skip to main content

Candidate Strategy in the GOP Race

As a social scientist, I've been very intrigued by the differing strategies taken by the Republican candidates. This provides a good test of whether unconventional approaches to winning a party's presidential nomination can work. The conventional approach, taken by the leading Democrats and Mitt Romney, is to focus much effort on the first two contests in Iowa and New Hampshire.

That makes sense from an historical perspective because, traditionally, the candidates who have swept those two states have been tough to beat. In fact, the only candidate who won Iowa and New Hampshire and didn't win the nomination in the primary era (beginning in 1972) was Edmund Muskie, and that was before the media paid a great deal of attention to the Iowa caucuses.

Putting aside the momentum that wins in those states can bring about, from a sheer numbers perspective, Iowa and New Hampshire should not be as decisive because they only provide the winner with a sliver of the delegates needed to win the nomination. But candidates have been reluctant to gamble that they can perform poorly in Iowa and New Hampshire but still be a factor in the nomination.

That is until 2008. Rudy Giuliani largely ignored Iowa and New Hampshire and is counting on strong showings in the big states with large numbers of delegates, such as Florida (Jan. 29) and California and New York (both Feb. 5). The reason his strategy is so risky is because the media cannot cover all of the candidates, and it is going to focus on the ones generating the most news, namely the Iowa and New Hampshire victors.

Giuliani certainly has taken some short-term hits because of his strategy, his national support has been cut in about half since December, and he has fallen from first place to vying with Romney for third place nationally behind McCain and Huckabee. There have also been reports of his campaign running out of money. But this strategy could work for Giuliani, given that he still has a high national profile, and he hasn't fallen so far behind the front-runners that the media still pay some attention to his campaign. A dark-horse candidate such as Mike Huckabee probably could not succeed with the Giuliani strategy.

Giuliani isn't the only Republican with a somewhat unconventional strategy. Huckabee concentrated on Iowa while not putting forth much effort in New Hampshire, and McCain concentrated on New Hampshire and focused little on Iowa. Both those gambles paid off for Huckabee and McCain with victories that gave their campaigns momentum, and they currently rate as the two GOP front-runners in national polls.

Fred Thompson also had an unusual strategy of largely bypassing Iowa and New Hampshire and staking his fortunes on a strong showing in South Carolina this weekend.

What this means is that whichever Republican wins the presidential nomination will do so with an unconventional campaign strategy. Even if Romney wins the nomination, it won't be because he succeeded in winning Iowa or New Hampshire, but came back to do better in later states.

Perhaps the only reason the unconventional strategies might work is that the GOP field is so wide open this year, with no dominant front-runner and each candidate having a strong appeal to a geographic or demographic slice of the GOP electorate. Had one of the GOP candidates campaigned hard in and won Iowa and New Hampshire on the way to winning the nomination, it would likely deter GOP presidential candidates in future elections from bypassing one or both of those states.


Gallup https://news.gallup.com/poll/103816/candidate-strategy-gop-race.aspx
Gallup World Headquarters, 901 F Street, Washington, D.C., 20001, U.S.A
+1 202.715.3030