skip to main content
New Orleans, President Bush, New Strategy, Saddam Hussein, Rice in Europe, Civil Partnerships, DeLay, Death Penalty, Prescription Drug Plan

New Orleans, President Bush, New Strategy, Saddam Hussein, Rice in Europe, Civil Partnerships, DeLay, Death Penalty, Prescription Drug Plan

New Orleans

New Orleans Mayor Ray Nagin traveled to Houston, Memphis, Tenn., and Atlanta last week, urging displaced New Orleans residents who fled to those cities to return home. His concern: New Orleans can't recover without enough manpower to do the work, and, to date, about two-thirds of the former population of New Orleans is missing in action.

The fact that much of the population of New Orleans has not yet returned shouldn't come as a total surprise to Nagin and other officials. The CNN/USA Today/Gallup poll of Hurricane Katrina victims, conducted Sept. 30 to Oct. 9, showed that 39% of New Orleans residents who applied for aid from the American Red Cross said they probably or definitely would not return home. Half said they would probably or definitely return.

President Bush

There is a lot of interest in how President George W. Bush looks in the eyes of the American public. His job approval ratings in early to late November -- including two consecutive Gallup Polls -- fell into the 30% range, the lowest ratings of his administration. Since then, the administration has launched a public relations campaign of sorts, with Bush and other administration spokespeople talking about progress in Iraq, the improving economy, and other positive indicators.

But is it working? Gallup is in the field now with our early December Bush update and will release a new job approval measure on Dec. 12. Meanwhile, two polls have been conducted since Thanksgiving that I'm aware of, one by TIME magazine, and the other by Fox News/Opinion Dynamics. The TIME poll has Bush approval at 41%; Fox/Opinion Dynamics has it at 42%. The Fox poll's number is up some six points from their last poll conducted in early November.

These data suggest that the president's job ratings are probably not continuing to drop, and may actually have picked up a bit. The Gallup Poll and other polls released over the next week or two will give us a more solid picture of the population's views of the president.

New Bush Strategy

There's little question that the administration has been attempting to counter negative public views of the war in Iraq by emphasizing more positive news -- including, in particular, the theme that there ultimately will be a "victory" in Iraq. According to a report in The New York Times over the weekend, this represents the handiwork of Duke University professor Peter Feaver, who is currently on leave from the university and working as a consultant for the National Security Council. According to the reports, Feaver's research indicates that the public will support a war as long as it sees that the war can ultimately be won, even when casualties are mounting.

From my perspective, there are several ways of looking at this White House initiative. It's always good news when elected officials pay attention to the views of the people as are measured by polls. The Bush administration has discounted polls in general, particularly in the last six months when Bush's approval rating and support for the war have been dropping. The fact that they are listening to Feaver's analysis suggests that the administration is concerned about the public's views, and I think that's a good thing.

On the other hand, the current strategy reminds me of the thesis of an important book written by political scientists Larry Jacobs and Bob Shapiro in 2000, Politicians Don't Pander. In that book, Jacobs and Shapiro argue that while many politicians do pay attention to polls, they do so more to be able to manipulate public opinion than they do to guide policy. As the authors summarize: "Politicians devote substantial resources to tracking public opinion, not for the purposes of policymaking but to change public opinion -- to determine how to craft their public statements and actions to win support for the policies they and their supporters want." In Jacobs' and Shapiro's opinion, and mine as well, that's not necessarily a good thing. Politicians should use polls as the basis for taking the public seriously and as the basis for policy decisions, rather than solely for the purpose of attempting to create support for already decided-upon policies.

Saddam Hussein

Saddam Hussein's trial resumed in Baghdad on Monday, with the deposed Iraqi leader telling the special court he is not afraid of execution. Hussein and his co-defendants could be put to death if convicted of being responsible for the deaths of more than 140 Shiites in the early 1980s.

The American public has little sympathy for Hussein and certainly would not be upset if he were ultimately convicted and executed for his crimes. A Gallup Poll conducted earlier this fall found 72% of Americans say Hussein should be given the death penalty if convicted of murder. 

Bush and the Economy

Bush visited the Deere-Hitachi Construction Machinery Corp. in Kernersville, N.C., on Monday, showcasing what the administration believes is a reviving national economy. 

Bush needs a good deal of help in the economic arena. Although Gallup's measures of consumer confidence are trending upward, 40% of Americans still believe that Bush's policies are hurting the economy, compared with just 21% who believe they are helping and 37% who say they are not having much effect. These views have not changed much all year.

