skip to main content
In Presidential Race: Leadership Appears to Be the Key

In Presidential Race: Leadership Appears to Be the Key

by David W. Moore

GALLUP NEWS SERVICE

PRINCETON, NJ -- Texas Governor George W. Bush continues to lead Vice President Al Gore in the latest Gallup Poll presidential trial heat. An analysis of a series of measures designed to gauge the public's perceptions of the two front-runners suggests that Bush's key strength is his image as a leader rather than his positions on the issues.

The poll was conducted January 17-19, and shows that Bush is maintaining an 11-percentage-point lead over Gore among likely voters, 53% to 42%. To explore the images of the two front-runners that might help explain voters' preferences, the poll included questions that asked respondents to rate each of the two front-runners on 12 issues and 13 personal characteristics. The results show that Gore has a modest advantage over Bush on the issues included in the survey, but on the personal characteristics -- especially those related to leadership qualities -- Bush decisively beats Gore.

Personal Characteristics
A general question asked respondents whether they agreed or disagreed that each candidate had "the personality and leadership qualities a president should have." Sixty-five percent agreed that Bush has those qualities, compared with 52% who agreed that Gore does.

Among the 13 personal characteristics on which voters rated the two candidates, the one that most clearly distinguishes Bush from Gore is "strong and decisive leader," with 66% of Americans saying that the term applies to the Texas governor, while only 42% say it applies to the vice president. That 24-point difference is the largest on any of the more than two dozen items included in the survey.

Related to the leadership item are two other characteristics on which Bush also fares much better than Gore. Sixty-six percent of Americans say Bush can manage government effectively, while just 52% say that about Gore. And 60% say Bush inspires confidence, compared with 44% who say Gore does.

On two other items, Bush enjoys a more modest 9-point advantage over Gore: those who say each candidate is someone they can respect (73% say that about Bush, 64% about Gore), and those who say each candidate stands up for what he believes in (79% Bush, 70% Gore).

On none of the personal characteristics does Gore enjoy an advantage over Bush. The two candidates essentially tie in terms of the public's ratings on several characteristics:

  • shares your values
  • cares about the needs of people like you
  • has strong moral character
  • has a vision for the country's future
  • understands complex issues
  • has new ideas
  • is likeable
  • can keep up with the changing times
Dealing With Issues
Respondents were also asked to indicate whether each of the two front-running candidates would do a good job or a bad job of dealing with 12 specific issues. Here, unlike the case with the personal dimensions, Gore does much better than Bush. On three of the issues, voters are more likely to say that Gore would do a good job than to say that about Bush, by at least a 10-point margin. These include the issue of poverty and homelessness, where 62% of Americans say Gore would do a good job, compared with 44% who say that about Bush -- an 18-point advantage that is the largest among any of the issues. Gore also enjoys a 15-point advantage over Bush on the environment, and a 10-point advantage on the issue of health care.

By contrast, Bush beats Gore by at least 10 points on just one issue -- crime -- with 66% of Americans saying Bush would do a good job of handling that issue, and 53% saying Gore would. Bush also beats Gore on two other issues, but by more modest margins: keeping the budget balanced (an 8-point advantage), and taxes (7-point advantage).

On the other items, the differences in ratings between the two candidates are not significant. These include:

  • the economy
  • foreign affairs
  • the gun issue
  • education
  • the problems of raising children in today's society
  • Social Security and Medicare
Given the results of this poll, it appears that the leadership characteristics that favor Bush are more important to the public in shaping its presidential vote than are the issue areas that favor Gore.

Survey Methods
The results reported here are based on telephone interviews with a randomly selected national sample of 1,496 adults, 18 years and older, conducted January 17-19, 2000. For results based on the whole sample, one can say with 95 percent confidence that the maximum error attributable to sampling and other random effects is plus or minus 3 percentage points. In addition to sampling error, question wording and practical difficulties in conducting surveys can introduce error or bias into the findings of public opinion polls.

Please tell me whether you agree or disagree that the following candidate has the personality and leadership qualities a president should have? How about … [Al Gore, George W. Bush]?

