skip to main content
Republicans Were Under The Gun In Budget Negotiations

Republicans Were Under The Gun In Budget Negotiations

by David W. Moore

GALLUP NEWS SERVICE

PRINCETON, NJ -- The budget deal agreed to by the President and GOP leaders in Congress this week appears to have saved the Republicans from public disfavor. The latest Gallup poll, taken before the agreement was announced, shows that the public was ready to give equal credit to Clinton and the GOP for passage of a balanced budget bill, but would have blamed Republicans leaders more than Clinton if such a bill were not passed.

According to the poll, 43% of Americans felt most of the credit for passage of a budget bill should go to the President, while an equal number felt most of the credit should go to the Republican leaders in Congress. Had the two sides failed to reach an agreement, however, Americans would have blamed the Republicans more than the President, by a margin of 50% to 36%.

These views reflect Clinton's continuing popularity. He currently enjoys a 58% approval rating, about what it has been since the election last November. Clinton also enjoys an edge over Republican leaders in dealing with budget matters. By an 11-point margin, 49% to 38%, Americans say that when it comes to dealing with the tough choices involved both in cutting the deficit and maintaining needed federal programs, they prefer Clinton's approach to that of the Republicans.

In Congress, Democrats and Republicans Competitive
A major concern of both parties is what effect the budget package could have on next year's mid-term congressional elections. The poll shows that if the election were held today, and if all Americans voted, the Democrats would lead the Republicans by a six-point margin, 49% to 43%. Among registered voters, the margin declines to five points.

Experience has shown, however, that in mid-term elections, Democrats are less likely than Republicans to turn out to vote, and that Democrats typically need an advantage among registered voters of six percentage points or more if they are to gain the majority. Given the margin of error of this poll, the results suggest that at this time neither party has an electoral advantage.

When asked if the country would be better off if the Republicans or Democrats controlled Congress, Americans are ambivalent, choosing the Democrats by 39% to 37%, slightly less than a month ago when the Democrats led by 40% to 34%. In October, 1994, shortly before the Republican congressional victory, Americans leaned to the GOP by 42% to 39%.

METHODOLOGY
Throughout the hearing, President Clinton's job approval rating from the American public has remained in the upper fifties, including the most recent 58% rating. In late May, prior to the start of the hearings, his job rating was 57% -- suggesting that the slow trickle of news about foreign contributions and improper fundraising has had no major impact on his reputation.

One set of charges that the public does seem to believe are those against Democratic fundraiser and former Clinton Administration official, John Huang. Approximately six in ten Americans think Huang arranged illegal foreign contributions to the Democratic Party and passed confidential U.S. government information to China in 1996. However, the message from the poll, and from Clinton's stable approval ratings, seems to be that the public is not overly concerned with these violations.

Moreover, most Americans who believe Huang broke the law also believe that Clinton knew about it, representing about one in four Americans. Nevertheless a perhaps surprisingly large minority of this group, about 30%, still approve of the job Clinton is doing as president.

METHODOLOGY
The current results are based on telephone interviews with a randomly selected national sample of 1,004 adults, conducted July 25-27, 1997. For results based on a sample of this size, one can say with 95 percent confidence that the error attributable to sampling and other random effects could be plus or minus 3 percentage points. In addition to sampling error, question wording and practical difficulties in conducting surveys can introduce error or bias into the findings of public opinion polls.

Note: The first two questions were rotated, each following this introduction: As you may know, President Clinton and the Republican leaders in Congress are working out details of a new budget plan to make changes in taxes and spending which they say will balance the federal budget by the year 2002....

If a budget bill that accomplishes this is passed into law, who do you think will be more responsible for the fact that it becomes law: President Clinton - or - the Republican leaders in Congress? (ROTATED)

Credit? - Trend

May 6-7* July 25-27
Clinton 40% 43%
Republicans 44 43
Both equally (vol.) 6 8
Neither/other (vol.) 2 1
No opinion 8 5
___ ___
100% 100%
*"Who do you think ismostresponsible for reaching the budget agreement -- Bill Clinton or the Republicans in Congress?"


