skip to main content
Majority Support for Elian Raid Continues, Even Though Public Disapproves of Method

Majority Support for Elian Raid Continues, Even Though Public Disapproves of Method

GALLUP NEWS SERVICE

PRINCETON, NJ -- There has been little change over the past week in the American public's attitude towards the government raid on Saturday, April 22 that took Elian Gonzalez away from his relatives in Miami and returned him to his father. After having had a week to digest television, newspaper and magazine coverage of the raid, about six out of ten Americans continue to say they approve of the raid -- little changed from the results of two polls conducted last week. A little more than a third disapprove of the raid.

This overall majority approval does not mean, however, that the public approves of how the INS officials went about the raid. Fifty-three percent of Americans say they disapprove of the methods used by gun-bearing government agents who barged into the Miami residence where Elian was being kept (43% approve). In fact, when asked in a separate question to disregard the methods used to get Elian, the percentage of Americans who approve of the raid goes up to 68%.

Custody Versus Asylum Issues
There have been two concurrent themes that have played out in the Elian Gonzalez drama: one concerning a father's right to have custody of his child, and the other concerning the larger-scale issues of freedom-loving people attempting to seek refuge from a communist society.

The poll clearly shows that the public considers the custody of the child to be the more salient of these two factors:

  • Almost two-thirds of Americans say it is custody concerns that are the more important factor operating in this situation, not political asylum concerns "about whether Elian is better off growing up in a democratic country like the U.S. or better off returned to live under communism in Cuba."
  • In fact, when asked a very basic question about what should happen to Elian, 67% of Americans say he should return to Cuba to be with his father, compared to only 23% who say that he should remain in the U.S. with his relatives.

This does not mean that Americans hold positive attitudes about life in Cuba, however. Forty-five percent of Americans say that young six-year-old Elian's life would be worse in Cuba than it would be if he remains in the U.S., while just 18% say it would be better. Apparently the more generally negative environment that the public perceives to exist in communist Cuba is outweighed by its perception of the positive benefits of Elian being with his natural parent.

Congressional Hearings?
Republican members of Congress last week called for hearings to investigate the Justice Department's handling of the Gonzalez situation, including the government's use of force in the Miami raid. A majority of Americans continue to express no interest in such hearings: 54% say they disapprove of the idea, while 43% say they approve.

There are political differences in response to this question: About half of Republicans nationwide say they approve of the idea of hearings, which is significantly more than the 41% of independents and 37% of Democrats who approve.

Survey Methods
The results below are based on telephone interviews with a randomly selected national sample of 1,003 adults, 18 years and older, conducted April 28-30, 2000. For results based on this sample, one can say with 95 percent confidence that the maximum error attributable to sampling and other random effects is plus or minus 3 percentage points. In addition to sampling error, question wording and practical difficulties in conducting surveys can introduce error or bias into the findings of public opinion polls.

As you may know, federal agents physically removed Elian Gonzalez from the home of his Miami relatives on Saturday, April 22nd, and took him to Washington, D.C. to reunite him with his father. Do you approve or disapprove of that action?

BASED ON -- 530 -- NATIONAL ADULTS IN FORM A; +/- 5 PCT PTS

 

 

Approve

Disapprove

No opinion

       

2000 Apr 28-30

60%

36

4

       

2000 Apr 24^

60%

35

5

2000 Apr 22^

57%

37

6



^One-night poll

As you may know, federal agents physically removed Elian Gonzalez from the home of his Miami relatives on Saturday, April 22nd, and took him to Washington, D.C. where they turned him over to his father. Regardless of how you feel about the methods used, do you approve or disapprove of the Justice Department's decision to remove Elian Gonzalez from the Miami home and turn him over to his father?

BASED ON -- 473 -- NATIONAL ADULTS IN FORM B; +/- 5 PCT PTS

 

 

Approve

Disapprove

No opinion

       

2000 Apr 28-30

68%

28

4



Now thinking specifically about the methods the Justice Department used, do you approve or disapprove of the way in which the Justice Department removed Elian Gonzalez from the home of his Miami relatives?

BASED ON -- 473 -- NATIONAL ADULTS IN FORM B; +/- 5 PCT PTS

 

 

Approve

Disapprove

No opinion

       

2000 Apr 28-30

43%

53

4



Which factor do you think should be more important in determining whether Elian Gonzalez remains in the United States or returns to Cuba -- [ROTATE: Custody concerns about whether his father or Miami relatives would make the better guardian (or) political asylum concerns about whether Elian is better off growing up in a democratic country like the U.S. or better off returned to live under communism in Cuba]?

 

 

Custody concerns

Political asylum
concerns

SAME
(vol.)

No
opinion

         

2000 Apr 28-30

64%

26

2

8



What do you think should happen to Elian Gonzalez -- should he [ROTATE: Remain in the U.S. to live with the relatives who have requested he stay here (or) return to Cuba to live with his father, as his father has requested]?

 

 

Remain in U.S.

Return to Cuba

OTHER (vol.)

No
opinion

         

2000 Apr 28-30

23%

67

5

5



In the long run, if Elian Gonzalez is actually returned to Cuba, do you think his life there would be better than it would be if he remained in the United States, worse than if he remained in the United States, or about the same? (If better or worse: Do you think it would be much [better/worse] in Cuba, or just somewhat [better/worse]?)

 

Much better

11%

Somewhat better

7

About the same

26

Somewhat worse

19

Much worse

26

No opinion

11



Finally on this topic, as you may know, Congress is planning to hold hearings next week to investigate the Justice Department's removal of Elian Gonzalez from the Miami home. Do you approve or disapprove of these hearings?

 

 

Approve

Disapprove

No opinion

       

2000 Apr 28-30

43%

54

3



(vol.) Volunteered response


Gallup https://news.gallup.com/poll/2947/majority-support-elian-raid-continues-even-though-public-disappro.aspx
Gallup World Headquarters, 901 F Street, Washington, D.C., 20001, U.S.A
+1 202.715.3030