skip to main content
Iraq: Only an Issue or the Issue for Democrats?

Iraq: Only an Issue or the Issue for Democrats?

Every election cycle we ponder the age-old political science question of how important issues are to voters in making up their minds about candidates. I'm starting to think we might have a useful laboratory for answering that in Connecticut, where pro-Iraq war U.S. Sen. Joe Lieberman -- up for re-election this year -- is facing an interesting challenge for the Democratic nomination from anti-Iraq war activist Ned Lamont. The Republicans have not come up with any heavy hitters to run, so whoever wins the Democratic nomination will likely face a weak Republican opponent in November.

Lamont officially threw his hat (and much of his personal wealth) into the ring in March and is already racking up enough delegate commitments for the May Connecticut Democratic convention to be able to challenge Lieberman in the Democratic primary election in August. He is also supported by numerous left-wing ("progressive") blogs and Web sites, which are helping to raise national money for him.

All of this came about because of Lieberman's unflinching support for the Iraq war. Plus the once solidly liberal state senator and Connecticut attorney general has adopted a more moderate image since he's been in the Senate, and that has increasingly irked the left wing of his party. Being donned Bush's favorite Democrat -- sealed with a kiss at this year's State of the Union -- has become the symbolic representation of all that Lieberman's critics say is wrong with the senator.

Lamont regularly quips to voters that by nominating him they won't be losing a senator; they'll be gaining a Democrat.

A few weeks ago Lieberman said that, should he lose the nomination, he would run in the general election as an independent. As the quintessential Connecticut Democrat -- he was the Democratic nominee for vice president just six years ago -- it is absolutely remarkable to me Lieberman would even think, much less utter those words. My first thought at hearing them was that Lieberman's poll numbers must be really bad. 

But not so. According to the Quinnipiac Poll, a majority of Connecticut Democrats approve of the way Lieberman is handling his job (57%) and think he deserves to be re-elected (61%). His personal favorable rating among the same group is a bit anemic at 50%, but that is suppressed by the fact that in addition to the "unfavorable" response (20% for Lieberman), respondents are given a third "mixed" option that garners 24%.

Already these numbers tell me that Connecticut Democrats either consider other factors to be more important than Iraq when weighing the pros and cons of Lieberman, or that they aren't paying close enough attention to the news to know that Lieberman is an Iraq hawk (also telling).

So what does this mean for the primary? It's too soon to pay attention to horse race polls between Lamont and Lieberman because voters don't even know who Lamont is at this early stage. But for what it's worth, Lieberman bested Lamont 68% to 13% among Democrats for the nomination in a February Quinnipiac poll.

If by August Lamont's profile increases and voters understand the choice they are faced with, then we will get a clear test of how angry Connecticut Democrats really are about the Iraq war. With so few Democratic incumbents or candidates sharing Lieberman's pro-war stance, it is a unique test of the issue within the party.

Given the views of Democrats' nationally on the Iraq war, one would think Lieberman could be in trouble over the issue. According to recent Gallup Polls, most Democrats oppose the war (82% say sending troops was a mistake). Nearly a third of Democrats (much more than Republicans) mention Iraq spontaneously when asked to name the most important issue facing the United States. Only 22% of Democrats say the Iraq war will be "the most important" issue to their vote for Congress this year, but another 44% say it will be "very important."

Between now and the primary, I'd like to see more questions on Quinnipiac's Connecticut polls about Lieberman's stance on the war. That would help to parse the numbers a little more. How do Connecticut Democrats feel about Lieberman's Iraq position? How do they feel about the war? How do these views relate to their vote?

If Connecticut Democrats don't turn Lieberman out, or at least give him a good scare, then one has to ask how serious Democrats' opposition to the Iraq war really is. More generally, one has to ask how much issues really matter when voters have other things, such as candidate favorability and strategic voting, to consider. 

Already it's unclear whether Lieberman's position on the Iraq war remain the central campaign issue, or whether this will be muddied by the mechanics of preventing the seat going to a Republican.

Indeed, by threatening to run as an independent, Lieberman has perhaps intentionally signaled that a vote for Lamont would be a vote for a three-way race in which the Democrats could lose the seat by splitting their vote and electing an otherwise weak Republican nominee. In my experience, pragmatism usually trumps principle for voters when elections are framed in these terms, so it is an important tool in Lieberman's arsenal. Lamont has pledged not to run as an independent, and is trying to use Lieberman's position against him within the party. 


Gallup https://news.gallup.com/poll/22555/iraq-only-issue-issue-democrats.aspx
Gallup World Headquarters, 901 F Street, Washington, D.C., 20001, U.S.A
+1 202.715.3030