skip to main content

Optimism Soars Among Investors

by David W. Moore and Dennis Jacobe

GALLUP NEWS SERVICE

Investors are more optimistic now than they have been at any time in the past two and a half years, according to the latest PaineWebber/Gallup Index of Investor Optimism. Combined with today's record level of consumer confidence, February's record level of optimism among investors suggests that the economy, at least for the first half of 1999, may be stronger than generally expected. Investor optimism and consumer confidence have been driving forces behind the strong economic performance of recent years.

  • The Index now stands at 184, up from 147 last December.

  • The previous high was in March of last year, when it stood at 171.

  • The Index was standardized at 100 when it was instituted in October, 1996.

PaineWebber/Gallup Index of Invertor Optimism

  Overall Personal Economic Governmental
'99 Feb 184 110 76 -2
'98 Dec 147 108 56 -17
'98 Sep 158 104 63 -9
'98 Jun 162 105 71 -14
'98 Mar 171 104 73 -6
'97 Dec 126 103 62 -39
'97 Sep 141 101 62 -22
'97 Jun 119 104 57 -42
'97 Feb 87 97 43 -53
'96 Nov 95 99 40 -44
'96 Oct 100 95 41 -36

The Index consists of three dimensions -- optimism about one's personal situation, optimism about the economic conditions in the country, and optimism about the extent to which governmental policies are favorable to the investment climate. The largest increase is in the economic index, which stands at 76, up 20 points from last December and three points higher than the previous peak in March of last year.

The governmental index has also increased, from -17 (indicating more pessimism than optimism) to -2, a 15-point surge due mostly to greater optimism about a balanced budget and tax incentives for saving and investing.

Increased Optimism on the Economic Index limited to Next Year
The increase in the economic index comes from increased investor optimism about the next 12 months, with optimism about the next five to ten years remaining high but unchanged from last December. Investors are more optimistic about economic growth, inflation, and unemployment -- and about the performance of the financial markets -- in the next twelve months. They also expect somewhat higher returns over the next year than what they expected just two months ago.

When it comes to the long term (five years, and ten years), investors continue to be optimistic about economic growth and the performance of the financial markets, but not more than they were two months ago. Similarly, their optimism about the level of interest rates over the next year remains high, but unchanged from last December.

Higher Optimism on Governmental Dimension-A Surplus Budget and Proposals for Tax Incentives
The 15-point improvement in the governmental index comes from two of the three areas measured in this dimension: the federal budget and tax incentives for saving and investing. There was no significant improvement in optimism about the government's likelihood of dealing with Social Security and Medicare.

The declining pessimism about the federal budget perhaps reflects the announcement that not only would there be a budget surplus this year of about $70 billion, but that a surplus is likely to occur in the next several years as well. The net result of the surplus has been a flurry of speculation about which types of tax cuts might be enacted by Congress. Thus, it is not surprising that investor optimism has increased precisely in this segment of the Index.

Optimism Among Substantial and Average Investors
Overall optimism increased among both substantial investors (those with at least $100,000 of investable assets) and average investors (those with assets of $40,000 to less than $100,000), but the increase was much greater among the substantial than average investors. The overall Index is 230 for substantial investors, up 51 points from last December, the highest score for this group since inception of the Index in October, 1996. Among average investors, the Index has risen to 157, up 28 points from December but still 10 points lower than the high for this group in March of last year.

There is little difference in the increase between the average and substantial investors on the economic dimension, however, with a 23-point surge among substantial investors to an all-time high of 89, and an 18-point surge among average investors to 69. Substantial investors have higher increases on the personal and governmental dimensions than the average investors.

Optimism Among Male and Female Investors
Both male and female investors express higher optimism overall, with males showing an Index score of 187 -- just a point lower than their all-time high last March, and 28 points higher than December. Meanwhile, females score at 179, the highest score for them since the Index began and 50 points higher than two months ago.

Females show a particularly large increase in the economic dimension, going from 44 to 73 -- a 29-point increase. By comparison, males increased from 66 to 79, a 13-point increase over the past two months. Males and females show about the same level of increase on the governmental dimension.

Female Substantial Investors Show Greatest Increase in Optimism
Until this month, substantial female investors have trailed their male substantial investors in overall optimism for the life of the Index -- initially by just 5 points at the inception of the Index in October, 1996, but by as much as 42 points last March. However, that "gender gap" among substantial investors declined to just 14 points last December, as males scored 184 and females 170. And this month, substantial female investors score higher than males for the first time -- with a 233 overall index, compared to 228 for males.

