

42

23

18

5

3

00 Aug

11

41

23

17

3

5

00 Jul

9

38

25

20

6

2

00 Jun

12

34

22

24

6

2

00 May

8

38

24

22

5

3

00 Apr

11

33

23

26

5

2

00 Mar

14

32

21

26

5

2

00 Feb

12

42

22

18

4

2

00 Jan

14

43

23

14

3

3

99 Dec

15

42

18

18

3

4

99 Nov

9

43

22

19

4

3

99 Oct

9

41

22

21

6

1

99 Sep

12

37

23

22

4

2

99 Aug

13

36

25

19

4

3

99 Jul

14

40

23

18

3

2

99 Jun

12

38

22

23

4

1

99 May

18

36

22

18

5

1

99 Apr

21

36

25

14

2

2

99 Mar

16

41

21

16

4

2

99 Feb

19

47

20

11

2

1

98 Dec

14

39

22

20

3

2

98 Sep

18

40

20

16

3

3

98 Jun

17

42

21

13

3

4

98 Mar

19

39

21

15

3

3

97 Dec

16

40

23

15

4

2

97 Sep

14

40

21

15

6

4

97 May/Jun

14

35

25

18

5

3

97 Feb/Mar

12

35

24

18

7

4

96 Nov

11

34

28

17

6

4

96 Oct

12

34

28

17

5

4

e. interest rates

Very opti-
mistic

Some-
what opti-
mistic

Neither opti-
mistic nor pessi-
mistic

Somewhat pessi-
mistic

Very pessi-
mistic

Don't know/
refused

%

%

%

%

%

%

01 Feb

16

43

21

14

4

2

01 Jan

18

37

21

18

3

3

00 Dec

11

36

25

19

5

4

00 Nov

8

39

28

19

4

2

00 Oct

8

36

26

21

4

5

00 Sep

9

39

26

18

5

3

00 Aug

10

34

29

19

4

4

00 Jul

8

34

26

23

6

3

00 Jun

10

32

21

28

7

2

00 May

8

32

22

29

6

3

00 Apr

9

32

26

26

6

1

00 Mar

10

30

23

32

4

1

00 Feb

9

36

23

25

4

3

00 Jan

10

42

21

20

2

5

99 Dec

12

45

22

15

4

2

99 Nov

6

41

23

22

4

4

99 Oct

7

45

19

21

6

2

99 Sep

6

39

20

28

4

3

99 Aug

8

39

20

26

4

3

99 Jul

11

40

22

19

5

3

99 Jun

8

42

21

23

3

3

99 May

14

44

20

18

2

2

99 Apr

16

40

21

16

4

3

99 Mar

13

42

18

19

6

2

99 Feb

20

45

17

13

2

3

98 Dec

20

45

17

12

4

2

98 Sep

18

43

17

14

5

3

98 Jun

16

43

21

12

3

5

98 Mar

20

39

22

12

5

2

97 Dec

15

42

21

15

5

2

97 Sep

11

42

25

13

4

5

97 May/Jun

8

39

25

20

5

3

97 Feb/Mar

9

40

24

16

5

6

96 Nov

11

38

24

17

5

5

96 Oct

9

37

26

18

5

5

Governmental Dimension:

Now, I would like you to think about how the federal government's policies may affect the overall investment environment OVER THE NEXT 12 MONTHS. How would you rate the federal government's policies dealing with(read and rotate A-C), OVER THE NEXT 12 MONTHS?