If a budget bill that accomplishes this is not passed into law, who do you think will be more responsible for the fact that it does not become law: President Clinton - or - the Republican leaders in Congress? (ROTATED)

Blame?(July 25-27)

Clinton 36%
Republicans 50
Both equally (vol.) 6
Neither/other (vol.) 2
No opinion 6
___
100%


Do you approve or disapprove of the way Bill Clinton is handling his job as president?

Clinton Job Approval - 1997 Trend

Approve Disapprove No opinion
1997 Jul 25-27 58% 34 8
1997 Jun 26-29 55% 36 9
1997 May 30-Jun 1 57% 35 8
1997 May 6-7 57% 35 8
1997 Apr 18-20 54% 37 9
1997 Mar 24-26 59% 35 6
1997 Feb 24-26 57% 33 10
1997 Jan 30-Feb 2 60% 31 9
1997 Jan 10-13 62% 31 7
1997 Jan 3-5 58% 35 7


When it comes to dealing with the tough choices involved both in cutting programs to reduce the budget deficit and still maintaining needed federal programs, whose approach do you prefer: the Republicans in Congress or President Clinton's?

Best for Tough Choices - Trend

GOP Clinton Neither (vol.) Both (vol.) No opinion
1997 Jul 25-27 38% 49 6 2 5
1995 Dec 15-18 38% 52 5 1 4
1995 Jul 7-9 48% 42 3 2 5


If the elections for Congress were being held today, which party's candidate would you vote for in your Congressional district: The Democratic Party's candidate - or - the Republican Party's candidate? (ROTATED) (Asked of those undecided) As of today, do you lean more to the Democratic Party's candidate - or - to the Republican Party's candidate? (ROTATED)

July 25-27

Dem Rep Undecided/ other (No. of intvs.)
Total 49% 43 8 (1004)
Registered voters 48% 43 9 (856)


Congress: Party Choice
(Special Selected Trend)

Dem Rep Undecided/ other
1996 Nov 3-4¨ 47% 48 5
1996 Nov 1-2¨ ¨ 50% 44 6
1996 Oct 30-31¨ ¨ 51% 44 5
1996 Oct 28-29¨ ¨ 48% 45 7
1996 Oct 26-27¨ ¨ 49% 44 7
1996 Oct 24-25¨ ¨ 51% 42 7
1996 Oct 22-23¨ ¨ 51% 42 7
1996 Oct 19-20¨ ¨ 52% 42 6
1996 Oct 11-12¨ ¨ 53% 41 6
1996 Oct 1-2¨ ¨ 51% 43 6
1996 Sep 20-22¨ ¨ 48% 45 7
1996 Sep 13-15¨ ¨ 52% 42 6
1996 Sep 6-8¨ ¨ 50% 40 10
1996 Aug 30-Sep 1** 51% 41 8
1996 Aug 16-18** 49% 45 6
1996 Aug 5-7** 48% 44 8
1996 Jul 18-21** 48% 44 8
1996 Jun 18-19** 50% 43 7
1996 May 28-29** 48% 46 6
1996 May 9-12** 51% 44 5
1996 Apr 9-10** 51% 45 4
1996 Feb 23-25** 48% 46 6
1996 Jan 12-15** 46% 47 7
1996 Jan 5-7** 44% 48 8
1995 Dec 15-18** 49% 43 8
1995 Nov 6-8** 47% 46 7
1995 Aug 28-30** 43% 47 10
1995 Jul 7-9** 46% 47 7
1995 Nov 2-6** 46% 46 8
¨ CLV=Cutoff-based Likely Voters
¨ ¨ PLV=Probability-based Likely Voters
** RV=Registered Voters


(Based on total sample) Do you think the country would be better off if the Republicans controlled Congress, or if the Democrats controlled Congress?

Who Control? - Trend

Reps Dems Neither (vol.) Same (vol.) No opinion
1997 Jul 25-27 37% 39 11 5 8
1997 Jun 26-29 34% 40 12 4 10
1996 Oct 26-29** 39% 42 7 2 10
1995 Dec 15-18 41% 41 8 2 8
1995 Mar 27-29 45% 33 10 4 8
1994 Oct 18-19 42% 39 10 2 7
** Likely voters


Gallup https://news.gallup.com/poll/4477/Republicans-Were-Under-Gun-Budget-Negotiations.aspx
Gallup World Headquarters, 901 F Street, Washington, D.C., 20001, U.S.A
+1 202.715.3030