A. Al Gore

  Agree Disagree No opinion
Likely Voters
(LV) 2000 Jan 17-19 50% 47 3
 
National Adults
(NA) 2000 Jan 17-19 52% 43 5

B. George W. Bush

  Agree Disagree No opinion
Likely Voters
(LV) 2000 Jan 17-19 64% 32 4
 
National Adults
(NA) 2000 Jan 17-19 65% 28 7

HISTORICAL TREND: George H. Bush§

  Agree Disagree No opinion
Likely Voters
(LV) 1988 Nov 2-6 65% 33 2
(LV) 1988 Oct 6-10 58% 40 2
(LV) 1988 Sep 1-6 56% 39 5
(LV) 1988 Aug 19-22 58% 38 4
(LV) 1988 Aug 4-9 46% 50 4
(LV) 1988 Jun 1-6 48% 47 5
 
National Adults
(NA) 1988 Apr 1-5 53% 43 4
(NA) 1988 Jan 7-11 50% 47 3
(NA) 1987 Oct 29-Nov 4 46% 49 5
(NA) 1987 Apr 10-15 39% 55 6

§ Based on Harris polls

Thinking about the following characteristics and qualities, please say whether you think it applies or doesn't apply to Al Gore. How about ... [RANDOM ORDER]?

BASED ON -- 765 -- FORM A RESPONDENTS; ± 4 PCT PTS

  Applies Doesn't apply No opinion
A. Shares your values
2000 Jan 17-19 51% 39 10
 
1999 Sep 10-14 52% 41 7
1999 Mar 12-15 56% 37 7
1998 Aug 21-23 52% 35 13
 
B. Cares about the needs of people like you
2000 Jan 17-19 59% 33 8
 
1999 Sep 10-14 61% 33 6
1999 Mar 12-15 63% 31 6
1999 Jan 22-24 62% 28 10
1998 Aug 21-23 59% 31 10
 
C. Can manage the government effectively
2000 Jan 17-19 52% 37 11
 
1999 Sep 10-14 53% 40 7
1999 Mar 12-15 59% 35 6
 
D. Has strong moral character
2000 Jan 17-19 70% 20 10
 
1999 Sep 21-23(‡) 61% 25 14
(‡) A CNN/Time poll
 
E. Has vision for the country's future
2000 Jan 17-19 67% 25 8
 
F. Understands complex issues
2000 Jan 17-19 63% 26 11
 
G. Is a strong and decisive leader
2000 Jan 17-19 42% 47 11
 
1999 Sep 21-23(‡) 39% 49 12
1999 May 26-27(‡) 39% 47 14
1999 Mar 25(‡) 35% 49 16
1999 Mar 4(‡) 39% 41 20
1997 Sep 10-11(‡) 41% 47 12
1997 Mar 11-12(‡) 40% 43 17
(‡) A CNN/Time poll
 
H. Stands up for what he believes in
2000 Jan 17-19 70% 23 7
 
I. Has new ideas
2000 Jan 17-19 56% 31 13
 
1999 Sep 21-23(‡) 42% 44 14
1999 Mar 4(‡) 44% 33 23
(‡) A CNN/Time poll
 
J. Is likeable
2000 Jan 17-19 72% 23 5
 
K. Inspires confidence
2000 Jan 17-19 44% 47 9
 
L. Is someone you can respect
2000 Jan 17-19 64% 31 5
 
M. Can keep up with changing times
2000 Jan 17-19 64% 27 9

Thinking about the following characteristics and qualities, please say whether you think it applies or doesn't apply to George W. Bush. How about ... [RANDOM ORDER]?

