skip to main content
Bush Approval, Economy, Personal Happiness, Pharmaceuticals, Football, Fifth Anniversary

Bush Approval, Economy, Personal Happiness, Pharmaceuticals, Football, Fifth Anniversary

Bush Approval

The news -- at least on the public opinion front -- has been somewhat more positive for President George W. Bush over the past week. A series of national polls have shown his approval ratings moving back up -- if only slightly -- instead of continuing their downward slide.

Gallup conducted two national polls between Dec. 5 and Dec. 11. Bush's job approval was 43% in the Dec. 5-8 poll and 42% in the Dec. 9-11 poll. The president's approval had been at 38% and 37% in two mid-November polls.

The bottom line: Bush's job approval appears to have risen by about four points to five points between Thanksgiving and early December. This still marks a general downward trend this year for the president; his month-by-month job approval ratings went from 52% in January to 49% in April, from 46% in June to 44% in September, from 38% in November back up to 43% so far in December.

It's impossible to pinpoint precisely what's behind the modest uptick in Bush's job approval ratings. Rising public confidence in the economy and the president's recent more aggressive stance on the war in Iraq are two of the most likely explanations.

National Public Radio commentator Juan Williams speculated on "Fox News Sunday" that Bush's uptick in various polls had everything to do with the economy and nothing to do with Iraq: "The president's poll numbers have improved just slightly, up about five points, largely as a result of improved sense of how the economy is going and the fact that gas prices have gone down -- has nothing to do with Iraq."

The new Gallup Poll data don't support Williams' hypothesis. Americans' approval of how Bush is handling the economy is up from 37% in mid-November to 40% now -- a modest three points. But, approval of Bush's handling of the situation in Iraq is up from 35% in mid-November to 39% -- a four-point gain. Bush has also gained five percentage points on his foreign affairs approval rating, from 37% in mid-November to 42%. These data certainly suggest that Iraq does in fact have something to do with the uptick in Bush approval -- or at least that it can't be ruled out as a cause.

There is other mixed news for Bush in the current poll. Just 38% of Americans say the president has a "plan that will achieve victory for the United States in Iraq," while 58% say he does not. This is telling, given that Bush's speech at Annapolis, Md., two weeks ago was made in front of multiple signs proclaiming: "Plan for Victory." On the other hand, 63% of Americans say that Iraq has made real progress toward establishing a democratic government over the past two years.

The Economy

There certainly has been positive news in some of our measures of the public's view of the economy -- but I believe one needs to be cautious in ascribing too much significance to these data at this point.

The most substantial change is apparent in Americans' outlooks on the direction of the economy. Just 50% now say that the economy is "getting worse," compared with the 68% who said so in October. But the current "getting worse" percentage is actually higher than it was at the beginning of the year.

Americans' ratings of the current economic conditions have also been lower at several points earlier this year. And the percentage of Americans who say that now is a good time to find a quality job has not increased substantially.

Gallup combines the current conditions and outlook measures into an "economic outlook index." A "positive" outlook group consists of those who say the economy is "getting better" and also rate the current economy as "excellent" or "good." Twenty-eight percent of Americans fall into this group. A "negative" outlook group is made up of those who say the economy is getting worse and also rate the economy as "poor." Forty-seven percent of Americans fall into this group. So, the net, at this point, is -19. This is certainly better than the nadir of -44 measured in October. But this same "net" measure was -15 in May and was as positive as a -6 near the beginning of this year.  

Personal Happiness

Americans' tendency to rate local aspects of various issues more positively than they do national aspects of the same issues has long fascinated social scientists. Local schools are rated more positively than schools across the country, personal healthcare is rated more positively than the nation's healthcare system in general, and congressional representatives from one's local district are rated more positively than "most members of Congress." 

Nowhere is this more evident than in the comparison of Americans' ratings of their satisfaction with the way their personal lives are going and their ratings of the way things are going in general across the United States.