  1. tax incentives for saving/investing

Very opti-
mistic

Some-
what opti-
mistic

Neither opti-
mistic nor pessi-
mistic

Somewhat pessi-
mistic

Very pessi-
mistic

Don't know/
refused

%

%

%

%

%

%

01 Feb

15

36

20

17

8

4

01 Jan

12

36

20

19

10

3

00 Dec

8

28

25

24

10

5

00 Nov

7

36

26

20

7

4

00 Oct

7

32

24

24

9

4

00 Sep

8

28

26

24

11

3

00 Aug

6

31

27

20

9

7

00 Jul

8

26

24

28

10

4

00 Jun

5

29

24

27

12

3

00 May

5

32

23

25

11

4

00 Apr

6

33

24

26

10

1

00 Mar

7

29

24

27

11

2

00 Feb

7

33

22

27

8

3

00 Jan

6

34

23

24

10

3

99 Dec

6

31

20

24

14

5

99 Nov

5

29

25

26

12

3

99 Oct

5

32

22

29

10

2

99 Sep

5

27

24

28

13

3

99 Aug

7

30

23

25

12

3

99 Jul

8

33

19

27

11

2

99 Jun

5

31

21

26

15

2

99 May

7

28

25

28

11

1

99 Apr

5

27

25

25

14

4

99 Mar

7

27

21

26

15

4

99 Feb

9

31

22

23

11

4

98 Dec

6

29

24

25

13

3

98 Sep

8

33

21

27

7

4

98 Jun

8

29

23

22

11

7

98 Mar

9

33

21

24

10

3

97 Dec

6

29

22

25

15

3

97 Sep

8

31

21

23

12

5

97 May/Jun

6

25

22

30

14

3

97 Feb/Mar

5

24

21

29

16

5

96 Nov

5

23

24

28

15

5

96 Oct

5

25

25

27

14

4

b. the federal budget

Very opti-
mistic

Some-
what opti-
mistic

Neither opti-
mistic nor pessi-
mistic

Somewhat pessi-
mistic

Very pessi-
mistic

Don't know/
refused

%

%

%

%

%

%

01 Feb

12

33

19

21

10

5

01 Jan

10

29

22

23

12

4

00 Dec

10

24

26

25

10

5

00 Nov

6

36

24

21

7

6

00 Oct

8

29

25

23

9

6

00 Sep

8

31

25

23

10

3

00 Aug

8

33

23

17

12

7

00 Jul

9

26

24

24

13

4

00 Jun

7

26

23

29

12

3

00 May

6

34

22

25

10

3

00 Apr

6

27

25

26

14

2

00 Mar

8

28

23

28

10

3

00 Feb

8

32

22

23

12

3

00 Jan

10

31

20

25

12

2

99 Dec

8

28

18

26

16

4

99 Nov

6

26

21

29

14

4

99 Oct

5

28

22

31

13

1

99 Sep

6

28

23

28

13

2

99 Aug

8

28

24

22

15

3

99 Jul

11

32

20

23

13

1

99 Jun

8

27

19

30

14

2

99 May

6

30

21

28

14

1

99 Apr

9

27

25

24

13

2

99 Mar

8

33

18

24

14

3

99 Feb

14

33

19

20

12

2

98 Dec

8

33

19

24

14

2

98 Sep

9

31

18

27

11

4

98 Jun

11

30

17

23

14

5

98 Mar

14

32

18

23

11

2

97 Dec

5

23

19

31

20

2

97 Sep

7

27

20

27

16

3

97 May/Jun

3

20

16

31

28

2

97 Feb/Mar

3

20

16

31

28

2

96 Nov

5

21

18

31

23

2

96 Oct

4

22

19

28

22

5

c. Social Security and Medicare

Very opti-
mistic

Some-
what opti-
mistic

Neither opti-
mistic nor pessi-
mistic

Somewhat pessi-
mistic

Very pessi-
mistic

Don't know/
refused

%

%

%

%

%

%

01 Feb

14

28

22

23

12

1

01 Jan

11

27

23

25

12

2

00 Dec

8

24

24

26

14

4

00 Nov

8

29

26

21

13

3

00 Oct

9

30

23

23

12

3

00 Sep

10

26

22

26

14

2

00 Aug

7

25

24

26

14

4

00 Jul

7

21

21

31

17

3

00 Jun

7

25

21

30

16

1

00 May

7

25

20

32

14

2

00 Apr

8

27

22

26

16

1

00 Mar

10

23

22

28

15

2

00 Feb

8

29

20

27

15

1

00 Jan

7

25

19

30

17

2

99 Dec

7

22

16

33

20

2

99 Nov

5

21

20

31

21

2

99 Oct

7

24

17

32

19

1

99 Sep

6

22

21

30

20

1

99 Aug

7

22

21

30

18

2

99 Jul

8

24

17

32

18

1

99 Jun

7

20

16

32

23

2

99 May

5

22

21

31

20

1

99 Apr

7

21

19

34

19

-

99 Mar

6

24

17

29

22

2

99 Feb

10

21

18

29

20

2

98 Dec

6

22

19

32

19

2

98 Sep

7

21

17

32

19

4

98 Jun

7

20

17

29

23

4

98 Mar

6

22

18

34

19

1

97 Dec

5

18

16

33

25

3

97 Sep

7

18

21

29

23

2

97 May/Jun

6

17

19

31

24

3

97 Feb/Mar

5

16

17

32

26

4

96 Nov

5

20

19

30

24

2

96 Oct

5

22

18

30

20

5


Gallup https://news.gallup.com/poll/1945/investor-optimism-provides-another-gloomy-sign-economy.aspx
Gallup World Headquarters, 901 F Street, Washington, D.C., 20001, U.S.A
+1 202.715.3030