skip to main content
Bush Appears to Have Narrow Lead Over McCain in South Carolina

Bush Appears to Have Narrow Lead Over McCain in South Carolina

by David W. Moore

GALLUP NEWS SERVICE

PRINCETON, NJ -- A just-completed Gallup poll of likely voters in South Carolina, conducted February 11-13, shows Texas Governor George W. Bush leading Senator John McCain by 49% to 42%, with Alan Keyes receiving 5% of the vote. The 7-point lead is within the poll's margin of error of plus or minus 5 percentage points, based on 552 "likely" voters. But even among the larger group of 1,015 respondents interviewed by Gallup, all of whom said they plan to vote in the primary but whose past voting behavior does not qualify them to be classified among the most likely to actually turn out to vote, Bush also leads McCain by a 7-point margin, 48% to 41%. These numbers suggest that at this point in the campaign, McCain and Bush supporters are about equally likely to actually vote in the primary.

The issue of negative campaigning has been the subject of much debate among the two candidates, but the poll suggests that neither candidate has been particularly harmed by the exchanges. The favorable ratings of Bush and McCain are quite high, at 76% and 77% respectively, and the unfavorable ratings are still relatively low -- 20% for Bush and 17% for McCain. Furthermore, about the same number of voters say McCain is attacking Bush unfairly (38%) as say that Bush has been attacking McCain unfairly (35%). When asked who they blame for starting the negative campaigning, the voters split evenly, with 30% each naming Bush and McCain, 11% blaming both equally, and another 11% saying that neither candidate is to blame.

Republicans Favor Bush, Non-Republicans McCain
The South Carolina Primary is classified as an "open" election, allowing independents and Democrats, as well as Republicans, to participate. In television interviews over the weekend, Bush expressed his concern that large numbers of Democrats would participate in the Republican primary, to vote for McCain as the "weaker" candidate, who would be less likely than Bush to win in November. The poll shows, however, that only 6% of the expected electorate identify as Democrats, while 60% say they are Republican, and the rest independent. Bush is right, however, to fear the consequences of the open primary. The Texas governor leads McCain by 59% to 34% among Republican identifiers, while McCain leads Bush by 54% to 35% among those who do not identify with the Republican Party. The more non-Republicans who participate in the primary, the better it will be for McCain.

The poll does not support the contention, however, that McCain's supporters are trying to sabotage the Republican Party's nomination process by selecting a weaker candidate to run against the Democratic nominee in the fall. Among voters who say they prefer McCain, whether Republican or non-Republican, McCain is seen as stronger than Bush on all of the characteristics and issues included in the poll. Bush's greatest advantage over McCain, for example, is that the Texas governor is seen by 59% of the likely voters to have the better chance of beating the Democrat in November, while only 29% say McCain has a better chance. But among McCain supporters, both Republicans and non-Republicans, McCain is viewed as better able to win in November by a 2-to-1 margin.

Still, it is clear that many of McCain's supporters -- about a quarter -- think Bush would be the more electable candidate in the fall, but still intend to vote for the Arizona Senator. Only about 5% of Bush's supporters think McCain would be the more electable candidate in November. The poll shows that many voters are apparently more influenced by their strongly positive views of a candidate than they are by whether or not he will win in the general election.

Survey Methods
The results reported here are based on telephone interviews conducted February 11-13, with 1,015 registered voters in South Carolina who said they intended to vote in the Republican Primary. This sample includes 552 "likely voters," whose past voting behavior suggests that they are the most likely to actually turn out to vote. For results based on the whole sample, one can say with 95 percent confidence that the maximum error attributable to sampling and other random effects is plus or minus 3 percentage points. For results based on the sample of 552 likely voters, the margin of error is plus or minus 5 percentage points. In addition to sampling error, question wording and practical difficulties in conducting surveys can introduce error or bias into the findings of public opinion polls.

Suppose the Republican primary election for president were being held today. If you had to choose among the following candidates, which candidate would you vote for -- [Random order: George W. Bush, John McCain, or Alan Keyes]?

(If unsure) As of today, to which of the Republican candidates do you lean most?

  Bush McCain Keyes Other/Undecided
2000 Feb 11-13 49% 42 5 4

As you may know, there have been accusations of negative campaigning in this year's Republican primary race in South Carolina. Which campaign organization do you tend to blame more for starting the negative campaigning in this election - [Rotate: 1) George W. Bush's campaign, or 2) John McCain's campaign]?

  2000 Feb 11-13
Bush campaign 30%
McCain campaign 30
   
BOTH EQUALLY (vol.) 11
NEITHER/OTHER (vol.) 11
NO NEGATIVE CAMPAIGNING (vol.) 2
No opinion 16
  100%


Gallup https://news.gallup.com/poll/3235/bush-appears-narrow-lead-over-mccain-south-carolina.aspx
Gallup World Headquarters, 901 F Street, Washington, D.C., 20001, U.S.A
+1 202.715.3030