Satisfaction with the way things are going in the United States is now at 35%. As Assistant Gallup Poll Editor Joe Carroll wrote in a recent analysis: "Satisfaction was highest in February 1999, when 71% of Americans said they were satisfied and 26% said they were dissatisfied. The low point for this measure came in July 1979 -- only 12% of Americans were satisfied at that time, while more than 8 in 10 adults (84%) were dissatisfied." So, that's a range of 59 percentage points in general satisfaction over the last quarter-century. 

But it's a vastly different situation when we ask Americans this question: "In general, are you satisfied or dissatisfied with the way things are going in your personal life at this time?" to which 85% of Americans respond affirmatively.

There has been little change in this personal satisfaction measure over time. The highest level recorded since Gallup first began asking this question in 1979 was 88% in December 2003. The lowest reading was 73% in July 1979. That's a range of only 15 percentage points, compared with the aforementioned 59-point spread in the national satisfaction measure.

Pharmaceuticals

Mixed news for Merck & Co. Monday when a federal judge in Houston declared a mistrial in the first federal Vioxx case. The lawsuit was filed against Merck by a widow of a man who had taken the Merck drug Vioxx, and then died of cardiovascular problems. The federal suit will be retried with a new jury. Merck had been found liable in a Texas state court in a similar case, but not liable in a New Jersey state court trial. 

All of this focus on the effects of prescription drugs is not trivial. A recent Gallup analysis found that half of Americans report taking prescription medications, a percentage that rises to 88% among those aged 65 and older. Americans who take prescription drugs pay $89 a month on average, a significant amount for those on limited incomes. The analysis also shows that the majority of those taking prescription drugs are doing so to combat long-term conditions, and that they do so to help with physical problems, rather than mental or emotional problems.

Football Playoffs Near

One is hard-pressed to avoid football these days, as the NFL season builds to its climax and the college football bowl season begins. No fewer than 28 college bowl games will be played, beginning with the New Orleans Bowl between Southern Mississippi and Arkansas State on Dec. 20, and ending with the Rose Bowl between USC and Texas on Jan. 4.

All of this exposure is perhaps fitting, given our recent finding that football remains -- by a wide margin -- Americans' favorite sport to watch. Thirty-four percent of Americans name football as their favorite sport, followed by baseball and basketball, which tie with 12% of mentions each. Behind these "big three" are auto racing, ice hockey, figure skating, tennis, soccer, and golf. 

Interestingly, this marks the first time baseball has tied basketball since November 1998. In five polls conducted after that, basketball led baseball by at least one percentage point in terms of overall mentions.

Football has not always been on top. In Gallup Polls conducted in 1937, 1948, and 1960, Americans were more likely to mention baseball than football. Football took over first place in 1972 and has remained the favorite sport to watch ever since, usually getting between 30% and 38% of mentions.

There are few differences by gender. Men's top three sports are football, baseball, and basketball. For women, the top three are football, basketball, and baseball -- same sports, different order. But 17% of women say they can't name a favorite sport to watch, compared with 9% of men who can't.

Fifth Anniversary

Monday marked the fifth anniversary of the end of the 2000 presidential election recount battle.

Some Democrats continue to argue that Al Gore actually won the 2000 election and that it was stolen by a combination of malfeasance at the polls and a politically motivated Supreme Court decision.

But few Americans agree that the election was stolen. Gallup last asked the public about the 2000 election in January 2004, when 49% said that Bush won fair and square, 31% said he won on a technicality, and 18% said he stole the election. These responses are almost identical to those gathered when Gallup first asked this question in a mid-December poll in 2000 -- shortly after the Supreme Court decision had been handed down.

Author(s)

Dr. Frank Newport is a Gallup Senior Scientist and the author of Polling Matters (Warner Books, 2004) and The Evangelical Voter.


Gallup https://news.gallup.com/poll/20440/Bush-Approval-Economy-Personal-Happiness-Pharmaceuticals-Football.aspx
Gallup World Headquarters, 901 F Street, Washington, D.C., 20001, U.S.A
+1 202.715.3030