Rice in Europe

Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice is in the middle of a weeklong trip to Europe, with meetings in Germany, Romania, Ukraine, and Belgium. An October Gallup Poll found that 59% of Americans have a favorable opinion of Rice, compared with a relatively low 26% unfavorable rating. Rice remains much more popular than Bush, Vice President Dick Cheney, Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld, or almost any other member of the administration that Gallup has asked about in recent months.

Civil Partnerships in Great Britain

Same-sex couples in Great Britain were allowed to register on Monday to have their partnerships legally recognized. The new law allows gay couples many of the same legal benefits as heterosexual couples. One of the most famous couples planning to take advantage of the new rules is singer Elton John, who reportedly will consecrate his union with long-time partner, David Furnish, on Dec. 21, the date when the law allows ceremonies to take place in England and Wales.

Gallup Poll data suggest that Britons in general are somewhat more liberal on this issue than are Americans. An April 2005 poll in Great Britain found than only 15% wanted homosexuality to be less widely accepted, while 38% wanted it to be more widely accepted. Results from the same question in the United States (from a January 2005 poll) found that 36% wanted homosexuality to be less widely accepted and 29% wanted it to be more widely accepted.

DeLay Fundraiser

Both Cheney and Texas Rep. Tom DeLay have been suffering from negative press and Democratic criticism recently. This didn't prevent DeLay from holding a high-powered fundraiser in Houston Monday night, at which Cheney was the main attraction. DeLay, of course, has been indicted by a Travis County, Texas, grand jury on conspiracy and money-laundering charges. The judge in the case threw out one of the conspiracy charges Monday, but indicated that DeLay will have to continue to trial next year on the other charges.  

DeLay receives a 45% unfavorable rating and only an 18% favorable rating in Gallup's most recent polling (the rest had no opinion). Importantly, DeLay gets a favorable rating of only 35% from Republicans around the country. Cheney does somewhat better, with an overall 42% to 51% favorable-to-unfavorable ratio, and with a 74% favorable rating among Republicans.

A new CNN/USA Today/Gallup poll taken over the weekend in DeLay's Texas Congressional District shows he isn't doing much better there. Registered voters in the district give DeLay (their current representative in Congress) a 52% unfavorable, 37% favorable rating. Asked whom they would vote for next November if DeLay runs again, voters in his district choose the "Democratic candidate" over DeLay by a 49% to 36% margin.

They're Back

The House of Representatives returned from its Thanksgiving recess Monday, but that in and of itself will not create a great deal of positive excitement on the part of the American people. 

Gallup's recent update on the perceived honesty and ethics of various professions shows that "congressmen" are near the bottom of the list, with a low 14% very high/high rating from the American people. That puts congressmen just slightly above telemarketers and car salesmen on the list. 

Nurses came in on top, with an 82% honesty rating, followed by two other healthcare professions: pharmacists and doctors.

Death Penalty

The U.S. Supreme Court will hear arguments on two death penalty cases this week, following last week's execution of Kenneth Lee Boyd in North Carolina. He became the 1,000th person put to death since the reinstitution of the death penalty nearly 30 years ago.

Support for the death penalty in the United States has declined some over the last 10 years, but still remains quite high. Almost two-thirds of Americans say they favor the use of the death penalty in cases of murder, and a majority (56%) say they support it even when there is the clearly stated alternative of life imprisonment with no chance of parole. More than half of Americans say the death penalty is not imposed often enough, and 6 in 10 say it is applied fairly in this country.

New Medicare Prescription Drug Plan

Senior citizens around the country are continuing to attempt to figure out the new Medicare prescription drug benefit, which takes effect at the beginning of the new year for those who sign up for it. 

Just how confusing is it? An October 2005 Kaiser Family Foundation/Harvard School of Public Health poll of Americans aged 65 and older found that 61% of seniors said they understood the new prescription drug benefit not too well or not well at all, while only 14% understood it very well. Six in 10 said they didn't know how the new Medicare prescription drug benefit would affect them personally, and seniors had a slightly more unfavorable than favorable opinion of the drug plan.

These attitudes may well change as the deadline for enrollment gets closer, but it is not an auspicious beginning for the new plan.

Author(s)

Dr. Frank Newport is a Gallup Senior Scientist and the author of Polling Matters (Warner Books, 2004) and The Evangelical Voter.


Gallup https://news.gallup.com/poll/20332/new-orleans-president-bush-new-strategy-saddam-hussein-rice-eur.aspx
Gallup World Headquarters, 901 F Street, Washington, D.C., 20001, U.S.A
+1 202.715.3030