skip to main content
Politics
Washington, D.C., New York Reach New Highs in Perceived Safety
Politics

Washington, D.C., New York Reach New Highs in Perceived Safety

Story Highlights

  • D.C. and New York reach their highest perceived safety ratings since 1990
  • Minneapolis and Seattle, once rated the most safe, are now at record lows
  • Partisan gap in D.C.’s safety has shrunk as Republicans’ views have improved

WASHINGTON, D.C. — Americans’ perception of Washington, D.C., as a safe place to live or visit has risen 12 percentage points since 2023, to 64%, the highest level in Gallup's trend dating back to 1990. New York City's rating is also at a new high, up six points to 47%, while Los Angeles (42%) and Miami (56%) essentially match their record highs from 2023.

###Embeddable###

Gallup has measured Americans’ perceptions of the safety of 14 cities eight times since 1990. Las Vegas and New Orleans were added in 2006, and each has three readings. The list includes six of the nation’s 10 most populous cities, as well as smaller cities that are important as tourist destinations or for economic or political reasons.

The latest findings are from an Oct. 1-19 Gallup poll, which finds perceptions of safety in Minneapolis and Seattle at their lowest levels since 1990, although majorities of Americans still consider both safe. Minneapolis’ rating has declined seven points since 2023, to 51%, while Seattle's 63% ties its previous low from 2023. Both cities were routinely perceived as safe by at least seven in 10 Americans between 1993 and 2006.

###Embeddable###

Of the two cities added to the list in 2006, Las Vegas’ 64% safety rating is higher than its prior readings of 58% and 61%. New Orleans' 47% rating is down from 55% in 2023 but remains well above its initial 28% reading in 2006.

 

Of the remaining eight cities, seven (Dallas, Boston, Houston, San Francisco, Chicago, Philadelphia and Detroit) are near their long-term averages, while Atlanta falls below its historical average.

The perceived safety of most of these eight cities peaked in the early-to-mid 2000s, when U.S. crime rates were well below 1990s levels. This period also followed the 9/11 attacks, which may have affected Americans' views of domestic crime or willingness to call cities unsafe. By Gallup’s 2026 reading, however, several of these cities were back down.

Chicago’s trajectory illustrates this pattern, with 26% rating it safe in 1990, rising to 53% in 2001 and 2004 before dropping to 27% in 2023. Chicago's current 39% is a 12-point improvement, matching Washington, D.C., for the biggest gain since 2023 — yet it still places second to last among the 16 cities, above only Detroit (31%).

###Embeddable###

Most Cities Rated Safer Than in 1990

Underscoring the general improvement in public perceptions of U.S. cities since the high-crime era of the 1990s, 12 of the 14 cities that Gallup has tracked since then are more likely to be considered safe today. The average share of Americans rating these cities as safe climbed from 39% in 1990 to 56% in 2001 and has stayed in the low-to-mid 50s since, averaging 53% this year. Majorities of Americans now consider eight of the 14 cities safe, up from five in 1990.

Minneapolis and Seattle are the exceptions to this long-term pattern. Both were highly regarded as safe in 1990 and ranked among the safest cities in every reading through 2006, but they have fallen below the top tier since 2023.

Some of the biggest improvements have occurred in cities that received the lowest ratings in 1990. New York’s rating has climbed from 11% to 47%, Washington’s from 22% to 64%, and Miami's from 17% to 56%.

###Embeddable###

Partisan Gaps Have Grown Much Wider Since 2006

In 1990 and 2006, Democrats' and Republicans' perceptions of city safety differed by no more than 11 percentage points for any of the cities Gallup measured. By the next reading in 2023, those differences had widened considerably. Democrats were more likely than Republicans to consider 15 of the 16 cities safe, with gaps of at least 25 points for 13 cities. The largest were for Los Angeles (53 points) and Seattle (50 points). Because Gallup did not measure city safety between 2006 and 2023, it is unclear when these partisan differences developed.

Large partisan gaps persist in 2026, with Democrats at least 40 points more likely than Republicans to consider six cities safe, including San Francisco, Seattle, New York and Minneapolis.

Washington is a notable exception. In 2023, 77% of Democrats and 29% of Republicans considered the nation's capital safe, a 48-point gap. Today, the gap has narrowed to just seven points, with 70% of Democrats and 63% of Republicans calling it safe. The change largely reflects a 34-point increase among Republicans, perhaps in response to the Trump administration's deployment of National Guard troops and federal law enforcement personnel to the city beginning in August 2025.

###Embeddable###

Bottom Line

Americans are more likely today than in 1990, but less likely than in 2006, to consider several major U.S. cities safe places to live or visit. Washington, D.C., and New York City now have their highest ratings in the three-and-a-half decades of Gallup's trends, while Los Angeles and Miami remain near their record highs. Minneapolis and Seattle buck the pattern, with both at their lowest ratings since 1990.

Some of the long-term improvement in perceptions of city safety parallels the steep national decline in violent crime during the 1990s. Since 2000, however, average safety ratings have changed little, even as violent crime has continued to decline.

Meanwhile, perceptions of city safety have become strongly divided along partisan lines. Washington is the biggest exception, with a sharp rise in Republicans' ratings nearly eliminating what had been a wide partisan gap in 2023. The broader pattern suggests that Americans' views of city safety may reflect political considerations as well as actual conditions, although the relative importance of these factors remains unclear.

To stay up to date with the latest insights and updates, follow @Gallup on X and Instagram.

Learn more about how the Gallup Poll Social Series works. View complete question responses and trends (PDF download).

###Embeddable###


Gallup https://news.gallup.com/poll/716798/washington-new-york-reach-new-highs-perceived-safety.aspx
Gallup World Headquarters, 901 F Street, Washington, D.C., 20001, U.S.A
+1 202.715.3030