The major reason for the higher overall score among substantial female than male investors is that females score much higher than males on the governmental index. Female investors score a +27, indicating much more optimism than pessimism. Male substantial investors, by contrast, score a -1, which is better than the -14 they scored last December, but still 28 points lower than females in the same investment category.

The difference in the scores on the governmental dimension comes from the higher optimism among female substantial investors on the issue of Social Security/Medicare. Both males and females show net optimism on tax incentives and on the federal budget, but men remain more pessimistic than optimistic on the likelihood that the federal government will address the problems of Social Security and Medicare. Women substantial investors, on the other hand, have moved from a net pessimism last December (49% pessimistic and just 27% optimistic) to a net optimism this month (only 33% pessimistic and now 41% optimistic). This represents a 30-point swing toward the optimistic end of the spectrum. Men also became less pessimistic, with a net swing of 12 points toward optimism, but that still left them with just 35% optimistic and 43% pessimistic.

These figures suggest that substantial female investors have responded more favorably than their male counterparts to the efforts by President Clinton and the Congress to confront the long-term problems of Social Security. Both parties have agreed that a major portion of the budget surplus will be devoted to helping the financial status of Social Security, though there remain some differences about how to address Medicare.

Investors Still Pessimistic on Social Security and Medicare
Average investors appear unfazed by recent events in Washington dealing with Social Security, as majorities of both men and women in this investment category are pessimistic rather than optimistic. The decline in their pessimism on the governmental index (12-point decline for men, 10 points for women) comes mostly from their more favorable views about the federal budget, and to a lesser extent from their more favorable views about tax incentives for investing. Pluralities of both males and females in this investment category are optimistic rather than pessimistic -- a turnaround from last December.

Index of Investor Optimism Trend Compared By Gender Of Investor Among Types Of Investors

A. Overall Index


  SUBSTANTIAL INVESTORS AVERAGE INVESTORS
  Male Female Male Female
'99 Feb 228 233 159 154
'98 Dec 184 170 142 113
'98 Sep 196 181 151 129
'98 Jun 201 193 156 128
'98 Mar 195 153 184 152
'97 Dec 180 140 137 71
'97 Sep 194 175 140 99
'97 Jun 150 133 143 69
'97 Feb 135 108 74 57
'96 Nov 133 116 90 64
'96 Oct 119 114 106 84

B. Personal Index


  SUBSTANTIAL INVESTORS AVERAGE INVESTORS
  Male Female Male Female
'99 Feb 138 120 98 96
'98 Dec 127 120 104 92
'98 Sep 119 116 105 88
'98 Jun 122 125 99 91
'98 Mar 129 100 103 89
'97 Dec 124 120 97 86
'97 Sep 128 115 92 89
'97 Jun 120 121 111 79
'97 Feb 122 109 83 84
'96 Nov 119 115 89 82
'96 Oct 112 119 87 86

C. Economic Index


  SUBSTANTIAL INVESTORS AVERAGE INVESTORS
  Male Female Male Female
'99 Feb 91 86 71 67
'98 Dec 71 55 60 40
'98 Sep 76 67 63 51
'98 Jun 83 78 74 57
'98 Mar 74 65 90 61
'97 Dec 86 64 65 42
'97 Sep 77 61 69 47
'97 Jun 67 60 70 34
'97 Feb 58 49 50 24
'96 Nov 59 44 42 29
'96 Oct 48 32 50 34

D. Governmental Index


  SUBSTANTIAL INVESTORS AVERAGE INVESTORS
  Male Female Male Female
'99 Feb -1 27 -10 -9
'98 Dec -14 -5 -22 -19
'98 Sep 1 -2 -17 -10
'98 Jun -4 -10 -17 -21
'98 Mar -8 -12 -9 2
'97 Dec -30 -44 -25 -57
'97 Sep -11 -1 -21 -37
'97 Jun -37 -48 -38 -44
'97 Feb -45 -50 -59 -51
'96 Nov -45 -43 -41 -47
'96 Oct -41 -37 -31 -34


Gallup https://news.gallup.com/poll/4039/optimism-soars-among-investors.aspx
Gallup World Headquarters, 901 F Street, Washington, D.C., 20001, U.S.A
+1 202.715.3030