BASED ON -- 765 -- FORM A RESPONDENTS; ± 4 PCT PTS

  Applies Doesn't apply No opinion
A. Shares your values
2000 Jan 17-19 55% 32 13
 
1999 Sep 10-14 56% 34 10
1999 Mar 12-15 58% 31 11
 
B. Cares about the needs of people like you
2000 Jan 17-19 56% 33 11
 
1999 Sep 10-14 59% 32 9
1999 Mar 12-15 59% 32 9
 
C. Can manage the government effectively
2000 Jan 17-19 66% 22 12
 
1999 Sep 10-14 72% 19 9
1999 Mar 12-15 77% 15 8
 
D. Has strong moral character
2000 Jan 17-19 70% 17 13
 
E. Has vision for the country's future
2000 Jan 17-19 71% 20 9
 
F. Understands complex issues
2000 Jan 17-19 60% 26 14
 
G. Is a strong and decisive leader
2000 Jan 17-19 66% 24 10
 
H. Stands up for what he believes in
2000 Jan 17-19 79% 13 8
 
I. Has new ideas
2000 Jan 17-19 57% 28 15
 
J. Is likeable
2000 Jan 17-19 75% 19 6
 
K. Inspires confidence
2000 Jan 17-19 60% 29 11
 
L. Is someone you can respect
2000 Jan 17-19 73% 20 7
 
M. Can keep up with changing times
2000 Jan 17-19 70% 20 10

Next, please say whether you think Al Gore would do a good job or a poor job of dealing with each of the following issues. How about ... [RANDOM ORDER]?

BASED ON -- 731 -- FORM B RESPONDENTS; ± 4 PCT PTS

  Good job Poor job No opinion
A. The economy
2000 Jan 17-19 62% 29 9
 
1999 Sep 10-14 58% 32 10
 
B. Foreign affairs
2000 Jan 17-19 50% 36 14
 
1999 Sep 10-14 46% 41 13
 
C. The gun issue
2000 Jan 17-19 41% 41 18
 
1999 Sep 10-14 45% 40 15
 
D. The environment
2000 Jan 17-19 69% 20 11
 
1999 Sep 10-14 67% 24 9
 
E. Education
2000 Jan 17-19 73% 19 8
 
1999 Sep 10-14 67% 24 9
 
F. Taxes
2000 Jan 17-19 44% 45 11
 
1999 Sep 10-14 47% 41 12
 
G. Crime
2000 Jan 17-19 53% 35 12
 
1999 Sep 10-14 52% 37 11
 
H. Health care
2000 Jan 17-19 60% 30 10
 
1999 Sep 10-14 57% 32 11
 
I. Keeping the federal budget balanced
2000 Jan 17-19 52% 38 10
 
1999 Sep 10-14 50% 39 11
 
J. The problems of raising children in today's culture
2000 Jan 17-19 60% 30 10
 
1999 Sep 10-14 62% 28 10
 
K. Social Security and Medicare
2000 Jan 17-19 57% 32 11
 
1999 Sep 10-14 55% 35 10
 
L. Poverty and homelessness
2000 Jan 17-19 62% 28 10

Next, please say whether you think George W. Bush would do a good job or a poor job of dealing with each of the following issues. How about ... [RANDOM ORDER]?

BASED ON -- 731 -- FORM B RESPONDENTS; ± 4 PCT PTS

  Good job Poor job No opinion
A. The economy
2000 Jan 17-19 62% 26 12
 
1999 Sep 10-14 63% 22 15
 
B. Foreign affairs
2000 Jan 17-19 55% 28 17
 
1999 Sep 10-14 61% 22 17
 
C. The gun issue
2000 Jan 17-19 47% 34 19
 
1999 Sep 10-14 50% 32 18
 
D. The environment
2000 Jan 17-19 54% 32 14
 
1999 Sep 10-14 55% 29 16
 
E. Education
2000 Jan 17-19 70% 19 11
 
1999 Sep 10-14 70% 18 12
 
F. Taxes
2000 Jan 17-19 51% 35 14
 
1999 Sep 10-14 54% 30 16
 
G. Crime
2000 Jan 17-19 66% 21 13
 
1999 Sep 10-14 65% 20 15
 
H. Health care
2000 Jan 17-19 50% 34 16
 
1999 Sep 10-14 57% 26 17
 
I. Keeping the federal budget balanced
2000 Jan 17-19 60% 30 10
 
1999 Sep 10-14 56% 29 15
 
J. The problems of raising children in today's culture
2000 Jan 17-19 57% 28 15
 
1999 Sep 10-14 62% 23 15
 
K. Social Security and Medicare
2000 Jan 17-19 51% 35 14
 
1999 Sep 10-14 53% 29 18
 
L. Poverty and homelessness
2000 Jan 17-19 44% 43 13


Gallup https://news.gallup.com/poll/3316/presidential-race-leadership-appears-key.aspx
Gallup World Headquarters, 901 F Street, Washington, D.C., 20001, U.S.A
+1 202.715.3030